Mario vs Sonic

Started by ScreamPaste8 pages

I'm not ignoring it, not that you haven't ignored a couple of my posts in this thread! >(

But yeah, no. The Flash is way faster than Sonic.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
I'm not ignoring it, not that you haven't ignored a couple of my posts in this thread! >(

But yeah, no. The Flash is way faster than Sonic.

Well then prove Mario can react to him. Once again Flash attacking Batman is like Sonic attacking Mario. Mario is no Deathstroke.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
I'd like to point out Mario survived galaxy wide catastrophe at the end of Mario Galaxy. -.o;
Bowser, Bowser Jr., their ship, Peach, her castle, as well as many nearby planetoids also survived the same event without so much as a scratch. It doesn't make sense to believe that all these things have galaxy-busting durability. Especially since we've consistently seen lava kill Mario and Bowser instantly.

And Sonic is not equal to the Flash. Flash is faster. Neither is Mario equal to Batman. Mario has strength that Batman lacks. Sonic could likely blitz Mario, but it isn't a stomp. Mario could land a punch or a fireball here or there. Eggman has done it.

I never said Flash=Sonic. Mario can't react to Sonic, saying he could is like saying Batman could react to Flash, and strength isn't going to help you react to either of them. That is my point.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
I never said Flash=Sonic. Mario can't react to Sonic, saying he could is like saying Batman could react to Flash, and strength isn't going to help you react to either of them. That is my point.
I understand your point. I was just pointing out that the comparison is flawed.

Eggman has hit Sonic, so while Sonic could likely outspeed Mario much of the time, Mario could land a hit every now and again. It isn't a stomp.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Well then prove Mario can react to him. Once again Flash attacking Batman is like Sonic attacking Mario. Mario is no Deathstroke.

Working with it a bit.

And no, it's not at all. Sonic is not close to the Flash in terms of speed. And we're still talking about Sonic physicly grabbign a hold of Mario, and throwing him. That takes much longer than a punch.

And where's the imaginary line in an undefined battlefield? It's not going to conveniently be a ten by ten circle to allow Sonic an easy win.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Working with it a bit.

And no, it's not at all. Sonic is not close to the Flash in terms of speed. And we're still talking about Sonic physicly grabbign a hold of Mario, and throwing him. That takes much longer than a punch.

And where's the imaginary line in an undefined battlefield? It's not going to conveniently be a ten by ten circle to allow Sonic an easy win.

See chili dog incident. You're basically saying Mario can punch faster than Sonic can run, and throw.

Originally posted by Acrosurge
I understand your point. I was just pointing out that the comparison is flawed.

Eggman has hit Sonic, so while Sonic could likely outspeed Mario much of the time, Mario could land a hit every now and again. It isn't a stomp.

Eggman has experience dealing with Sonic, and he is much smarter than Mario.

A chili dog doesn't actually fall very fast, at all. So that doesn't make Sonic any faster than he already was. -shrug-

I'm saying Mario can punch faster than Sonic can grab him, lift hhim, and throw him, yes. That'd take even Sonic a split second to do, atleast. All Mario really has to do is lash out in any random way he feels like. Say, spinning, or halting horizontal momentum with a ground pound.

Eggman's also in a lot worse physical shape than Mario. |: He's not even close to a peak human. If he can land a hit, ever, so can Mario.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Eggman's also in a lot worse physical shape than Mario. |: He's not even close to a peak human. If he can land a hit, ever, so can Mario.

You don't have to be in shape to operate a machine. Eggman has never physically touched Sonic with his own fists to my knowledge.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
A chili dog doesn't actually fall very fast, at all. So that doesn't make Sonic any faster than he already was. -shrug-

I'm saying Mario can punch faster than Sonic can grab him, lift hhim, and throw him, yes. That'd take even Sonic a split second to do, atleast. All Mario really has to do is lash out in any random way he feels like. Say, spinning, or halting horizontal momentum with a ground pound.

So you're an expert in the field of chili dogs? Once again prove Mario has that type of reaction skills.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Eggman's also in a lot worse physical shape than Mario. |: He's not even close to a peak human. If he can land a hit, ever, so can Mario.
True. We're not talking about intellect. Eggman's reflexes allowed him to tag Sonic, at least on occasion. Mario can do the same, preventing this from being a stomp.

IMO, Mario is the underdog here and Sonic's speed is a big hurdle, but with a couple of his powers, Mario could pull some wins. In a standard fight, Sonic would probably take a majority.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
You don't have to be in shape to operate a machine. Eggman has never physically touched Sonic with his own fists to my knowledge.
But he has stayed ahead of Sonic in a footrace in Sonic 3 and Knuckles and downright outran him in Sonic 2. That seems incredibly ridiculous, but there it is.

Hey, I like a good chili dog as much as anyone. @@; And seeing as I'm already hungry, this is cruel.

That said, chilidog's are not dense or heavy or particularly aero dynamic, they do not accellerate well through air and wouldn't fall as fast as say, a ball. o.O

brb, food. -.-

Merlina (Sonic and the Black Knight) also caught Sonic after he'd peeled out and held him immobile. Merlina has no superhuman reflexes. So why wouldn't Mario be able to land a punch every once in a while?

I brought this up earlier, but I'm not sure if anyone considered it a viable option. Would a Ground Pound by Mario be enough to make Sonic stumble? Sonic is quick on his feet, but a sudden tremor could likely throw him off.

I don't see why not. The first question is if Mario can generate a quake large enough to catch Sonic in its wake. When does he display this Ground Pound ability? The second question would be how long does it take to pull it off?

The earliest I remember Mario being able to perform any variation of ground pound was in SMW, with the cape power up. After taking flight, he was able to dive to the ground, causing the entire screen to shudder and making various enemies staggered. In later incarnations, he can just leap into the air and then flip once into a rump stomp, which I'm pretty sure caused tremors if he hit the ground instead of an enemy.

I'm hesitant to mention Mario's hammer, but it really has been a part of his arsenal for a quite a while now, and he could just as easily ground pound with it instead of his body.

Originally posted by XanatosForever
The earliest I remember Mario being able to perform any variation of ground pound was in SMW, with the cape power up. After taking flight, he was able to dive to the ground, causing the entire screen to shudder and making various enemies staggered. In later incarnations, he can just leap into the air and then flip once into a rump stomp, which I'm pretty sure caused tremors if he hit the ground instead of an enemy.

I'm hesitant to mention Mario's hammer, but it really has been a part of his arsenal for a quite a while now, and he could just as easily ground pound with it instead of his body.

I know a variation of the ground pound from New Super Mario Bros. I'll have to check to see if it causes a quake. I'm sure the "Cape Bomb" would knock Sonic off his feet. It might even damage him a bit; the dive bomb with the cape was a powerful move!