Thor (Classic) vs Hal Jordan · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

Starscream M Senior Member

Thor (Classic) vs Hal Jordan

Who wins?

SoulDevourer M0DERAT0R

lol
Hal
spite

batdude123 Fellow Tu Quoqumber

It's not spite.

Hal ftw.

Naija boy Senior Member

Thor.

The Nuul Senior Member

Current Hal?

Slaanesh The forces of Chaos

Hal..

kgkg Vigilante

Ahh I haven't posted this in so long.

For old times.

On a serious note Thor 6/10. Greater power output and ability to absorb vast amount of energy give him a minor edge.

The Nuul Senior Member

Thor

Raptor22 Senior Member

close fight but thor wins.

Warlord Yes, I am...

Thor drains the ring's energy ftw

Slaanesh The forces of Chaos

i don't think Thor can just drain the ring's energy..

Warlord Yes, I am...

Why not?

he can drain energies from suns and planets. He did it to the Presence.

Why not the ring?

Even if he can't suck it dry, he can lower the power supply

thanos-prime Senior Member

Thor

Prep-Man Senior Member

If it's CLASSIC Hal vs CLASSIC Thor, Hal wins. He has too many insane feats. Thor does, too, but Hal has it on a greater degree.

Now if it's CURRENT Hal vs Classic Thor, I'd give Thor a small majority.

Mindship Snap out of it.

Thor. As dependent as he is on his hammer for so much of his abilities, he's still a superphysical being, a god, without it. Hal is even more dependent on his ring, and w/o it he's just a man. Also, magic > oan energy (magic = ultimate plot device).

Overall a good/close fight, tho'.

Juntai Divine Vengeance

Originally posted by Mindship
Thor. As dependent as he is on his hammer for so much of his abilities, he's still a superphysical being, a god, without it. Hal is even more dependent on his ring, and w/o it he's just a man. Also, magic > oan energy (magic = ultimate plot device).
Overall a good/close fight, tho'.

The ring is equally as much of a plot device as magic in it's showings. It does ANYTHING he wills it.

Mindship Snap out of it.

Originally posted by Juntai
The ring is equally as much of a plot device as magic in it's showings. It does ANYTHING he wills it.

Yeah, I can't really argue with that. I guess the thing that always balanced it out for me was that the ring had to be recharged, it had definite limits in that vein.

DarkOdin Senior Member

Originally posted by Mindship
Thor. As dependent as he is on his hammer for so much of his abilities, he's still a superphysical being, a god, without it. Hal is even more dependent on his ring, and w/o it he's just a man. Also, magic > oan energy (magic = ultimate plot device).
Overall a good/close fight, tho'.

I woula agree and take it a step further. THe Hammer can absorb the energy of anything Hal use on Thor from energy blast to contructs even forcefields. Plus the ring would run out of juice on top of that.

Juntai Divine Vengeance

Originally posted by Mindship
Yeah, I can't really argue with that. I guess the thing that always balanced it out for me was that the ring had to be recharged, it had definite limits in that vein.

Most casters in this class have a limit before they burn out too. Does Thor? I dunno, I can't recall him whipping out powerful spell after spell after spell in rapid succession either. Usually he starts his uru tenderizer first.

Prep-Man Senior Member

Originally posted by Mindship
Thor. As dependent as he is on his hammer for so much of his abilities, he's still a superphysical being, a god, without it. Hal is even more dependent on his ring, and w/o it he's just a man. Also, magic > oan energy (magic = ultimate plot device).
Overall a good/close fight, tho'.

Ever heard of Wotan? High end mage that Hal has done well with. Among many others. Magic doesn't mean anything.