Originally posted by chomperx9
amazo has already copied supermans powers and many others. amazo murders her before she attempts to make a move.
Like I said before, if its rogue at her best she STOMPS amazo. If its normal classic rogue or current rogue then this is a none fight.
If op made this thread for it to be the rogue from extreme xmen, then theres no need for a sneak attack since she could EASILY just whip his ass without breaking a sweat.
Originally posted by carver9so rogue from extreme xmen can take out superman GL wonderwoman manhunter flash ?
Like I said before, if its rogue at her best she STOMPS amazo. If its normal classic rogue or current rogue then this is a none fight.If op made this thread for it to be the rogue from extreme xmen, then theres no need for a sneak attack since she could EASILY just whip his ass without breaking a sweat.
Originally posted by chomperx9
so rogue from extreme xmen can take out superman GL wonderwoman manhunter flash ?
Easily. I can list just a few of her powers that would take out the people that you named as a team.
*She has northstar powers (goes the speed of light)
*Hulk powers (high durability, amazing healing factor, Super strength that increase while mad).
*Storm powers (controls the weather)
*Magneto powers (Let me not even go here on his powers but his forcefield alone would cause trouble).
*Thor powers (she only possess his amazing strength and durability).
*Nightcrawler powers (This is the huge problem, teleport).
*Kitty pride (This completes it, I dont have to go any further)
Originally posted by The Nuul
Unless feats are put up, nope.
The series didnt go long but its kind of common sense that she could beat them since it was stated that she possessed all of these powers with the knowledge of how to use them. She doesnt need the feats to prove that her powerset should destroy this team.
If amazo didnt have the feats but he possess EVERY power of the jla member, would you think that martian manhunter could defeat him?
Originally posted by carver9
The series didnt go long but its kind of common sense that she could beat them since it was stated that she possessed all of these powers with the knowledge of how to use them. She doesnt need the feats to prove that her powerset should destroy this team.If amazo didnt have the feats but he possess EVERY power of the jla member, would you think that martian manhunter could defeat him?
Well, part of your argument is correct. But some of the abilities you stated are directly linked to the wielder's experience with them. Hulk's strength needs no introduction, sure, but something like Storm's weather control undoubtedly would. Even knowledge of how to use them isn't quite the same. BRB has knowledge of wielding his hammer, but we can't use Thor's feats for him. As comic readers, for another example, we have knowledge of how to use, say, Cyclops's abilities. That wouldn't make us as good with them as he is. Nearly any other character can apply to that example.
I'm intrigued by this debate, which I won't comment on because I didn't read the Rogue arc where she did all of this. But it wouldn't quite be like rolling all of those characters into one.
Originally posted by Digi
Well, part of your argument is correct. But some of the abilities you stated are directly linked to the wielder's experience with them. Hulk's strength needs no introduction, sure, but something like Storm's weather control undoubtedly would. Even knowledge of how to use them isn't quite the same. BRB has knowledge of wielding his hammer, but we can't use Thor's feats for him. As comic readers, for another example, we have knowledge of how to use, say, Cyclops's abilities. That wouldn't make us as good with them as he is. Nearly any other character can apply to that example.I'm intrigued by this debate, which I won't comment on because I didn't read the Rogue arc where she did all of this. But it wouldn't quite be like rolling all of those characters into one.
I agree with your post but theres one thing that helps my argument, she gains the memories of each person that she touch. So basically, every power that she has absorbed, she gains the memory of how to use them (which was also stated in xtreme xmen).
Now if she didnt have that ability, if she just went around touching people, taking there powers without having any knowledge, then your argument would be 100% precise but her powers work in more of an advanced way.
A good example of this is when she fought both the xmen and avengers teamed-up. She got there powers and used it just as good as they do/did and this was power that came to her in only that series. Rogue wins this in a stomp.
Originally posted by Survivor19
Since Rogue not only absorbs powers, but memories and experience and stuff as well...
If she absorbs there memories I'm pretty sure that would come with the experience part also. This has been said since the beginning of her appearance. A good example of this is when she absorbed Ms. Marvel powers and had to deal with all the memories of everything Ms. marvel had throughout rogue entire life.
Another example of this is when she touched gambit and broke up with him by seeing all of the horrible things that he did in the past.
She does not have sufficient power to deal with Amazo. You think Northstar's speed and Hulk's strength is going to take on someone with the combined powers of the JLA? There are 2 simple reasons why Amazo would take this every single time.
- The powers he has are far stronger.
- He has actually SHOWN that he can use his powers properly.
