Superman vs Thor (Full-Potential Battle)

Originally posted by psycho gundam
aren't you two talking to eachother right now? just make a thread in the battlezone forum and post at leisure.

believe me, your battlezone will not be the cure to the superman/thor eternal war

Originally posted by darthgoober
I was missing for most of it, but I was still stopping in to check my PM's cause you said you'd let me know when you were ready. Anyway, if you ever DO get the guts to follow through with it just let me know...

Originally posted by darthgoober
I'm pretty sure he's the one that threw down the challenge a couple of months back, I was just letting him know that I'm still game.

And no, it probably wouldn't be much of of a challenge.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Ok, but I hadn't seen you at all. Your time will come.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Hahaha, this from the same guy who tried using crossovers against trick as legitimate proof.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Better than running from a battlezone like you did when I asked you if you wanted to do one. I am a doer while you are a talker. It's simple.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Well like I said last time, just let me know when you're ready.

😂 The crossover was valid proof per the rules of the match 😉 .

It reeked of desperation when the rules were set up heavily in your favor to begin with.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Don't take multiple months off and then resurface to complain about someone else getting me in a battlezone, brah.

Originally posted by quanchi112
It reeked of desperation when the rules were set up heavily in your favor to begin with.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Multiple months? It was just over a month and like I said, I was still checking my PM's for you to say that you were ready to go.

They weren't set up in my favor, Trick and I talked about them in detail before the match ever started. You're just pissed that I won my match against Trick and you lost your's against nvr(who's even worse) a month or so later.

With the stipulations you set it wasn't even arguing for a majority so who's to say you could have won the debate arguing for one. Crossovers, lol.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I don't recall seeing you for a while. You should have said something.

Originally posted by quanchi112
With the stipulations you set it wasn't even arguing for a majority so who's to say you could have won the debate arguing for one. Crossovers, lol.

Now point your anger about my win over Trick and your loss to nvr where it belongs, at the guy in the mirror.

Originally posted by darthgoober
You said you'd let me know when you were ready. Not that everyone(including me) didn't already know that you'd bail on the idea come October, I'm just pointing out that the onus was on you to make contact

Again, Trick and I talked about the stipulations in detail. He openly insulted anyone who didn't see DS easily taking 10/10 from Thanos so that's the stance I debated against. I didn't have an issue with him thinking that DS won. Valid evidence 😉 .

Now point your anger about my win over Trick and your loss to nvr where it belongs, at the guy in the mirror.

Pretty convenient to be lurking and to come out when the coast is clear.

Nver would never be foolish enough to take those stipulations. My battlezone and yours were completely different and you had easier stips than I did. One of the judges already admitted I lost before the match even began as his mind was made up.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I figured you weren't here because it was october and only resurfaced after you realized I was doing another one so you could save face.

Pretty convenient to be lurking and to come out when the coast is clear.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Nver would never be foolish enough to take those stipulations. My battlezone and yours were completely different and you had easier stips than I did. One of the judges already admitted I lost before the match even began as his mind was made up.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Nope, I just had better shit going on at home. Plus I was abiding by the whole "Don't be a pain" rule about BZ challenges. But we can kick the thing off right now if you want. You're online, I'm online, you've had months to gather scans for Thor and I had enough from Surfer to beat you when the challenge was first made so it's not like we need more prep time. You ready to step?

You had different stips and lost because your reach overextended your grasp, that's no one's fault but your own.

You debated for Thanos against DS?

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
You debated for Thanos against DS?

Originally posted by darthgoober
Nope, I just had better shit going on at home. Plus I was abiding by the whole "Don't be a pain" rule about BZ challenges. But we can kick the thing off right now if you want. You're online, I'm online, you've had months to gather scans for Thor and I had enough from Surfer to beat you when the challenge was first made so it's not like we need more prep time. You ready to step?

You had different stips and lost because your reach overextended your grasp, that's no one's fault but your own.

You are on the backburner Norrin. I got me eyes on Kal-dude not you at the moment.

Yes, you handicapped the stips and trick was foolish enough to accept. You think batdude would let me argue Thor wins 3-4 out of ten?

Not that I would let him.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Yeah. That was during the period that Trick and nvr were running around calling anyone who thought Thanos was even close to DS in power a fanboy so I called Trick on it.

I remember that fight.

The one that was predetermined due to everybody being fed up with Trick's flaming.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Yeah. That was during the period that Trick and nvr were running around calling anyone who thought Thanos was even close to DS in power a fanboy so I called Trick on it.

Hmmmm I think I remember this.. This was before Final Crisis even right? I do think its funny they were arguing that DS wins 10/10 against Thanos and wanted have a debate with that being the startng premise lol. I would also like to say... I knew I liked you Darth 😄

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I remember that fight.

The one that was predetermined due to everybody being fed up with Trick's flaming.

It was predetermined when Trick said anybody who thinks Thanos can win one fight is out of their mind.. LOL

Originally posted by quanchi112
After batdude. You should have pmed me.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You are on the backburner Norrin. I got me eyes on Kal-dude not you at the moment.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes, you handicapped the stips and trick was foolish enough to accept. You think batdude would let me argue Thor wins 3-4 out of ten?

Not that I would let him.

Anyway, the threads been derailed enough. Like I said I'll be waiting if you're ever ready to "man up". Just let me know when you're ready 🙂 .

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I remember that fight.

The one that was predetermined due to everybody being fed up with Trick's flaming.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Hmmmm I think I remember this.. This was before Final Crisis even right? I do think its funny they were arguing that DS wins 10/10 against Thanos and wanted have a debate with that being the startng premise lol. I would also like to say... I knew I liked you Darth 😄

And thanks, I try...

Originally posted by darthgoober
The onus was on you, not me. But if you STILL haven't built up the courage just let me know when you're ready. And don't blame your match with batdude, that's not till Feb. We could debate for months and you'd still have time to get ready for it.

And oddly enough, you need ANOTHER several months to get ready to defend Thor even though you were supposedly getting ready to defend him for a couple of months already 😂 .

It's wasn't handicapping, I challenged him to support the arguments he'd already made. Stop hating just cause I won and you lost.

Anyway, the threads been derailed enough. Like I said I'll be waiting if you're ever ready to "man up". Just let me know when you're ready 🙂 .

Oddly enough you wait into hiding the entire month we were supposed to do this and only resurfaced now when the coast was clear. 😂

I realize you won an easy battlezone and didn't even have the stones to argue a majority. You still went for crossovers which to me shows a sure lack of confidence on your part.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You had your chance but now you have to sit on the sidelines. I am a nice guy and I will give you your battlezone afterwards.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Oddly enough you wait into hiding the entire month we were supposed to do this and only resurfaced now when the coast was clear. 😂

Originally posted by darthgoober
I understand quan, you think that you're a better judge of Thor than BRB is and that you're opinion trumps what is said in the comic. Believe it if you want, like I said that's on you.

And? He was regarded as faster and more dangerous than he was in that amped state. If you can't connect the dots there, that's just another thing that'll have to be on you.

First answer the question. Was Thor's help a massively powerful Elder of the Universe while Surfer's was a bunch of guys like the FF and the Shiar?

Unquantifiable feat. Thor's ability to channel his own divine energy is evidently below his ability to absorb energy from outside sources, which means that we don't know how much energy that was.

Huh?

That Thor's help was powerful enough to give G a fight all by his lonesome, while Surfer's help was guys like the FF and the Shiar. The two encounters aren't comparable.

And my point is that just because Surfer's never put the total sum of his energy into a single blast and unleashed it against G after he'd just finished a battle with Ego doesn't prove that Thor's energy output is superior to Surfers.

Nope. Thor's hammer has absorbed a blast capable of wiping out a fifth of the universe before, so the amount of power it can channel from Thor is evidently different than it's ability to absorb energy from outside sources. Unless of course you think that Thor can channel more energy than is required to destroy a fifth of the universe, in which case I'll just leave you to your opinion and be done with it.

Well just let me know when you're ready...

Originally posted by quanchi112
Again, I am the reader so I have access to more information than a character in the story who just sees what he sees. He couldn't see the valykrie at the time Thor was speaking could he? I could. Do you get it now? I cannot believe I've had to waste this much time explaining something that's fairly obvious.

Since when has warrior madness amped your speed?

He was using his hammer which is more dangerous than just punching. If you'd read a lot of Thor you'd realize this and the fact the two fights were completely different based on how Thor actually fought.

Galactus wasn't even injured enough to feel pain by Ego. This is plain for anyone to see reading the comic so once again you;re caught exaggerating a "weakened" state. You just make random claims with no real knowledge of the story and when asked to back it up dodge the question. Just like the Thing example I am noticing a pattern here. You really just don't know.

Enough to chase Galactus off which is more than anything I can say for the Surfer against Galactus when in direct opposition.

You want to ignore the Galactus showing, the Exitar showing, the blood and thunder showing, etc. while you want to exaggerate an inconsistent blackhole blast. That's pretty much all you have done here.

Galactus hadn't even experienced pain in the Thor arc from anything Ego brought to the table while in the Galactus the devourer arc he was described as being extremely weakened.

We agree they aren't anywhere near comparable at all. Thor chased off a much more powerful version of Galactus who was hardly challenged if at all by Ego. I suspect you haven't read it.

Inconsistent writing. In one arc he can barely lift a building while in another he has the strength to shatter mountains. I mean read a couple of comics and you'll see many are inconsistent from one writer to the next.

Oh, I will.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I realize you won an easy battlezone and didn't even have the stones to argue a majority. You still went for crossovers which to me shows a sure lack of confidence on your part.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Still not confident in your abilities huh? That's ok just let me know when you're ready.

I wasn't hiding, I was waiting for word from you. Remember...

The crossover was valid evidence for the debate. Using it didn't show a lack of confidence, it was smart debating. Your inability to differentiate between those kinds of things may very be a factor in you being 0-1 against nvr.

I thought you agreed the crossover info didn't count during the debate. You would need to use something like that to get an extra leg up even in a debate where you aren't even arguing for the majority.

Wait on the sidelines, k.