Hulcan vs. Superman

Started by -Pr-7 pages

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
I'll have to take your word for it, I have seen most of them as high and pretty impressive.

Well so far it doesnt seem to indicate that at all. Even another poster stated that Superman was the only one that didnt job in the JLA.

what superman comics are you reading? and what JLA are you comparing him to?

Originally posted by -Pr-
what superman comics are you reading?

Various. From 1991-2006.

Originally posted by -Pr-

and what JLA are you comparing him to?

From about 2000-2005

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Various. From 1991-2006.

From about 2000-2005

quite a broad spectrum there. have you read our worlds at war yet, or the rest of the impreriex saga?

Got a question, didnt they say that radiation along along with various forms of heat powered WWH?

Whats to stop the radiation from supes energy adding on to his dynamic abilities?

Originally posted by carver9
Got a question, didnt they say that radiation along along with various forms of heat powered WWH?

Whats to stop the radiation from supes energy adding on to his dynamic abilities?

what do you mean? his hv?

Originally posted by carver9
Got a question, didnt they say that radiation along along with various forms of heat powered WWH?

Whats to stop the radiation from supes energy adding on to his dynamic abilities?

huh? you think his HV will . . . empower hulk? or that just being NEAR superman would empower hulk?

never happened with sentry. ironman's blasts never empowered him. no way his HV would make hulk stronger.

Originally posted by -Pr-
quite a broad spectrum there. have you read our worlds at war yet, or the rest of the impreriex saga?

Nah not yet.. I was thinking of getting OWAW but people slag Leob off. I hate to admit it but hes quite a likeable character alot like Captain America with powers. It was actually the arc Time and Time again that made me like the character more. Hell hes such a nice guy even the dinosaurs liked him, for me that was more important than the power feats.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Nah not yet.. I was thinking of getting OWAW but people slag Leob off. I hate to admit it but hes quite a likeable character alot like Captain America with powers. It was actually the arc Time and Time again that made me like the character more. Hell hes such a nice guy even the dinosaurs liked him, for me that was more important than the power feats.

glad you're liking it.

the problem with loeb is that he used to be a very, very good writer. then his son died, and his talent seemed to go with it.

our worlds at war is simply one of the best superman stories ever written. the tpb is the size of a small phonebook, but even if you could dl it, its well worth the read.

through most of the 90s, superman is at a pretty standard level. he's good, he's superman, but he's never pushing for high herald status. then towards the end of the 90s and the early 00s, we start to see him getting written at a much higher level. guys like kelly, loeb, casey and chuck austen took over the books, and started writing a superman that was insanely powerful. you'll see it yourself when you get to that stage...

Originally posted by leonidas
meh, maybe. still, stone is stone. not sure why his healing wouldn't work. not like dormmy's stone was special i don't think . . .

Nah man stone aint stone. Thats like saying that Pyro can KO Hulk with flame after seeing Human Torch do it via supernova...you get the point.

Originally posted by leonidas

that's wwh. this version isn't only current, savage hulk. and not to long ago hulk had to have a piece of shrapnel removed from his head by apocalypse because he couldn't heal from it and it was interferring with his ability to think and his emotions.

Well I concede that if its not WWH it wont heal that qucikly however that showing contradicts the fact that his brain should have healed. If the rest of his body heals why wouldnt his brain. HF is for the whole body not just certain parts.

Originally posted by leonidas

the weird thing about gargoyle's attack though--it didn't even prevent BANNER from functioning. he was BANNER--not hulk--when he was changed to stone, and even as banner the change happened. that doesn't say much about the HULK's healing factor, if it was BANNER who changed in the first place. that whole story was . . . odd.

and its been said numerous times that Banner and Hulk are the same. Sorry not sure what your point is though.

Originally posted by leonidas

anyway, for your point to be true, we'd need to see a healing feat that would justify it, or need to see him recover from a similarly devastating brain trauma very quickly. we've seen shrapnel in his brain that he could NOT heal from (apoc removed it when he made him WAR), we've seen hulk rendered comatose by a far less potent attack to his brain (storm and cable). we've seen some GREAT healing feats, but nothing that would lead me to believe he could regenerate his brain nearly INSTANTLY.

Well I have one for WWH not others.

Originally posted by leonidas

there is also some evidence to suggest that hulk's power (namely emotion) does indeed stem from his brain--he has been calmed multiple times via mental powers.

Yeah but we agreed thats different to what were talking about.

Originally posted by leonidas

all those things taken together lead me to conclude that full-force HV (which has power enough to warm PLANETS!) fired through his eyes would certainly end this fight--at least long enough to score a ko for superman.

I concede for other version of the Hulk.