Captain Marvel vs Beta Ray Bill

Started by carver96 pages

Bill 7/10. He's overrall more powerful than cap even though cap is one of my fav characters : (

Overall more powerful???

Originally posted by KingD19
Overall more powerful???

He has to know, cap is one of his fav characters after all. 😐

Originally posted by KingD19
Overall more powerful???

Yes, overrall more powerful. We are talking about a guy that defeated ego off pure power alone and put a dent in galactus hull.

I have to go with Beta Ray Bill 6/10 , Only because he has stormbreaker. But if he did not have his hammer Captain Marvel 6-7/10

Versatility is key here!

I'd say Cap's speed is the key advantage here. Cap takes a majority.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
I'd say Cap's speed is the key advantage here. Cap takes a majority.

Speed? Are we talking about the same bill that fought a light speed with Silver Surfer?

Are we talking about the same bill that punched a fernus wolf 8 times in one second?

How about the same bill that bull rushed star dust and him him a couple of times before she reacted?

Originally posted by carver9
Speed? Are we talking about the same bill that fought a light speed with Silver Surfer?

Are we talking about the same bill that punched a fernus wolf 8 times in one second?

How about the same bill that bull rushed star dust and him him a couple of times before she reacted?


I suppose we are, we're also talking about the Captain Marvel that has FTL feats. Punching something 8 times in a second honestly isn't the least bit impressive. I'm pretty sure Spider-Man could manage that if he used both hands.

so close..
Goin with Marvel cause he isn't weak to magic. Slight majority.

Marvel 5.5/10

Originally posted by Omega Vision
I suppose we are, we're also talking about the Captain Marvel that has FTL feats. Punching something 8 times in a second honestly isn't the least bit impressive. I'm pretty sure Spider-Man could manage that if he used both hands.

IF cap wins and this is a HUGE if, its not because of speed. Beta ray bill have PLENTY of blitzes under his belt to make me realize that he is on caps level of speed.

I cant argue with cap having faster then light speed because he has the feats to back it up (on panel statements) but so does brb.

BRB has the energy manipulation and versatility to give CM a run for his money, but CM has always shown to be durable as heck.

First of all. It's not a huge IF when Captain wins. He has the speed, strength, and durability to hang with Superman. Except, he even has the resistance against Magic. So it is CM who actually has the advantage here, not BRB.

strength = tie
speed = tie
durability = tie
control of magic lightning = tie
energy/matter manip. = BRB

BRB 5.5/ or 6/10

Originally posted by TheKahn
strength = tie
speed = tie
durability = tie
control of magic lightning = tie
energy/matter manip. = BRB

BRB 5.5/ or 6/10

I go with

control of magic lightning - BRB (slight edge)
durability -Captain Marvel
speed - Captain Marvel

Originally posted by xJLxKing
First of all. It's not a huge IF when Captain wins. He has the speed, strength, and durability to hang with Superman. Except, he even has the resistance against Magic. So it is CM who actually has the advantage here, not BRB.

What does captain marvel having the ability to hang with Supes have ANYTHING to do with this thread.

Durability: HHHMMM, BRB survived unharmed and unfazed a sun going super nova. He also survived a crush clap by galactus without a scratch on him. He also survived without a scratch a planet exploding right in his face without a scratch. He also took hits from asteroth and beat her, and she is a universal threat.

Speed: Him keeping up with the surfer is pretty much solid evidence that he is either on or above cap in the speed dept.

Strength: His one strength feat of destroying 2 planet PHYSICALLY is>>Anything captain marvel has done.

Out put of power: Beta ray bill>>>Captain marvel. This is the same guy that blew a hole in the hull of galactus ship and beat ego off pure power alone.

Versatility: Beta ray bill>>>Captain marvel.

If anyone is winning this fight, its going to be brb.

Originally posted by carver9
What does captain marvel having the ability to hang with Supes have ANYTHING to do with this thread.

Durability: HHHMMM, BRB survived unharmed and unfazed a sun going super nova. He also survived a crush clap by galactus without a scratch on him. He also survived without a scratch a planet exploding right in his face without a scratch. He also took hits from asteroth and beat her, and she is a universal threat.

Speed: Him keeping up with the surfer is pretty much solid evidence that he is either on or above cap in the speed dept.

Strength: His one strength feat of destroying 2 planet PHYSICALLY is>>Anything captain marvel has done.

Out put of power: Beta ray bill>>>Captain marvel. This is the same guy that blew a hole in the hull of galactus ship and beat ego off pure power alone.

Versatility: Beta ray bill>>>Captain marvel.

If anyone is winning this fight, its going to be brb.

you were told to stop.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
I go with

control of magic lightning - BRB (slight edge)
durability -Captain Marvel
speed - Captain Marvel

Meh...its always hard for me to compare the strength, durability, and speed of cosmic/herald level characters like Superman, Thor, BRB, CM, WW, etc. given all of their impressive feats. So I just assume that they are close enough that it wouldn't determine the fight. Just my opinion though. 🙂

Originally posted by -Pr-
you were told to stop.

I didnt do anything. Would you like for me to provide scans?

What does captain marvel having the ability to hang with Supes have ANYTHING to do with this thread.

It shows that he is no pushover. It shows just how ridiculous your comment about CM winning is a big IF.

Durability: HHHMMM, BRB survived unharmed and unfazed a sun going super nova. He also survived a crush clap by galactus without a scratch on him. He also survived without a scratch a planet exploding right in his face without a scratch. He also took hits from asteroth and beat her, and she is a universal threat.

Batdude, PR and a few others already proved that ridiculous crap that your try and bring up. Post them scan again, and I'll prove your wrong myself.

Speed: Him keeping up with the surfer is pretty much solid evidence that he is either on or above cap in the speed dept.

That's your opinion

Strength: His one strength feat of destroying 2 planet PHYSICALLY is>>Anything captain marvel has done.

Fact is, no matter how many feats BRB has, I still haven't seen him beat anyone his level.

Out put of power: Beta ray bill>>>Captain marvel. This is the same guy that blew a hole in the hull of galactus ship and beat ego off pure power alone.

😂 okay, how strong is the armor of Galactus them?

Originally posted by carver9
I didnt do anything. Would you like for me to provide scans?

the scans of the supernova were proven wrong by several people. you know this, as iirc, you made the thread, or at the very least were heavily involved with it.

using ambiguous scans is one thing, but claiming that scans that are pretty straight forward are somehow something that they're not IS considered trolling on this board.