Dooku's Makashi vs. Mace Windu's Vaapad (Lightsaber Only)
In a battle of lightsaber dueling, who would win?
Personally, I think the match would be close, since Mace Windu doesn't have the chance to reflect Dooku's lightning with his Vaapad. Dooku has a lot more experience and precision, but Vaapad might physically overpower Makashi.
Originally posted by Anakin4Ever
Gosh, what's with you guys?
you made the rules yourself. Don't ask me whats with me: If they aren't using the force, Dooku doesn't have lightning, if they are using the force, Mace has Vapaad. If dooku has the force, and Mace doesn't, that's just stupid.
Be consistent.
Originally posted by truejedi
you made the rules yourself. Don't ask me whats with me: If they aren't using the force, Dooku doesn't have lightning, if they are using the force, Mace has Vapaad. If dooku has the force, and Mace doesn't, that's just stupid.Be consistent.
Quoted for Truth
Oh, and Mace wins either way.
Originally posted by HewhoknowsallActually, he blocked it. He didn't send it in any other direction.
Oh, and AOTC Kenobi effortlessly deflected Dooku's lightning.
Originally posted by Rampant oxOX!!!! WTF?!?! Where have you been???
Mace loses either way.
Originally posted by Darth Martin
Mace wins. Dooku may have an edge in Force powers but that's irrelevant here.
Originally posted by HellfireTerran
Mace Windu, he was one of the most powerful members in the Jedi order during the Clone Wars era. Dooku is nothing without his force powers. 😎
To both of you, Mace falls short in the sabers department to Dooku. And when speaking of being "powerful," that's usually in regards to force prowess, which, as was discussed a few times already, would not matter as force isn't allowed here. One is the ultimate refinement etc, the other is a form that's heavily based on the force (vaapad) which uses the darkside. That would be irrelevant here. Plus, Dooku's already beaten Mace. And without the force aide for his form, that puts him right back to where he was.