Captain Marvel vs Beta Ray Bill

Started by carver96 pages

Originally posted by -Pr-
the scans of the supernova were proven wrong by several people. you know this, as iirc, you made the thread, or at the very least were heavily involved with it.

using ambiguous scans is one thing, but claiming that scans that are pretty straight forward are somehow something that they're not IS considered trolling on this board.

Well Ill stop

Originally posted by xJLxKing
It shows that he is no pushover. It shows just how ridiculous your comment about CM winning is a big IF.

Batdude, PR and a few others already proved that ridiculous crap that your try and bring up. Post them scan again, and I'll prove your wrong myself.

That's your opinion

Fact is, no matter how many feats BRB has, I still haven't seen him beat anyone his level.

😂 okay, how strong is the armor of Galactus them?

http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/9578/stormbreaker0121vw9.jpg
http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/3760/stormbreaker0122cz1.jpg

http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/4829/stormbreaker41415fl8.jpg
http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/1236/stormbreaker41617ln0.jpg
http://img143.imageshack.us/img143/5586/stormbreaker418jo7.jpg

Originally posted by carver9
http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/9578/stormbreaker0121vw9.jpg
http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/3760/stormbreaker0122cz1.jpg

http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/4829/stormbreaker41415fl8.jpg
http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/1236/stormbreaker41617ln0.jpg
http://img143.imageshack.us/img143/5586/stormbreaker418jo7.jpg

What exactly is that suppose to prove?

http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/...aker0121vw9.jpg http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/...aker0122cz1.jpg

How is this impressive? What you proved was that apparently, a small smack from Galactus will KO BRB

http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/...ker41415fl8.jpg http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/...ker41617ln0.jpg http://img143.imageshack.us/img143/...eaker418jo7.jpg

I don't know what makes you think that blast was strong enough to destroy 2 planets. Also, BRB didn't even take the hit. He was behind the guy who took the hit. Two different things

Originally posted by TheKahn
What exactly is that suppose to prove?

He survives a thunder clap from GALACTUS and hes ok from a planet blowing up on him. 😕

Someone said that Cap is more durable than him when going by feats, brb durability>Caps.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
How is this impressive? What you proved was that apparently, a small smack from Galactus will KO BRB

I don't know what makes you think that blast was strong enough to destroy 2 planets. Also, BRB didn't even take the hit. He was behind the guy who took the hit. Two different things

LOL, so it was a small smack, a lick that lit up a small part of space. 😕 and it was from galactus.

What blast? What are you talking about? That was a planet being blown up and bill was in the middle of the explosion.

Originally posted by carver9
He survives a thunder clap from GALACTUS and hes ok from a planet blowing up on him. 😕

Someone said that Cap is more durable than him when going by feats, brb durability>Caps.


1- He was KOed from the smack from Galactus, nothing impressive. It's a low feat actually

2- It wasn't a planet exploding attack on him. His opponent was in front of him. He took most of the damage for him

Originally posted by carver9
He survives a thunder clap from GALACTUS and hes ok from a planet blowing up on him. 😕

Someone said that Cap is more durable than him when going by feats, brb durability>Caps.

Its impossible to quantify how hard Galactus hit him. All we do know is that it was enough to put BRB down. Thus its practically useless feat unless you can quantify it, imo. 😬

Originally posted by xJLxKing
1- He was KOed from the smack from Galactus, nothing impressive. It's a low feat actually

2- It wasn't a planet exploding attack on him. His opponent was in front of him. He took most of the damage for him

LOL, a crush from galactus>>>>>>>>>>>>captain marvel punches.

So if a planet blew up and I stood in front of you, youre not going to feel it? 😕

I dont care if someone is in front of you, behind you, beside you, across from you, etc.... If a planet blow up, you are going to feel EVERY piece of the blast.

Originally posted by TheKahn
Its impossible to quantify how [b]hard Galactus hit him. All we do know is that it was enough to put BRB down. Thus its practically useless feat unless you can quantify it, imo. 😬 [/B]

So galactus extending his arms and bringing them together isnt a indication of galactus putting power behind that smack? Then it lit up the sky.

Originally posted by carver9
LOL, a crush from galactus>>>>>>>>>>>>captain marvel punches.

Not necessarily. We don't know how much effort if any Galactus was putting in. You agree that if he didn't see BRB as a threat he wouldn't even go close to all out right?

LOL, a crush from galactus>>>>>>>>>>>>captain marvel punches.

Why? how strong is the smack?

It's a useless feat for BRB, it's nice for Galactus, get it?

So if a planet blew up and I stood in front of you, youre not going to feel it? I dont care if someone is in front of you, behind you, beside you, across from you, etc.... If a planet blow up, you are going to feel EVERY piece of the blast.
I am talking about the hit that caused the explosion.

Originally posted by carver9
So galactus extending his arms and bringing them together isnt a indication of galactus putting power behind that smack? Then it lit up the sky.

But you or I don't know how hard the hit was. Could Spiderman have survived it? Wolverine? Colossus? Thing? Firelord? and on and on. Was it like getting hit by a train, or a asteroid, or a planet? We simply don't know so its hard to use it as a feat in a debate.

Speed will probably not be the deciding factor here; however, I don't see BRB's versatility being that effective against CM either. On the strength/durability issue: BRB has MASSIVE damage-output —_at least as good as CM and maybe better. However, despite what some have said, I don't think he has the same durability at all. He has been taken down hard by Surfer, the Galactus clap, and was one-shotted by DP tyrant (though, admittedly, DP Tyrant was one of the strongest hand-to-hand fighters in Marvel). After a very long battle, I think Marvel's durability will win out.

CM 6/10

Originally posted by Simbon
Speed will probably not be the deciding factor here; however, I don't see BRB's versatility being that effective against CM either. On the strength/durability issue: BRB has MASSIVE damage-output —_at least as good as CM and maybe better. However, despite what some have said, I don't think he has the same durability at all. He has been taken down hard by Surfer, the Galactus clap, and was one-shotted by DP tyrant (though, admittedly, DP Tyrant was one of the strongest hand-to-hand fighters in Marvel). After a very long battle, I think Marvel's durability will win out.

CM 6/10

agree

Marvel wins 7/10, while Bill may be powerful his still no thor.

Marvel slight majority

brb 10/10

Marvel for the majority.

Originally posted by TheKahn
But you or I don't know how [b]hard the hit was. Could Spiderman have survived it? Wolverine? Colossus? Thing? Firelord? and on and on. Was it like getting hit by a train, or a asteroid, or a planet? We simply don't know so its hard to use it as a feat in a debate. [/B]

That argument can be applied to -anything- and going by your logic anything without specific numbers or hyperbole behind it would be inadmissible as feats. While Carver's own faulty logic, that since A knocked out B, anything less than B could not knock out A is just plain crap, yours is not exactly bulletproof. When a character like Galactus exerts any kind of pressure against an opponent, we know that it's often worthwhile. Remember how difficult is usaully is to simply get Galactus' notice? Often, outside of bullshit, he barely even acknowledges heroes.

The attack was sufficient to put BRB in his place, which a planetary attack has been incapable of. Surely it would not be very smart to claim that nothing short of these attacks would work, but it's not like we're going to simply ignore the attack by Galactus. Also, who is to say that Captain Marvel only has one attack? It's not as if he'll only hit BRB once and if that doesn't fall through, he'll quit. Fights like these would have numerous punches exchanged.