what where the elves doing at helms deep??

Started by sammilicious4 pages

Halidar's death was a bit sad.. i had a bit of a teary moment in the cimena's.. like him and arogorn were mates..., but i also have a bit of a tear when the elves rocked up to Helm's deep... just kindof gave me hope that they all weren't gonna die real quickly.. i haven't gotten up to the bit in the book where he dies.. is it in the third book???

😕 I think it wuz just to introduce the ppl of Rohan into the picture🤨 ...plus, we hadnt gotten ne information of the gondorians (<---????) till later in the second movie😖mart:...i duno PJ thought it would b better!!! ✅ ✅ ✅

sammilicious, haldir dont appear in books after the original appearance in lothlorien... the moviemakers changed a lot of things

yea...he went off to the grey havens @ the beginning of the fellowship after helping frodo + sam + merry + pippin

i think that pj well his writers anyway who filled in the gaps did a fantastic job of sort of summerising each section so it was right for the movie

no bit went totally away from the book so as to ruin the book.

even though every little detail wasnt included he still captured the different moods tolkein was trying and did create. thats the main thingi

its alright for people to say which things were changed but theuy shouldnt say it ruined the movie and therefore pj did a bad job, sure its something to talk about but he had to change things so as to make it a good movie and no he didnt ruin any part of the movie by changing details from the books, the part with farimir is debatable but yeah

not on the topic-are most of the people in these countries from Europe or USA coz im typing at night then then the next day all replies are in the afternoon previously in my time

i need to no exactly wats happening here

lol yea the times are mad different...like it says its 5:03 am on ur last post..bt its 12:42pm here in the US...lol but yea i do agree...for not following the books ver batum..i still think it made for a pretty interesting movie. there still are some scenes that i wouldn't have minded seeing in the movies tho : /

billyboyd forever, merry and pippen didn't go to the west.. they both died in gondor, only frodo, bilbo, sam, gandalf, legalos and gimli pass to the grey havens

Tolkiens last battle agaisnt evil

I hope JRR Tolkien does not have acess to see the movie in Valinor, because maybe he will send all the Valar and Maiar to fight their last battle against Peter Jackson's cast.

😎

Originally posted by sammilicious
billyboyd forever, merry and pippen didn't go to the west.. they both died in gondor, only frodo, bilbo, sam, gandalf, legalos and gimli pass to the grey havens

um sweety woa youre really messed up there...1st of all i was talking about haldir who went to the grey havens, not merry + pip, and 2nd of all
Spoiler:
merry + pip DO NOT die in gondor, they go back to the shire!!!

ooh my bad.. whoopsies..totally misread that up there... but merry and pippen don't die in the shire.. they leave and do a bit of travelling and both of them are by theordin when he dies and they die soon after i think... well that's what it says in those huge are appendices at the end of the book.. man that was a read

yea, but i thought you meant they died in the battle of pelannor fields/the last battle, thats why i was confused, but yea i think youre rit w/the whole appendix thing...

Re: Tolkiens last battle agaisnt evil

Originally posted by Corlindel
I hope JRR Tolkien does not have acess to see the movie in Valinor, because maybe he will send all the Valar and Maiar to fight their last battle against Peter Jackson's cast.

*LOL*
But (I think) Tolkien was human, so nobody knows if he's really in Valinor...

The arrival of the elves was one of my favourite scenes, yet I think it's stupid;
Though there were still some hundred elves left in Middle-earth, they were far too weak to do something like that; while the earth dies, they're fading away, and usually fading people don't fight

Awww...Its Exa...way back when she was little...and so were her posts 😍 😊 😄

AWWWWWW 😆 😆
Owch, my posts back then were even more pointless than they're now 😑 if that's possible... omg, that must've been one of my very first posts here... not even a week after I registered touched

hyper N00000000b hyper *shouts at self*

Awwwww touched that's cute 😊

No...your posts arn't pointless...they're fun...

And you're an adorable Noob...not a stupid one 😱