Spider-Man vs Midnighter

Started by Starscream M4 pages

Spider-Man vs Midnighter

Who wins?

Fight in an urban setting.

Good match, I'd want to say Spiderman for the slight majority. It really just depends on the style and setting on the fighting. MN'ers calculation helps against Spiderman's movements, but Spidey's precog helps him to stay ahead. Spiderman has a few other abilities as well.

I want to say Spiderman 5.5/10, but some may or may not agree. When is that new? This has been done before too.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
Good match, I'd want to say Spiderman for the slight majority. It really just depends on the style and setting on the fighting. MN'ers calculation helps against Spiderman's movements, but Spidey's precog helps him to stay ahead. Spiderman has a few other abilities as well.

I want to say Spiderman 5.5/10, but some may or may not agree. When is that new? This has been done before too.

You bring up some good points. Its basically a form of precog vs a different form of precog. Still, I'd give the slight edge to Midnighter just based on fighting skills and sheer ruthlessness.

Originally posted by TheKahn
You bring up some good points. Its basically a form of precog vs a different form of precog. Still, I'd give the slight edge to Midnighter just based on fighting skills and sheer ruthlessness.

Probably so, but he doesn't have higher damage output. Maybe it is an even split though.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
Probably so, but he doesn't have higher damage output. Maybe it is an even split though.
actually he does.

he kicked a tank shell....that would shatter spiderman's legs if spiderman tried it

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
Probably so, but he doesn't have higher damage output. Maybe it is an even split though.

Not too sure about that...

*not for the faint of heart!!!!*

http://img369.imageshack.us/i/n23op4.jpg/
http://img513.imageshack.us/i/m17xa6.jpg/
and my personal favorite
http://img523.imageshack.us/i/spineyw8.jpg/

😉

I'm about to look, but I'm at work, is that when he kicks someone's head off? I've seen that, Spidey can do that too. If I'm wrong, then give me a second.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
I'm about to look, but I'm at work, is that when he kicks someone's head off? I've seen that, Spidey can do that too. If I'm wrong, then give me a second.

In order its
punch through a face
deadly nerve strike
and spine removal ala Mortal Kombat

Spiderman could likely accomplish 1 and 3 but if they are fighting in character (I didn't see where they were bloodlusted) he wouldn't go for the kill. Midnighter is a different story... 😈

the only thing spiderman can't replicate is the tank shell kick

Originally posted by Starscream M
actually he does.

he kicked a tank shell....that would shatter spiderman's legs if spiderman tried it

no he doesent. it called pis my friend. One time feats are not usable........

Originally posted by TheKahn
Not too sure about that...

*not for the faint of heart!!!!*

http://img369.imageshack.us/i/n23op4.jpg/
http://img513.imageshack.us/i/m17xa6.jpg/
and my personal favorite
http://img523.imageshack.us/i/spineyw8.jpg/

😉

That's not even close to what Spiderman could do, he could probably perform all those feats with only using a 3rd of his strength.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
no he doesent. it called pis my friend. One time feats are not usable........
you misunderstand the meaning of pis

just because something happens once doesn't make it PIS...for example, if wolverine only decapitates once, its not pis.

its only pis if the event contradicts prior characterizations

midnighter kicking a tank shell does not contradict his prior showings.

It has nothing to do with physical capability, I wouldn't say he has the higher maximum output, just that he's willing to kill, the idea is to do just enough to incapacitate. Something he can do. I'd say about even.

Originally posted by Starscream M
actually he does.

he kicked a tank shell....that would shatter spiderman's legs if spiderman tried it

Actually, he doesn't.

Originally posted by Starscream M
you misunderstand the meaning of pis

just because something happens once doesn't make it PIS...for example, if wolverine only decapitates once, its not pis.

its only pis if the event contradicts prior characterizations

midnighter kicking a tank shell does not contradict his prior showings.


No I understand it perfectly.

True, but if the individual never display that type of power/strength again that is infact pis. Midnighters never shown that type of power out put asside from that single event which makes it pis.

It does contrict it. He never been display as that strong. He only slightly within superhuman range, that feat puts him vastly into it, which infact makes it pis.

yes it does, he never display that type of power or closes to it since or before that, it is infact pis.

Originally posted by Mindset
That's not even close to what Spiderman could do, he could probably perform all those feats with only using a 3rd of his strength.

I know, hence...

Originally posted by TheKahn
In order its
punch through a face
deadly nerve strike
and spine removal ala Mortal Kombat

Spiderman could likely accomplish 1 and 3 but if they are fighting in character (I didn't see where they were bloodlusted) he wouldn't go for the kill. Midnighter is a different story... 😈

I didn't post them to argue Midnighter was stronger than Spiderman (I don't think he is) but to show that he had sufficient damage capacity to make this an interesting fight.

Midnighter is not even closes to Spidermans strength.

People realize people with Wolverine strength can kick punch hole in people, crush skulls ect.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
No I understand it perfectly.

True, but if the individual never display that type of power/strength again that is infact pis. Midnighters never shown that type of power out put asside from that single event which makes it pis.

It does contrict it. He never been display as that strong. He only slightly within superhuman range, that feat puts him vastly into it, which infact makes it pis.

yes it does, he never display that type of power or closes to it since or before that, it is infact pis.

umm...I love your ignorance

you've prob never read even one midnighter comic

he has shown similar strength feats

he has hurt a superman level character with a hit

he has ripped a human's spinal cord out.

read a goddamn comic.

You seemed indecisive to whether or not Spiderman could output more damage, or if he would be able to replicate those feats.

I'm telling you Spiderman definitely could.