Banning Fictional Rape

Started by BackFire7 pages
Originally posted by Robtard
Off topic, but there's supposedly a remake of 'I Spit...' happening.

Yeah, there is. Should be interesting.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
While we're at that topic, The Accused was pretty disturbing.

Indeed.

There are plenty of disturbing rape scenes, even some involving anal-rape as Irreversible, but none come close in portraying the act as Irreversible did.

Leaving Las Vegas and Boys Don't Cry spring to mind, both were sodomy and involved a vicious beating too.

Originally posted by Robtard
Indeed.

There are plenty of disturbing rape scenes, even some involving anal-rape as Irreversible, but none come close in portraying the act as Irreversible did.

Leaving Las Vegas and Boys Don't Cry spring to mind, both were sodomy and involved a vicious beating too.

I think Boys Don't Cry was a vaginal rape, but it was disturbing non the less.
She says that I think to the nasty sweating piece of lard, sheif.

Irreversible is deff number one for me. I hope I don't see anything that disturbing again.

And what was even more messed up is that it is shown in a matter that it makes sure you know that it could happen to anyone and at any time. Ugh, nasty.

In the real account, Brandon was anally raped (vaginally too) and the director went for that, though she had to change it for the theatrical release due to the MPAA rulings.

Uncut version includes both, iirc.

on the MPAA, and a total aside: Has anyone seen "this film is not yet rated"?

Originally posted by inimalist
on the MPAA, and a total aside: Has anyone seen "this film is not yet rated"?

Yes. Well done film.

wasn't it though?

the PI they hired reminded me of Kathy Bates, lol

Originally posted by Robtard
In the real account, Brandon was anally raped (vaginally too) and the director went for that, though she had to change it for the theatrical release due to the MPAA rulings.

Uncut version includes both, iirc.

I didn't know that. Must have seen the uncut version then.

Originally posted by inimalist
wasn't it though?

the PI they hired reminded me of Kathy Bates, lol

Shows you how political B.S. exist in the movie industry.

She did a bit.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
I didn't know that. Must have seen the uncut version then.

The director really wanted to include the anal-rape along with the vaginal because together, they depicted how Brandon was stripped of everything she viewed herself as.

Being raped vaginally obviously can only be done to a woman, then being raped anally is a form of degradation for a man; that's how she identified herself.

Aside from that fact that it happened that was in real life, though over a course of 10 hours, but that wouldn't be wise for a movie script.

Originally posted by Robtard
Shows you how political and BS even the movie industry is.

She did a bit.

The secrecy too, how hard it is to even know who is responsible for what, basically, we are allowed to see.

Really revealing, though, I can't imagine it changing until direct download becomes popular enough... or do places like netflicks host unrated movies?

EDIT: Not to diverge from the topic of rape or anything

Originally posted by inimalist
The secrecy too, how hard it is to even know who is responsible for what, basically, we are allowed to see.

Really revealing, though, I can't imagine it changing until direct download becomes popular enough... or do places like netflicks host unrated movies?

EDIT: Not to diverge from the topic of rape or anything

Netflix does offer unrated or director's cut version sometime, iirc.

Well, in a sense the viewer is being raped by the MPAA mod-like mentality. So I say you're on topic.

Originally posted by Robtard
The director really wanted to include the anal-rape along with the vaginal because together, they depicted how Brandon was stripped of everything she viewed herself as.

Being raped vaginally obviously can only be done to a woman, then being raped anally is a form of degradation for a man; that's how she identified herself.

Aside from that fact that it happened that was in real life, though over a course of 10 hours, but that wouldn't be wise for a movie script.

They raped him for 10 hours?!

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
They raped him for 10 hours?!

I still say "her", despite the boyish haircut and male attire, but yes, it was a 10 hour ordeal of rape and beating she endured, before they finally shot her.

So it didn't happen like it has in the movie? I thought she actually told the sheriff about the rape but was asked extreamely embarrassing and inappropriate questions?

Originally posted by BackFire
Clockwork Orange was definitely graphic for its day, even now, there is something about those scenes that still hold a great deal of power and are very disturbing. Thought I don't think it's quite at Irreversible's level.

Yeah I think there was only one actual rape scene. The one with the wife of the guy who was in the wheel chair later on. The other one wasn't really a rape, just a nasty beating.

Yup! only one scene which was enough to get the story in order. I don't know about levels of rape for movies but for my book Cannibal Holocaust had very most disgusting rape scene I can remember.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
So it didn't happen like it has in the movie? I thought she actually told the sheriff about the rape but was asked extreamely embarrassing and inappropriate questions?

I've only watched the movie once when it came out, so I don't recall clearly; I do believe they shot her after they took her back to the house and then learned that she was going to report it.

But this is a movie, so I'm sure certain facts where either left out or changed.

fictional rape is the best kind of rape.

And damn good too.

Originally posted by chithappens
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rapeman

sh*t, that's just disgusting.

as for a clockwork orange - there's the fight in the theatre over the nude woman and which group gets to rape her. that's why they go to the house with the wheelchair dude - because they didn't get the first girl.

and yeah, the murder of the feminist is [i think] supposed to be an intended rape - but then alex sees the giant dick sculpture and slams it down on her pelvis.

Originally posted by Robtard
I've only watched the movie once when it came out, so I don't recall clearly; I do believe they shot her after they took her back to the house and then learned that she was going to report it.

But this is a movie, so I'm sure certain facts where either left out or changed.

Did you happen to see Calvaire by any chance? The

Spoiler:
brutal anal gang rape of a guy

Messed up weird movie as well. Also revolting rape scene.