Scimitar vs Executor

One of the most powerful Star Trek ships vs one of the most powerful warships in the Empire. Who wins?

Can someone provide some details on the Scimitar? Preferably before this is closed.

Scimitar:

Length: 890 meters
Beam: 1350 meters
Speed: At least Warp 9.7
Armament: 52 pulse disruptor cannons;
27 photon torpedo launchers;
thalaron radiation emitters
Defenses: Primary and secondary shields;
*advanced cloaking device (considered "perfect"😉

Doing 40 seconds of research I came to this conclusion:

Worf (I think) said that it would take the entire payload of photon torpedoes on the Enterprise to destroy an asteroid (of unknown size to me). 250 photon torpedoes on board.

Imperial-class Destroyers were blasting asteroids apart like burst bubbles. In some comic I think it was, three ISSs emerged from hyperspace and slammed right in to the Executor. They were all vaporized.

...

Yeah.

...thats one helluva ship 😛

Yeah, Executor wins. The Scimatar was definitely one of the most dangerous ships in Trekverse, but wouldn't be able to stand up against the firepower of the Executor.

Sorry, 'Scimitar', not 'Scimatar'.

Doing 10 seconds of research, all based off of luciens post,

Executor FTW

Hit up stardestroyer.net

Star Wars ships RAPE all Star Trek ones.

Definetly Executor

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Doing 40 seconds of research I came to this conclusion:

Worf (I think) said that it would take the entire payload of photon torpedoes on the Enterprise to destroy an asteroid (of unknown size to me). 250 photon torpedoes on board.

Imperial-class Destroyers were blasting asteroids apart like burst bubbles. In some comic I think it was, three ISSs emerged from hyperspace and slammed right in to the Executor. They were all vaporized.

...

Yeah.

Well whatever the writer's reasons for giving that bit of information, it holds.

I'm going with Trek here. This is the Romulan win button, isn't it? The one where their missiles killed time or something? This word was the reason I gave up the thread in the Trek forum.

Yeah. The Executor is outranged, outgunned (?) and outmaneuvered. 😬

That ship can do THAT? Well f*ck that then. A ship that can kill time beats everything.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
I'm going with Trek here. This is the Romulan win button, isn't it? The one where their missiles killed time or something? This word was the reason I gave up the thread in the Trek forum.

Yeah. The Executor is outranged, outgunned (?) and outmaneuvered. 😬

Out ranged yes. But I think you're thinking of the Krenim timeship. The Scimitar is the one with the radiation weapon that can wipe out planets but it takes 7 minutes to deploy it.

I think the Executor has enough turbolasers to blast out in all directions to get a hit on the cloak/shields or the Scimitar in order to find it. Although all the Scimitar needs to do is keep moving while cloaked and while charging up the weapon then fire it while still cloaked.

Depends on whether the Executor can find/hit, track and then fire all it's weapons on the Scimitar to destroy it before it fires the Thaleron weapon.

http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Krenim_weapon_ship

This was it.

Instead, look at this:
http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Scimitar

This is the information for the on topicness.

But more importantly: omfg timegun.

Dude. A time-gun. I gotta start getting in to Star Trek.

But anyhoo. The problem for the Executor will be finding the Scimitar. I don't think they ever tell us exactly how Star Wars sensors operate. I've never heard of them tracking tachyons or "residual anti-protons" so there's no way of telling if they can or can't find them. If it does find them though, the Executor will win.

We do know that 'wars has cloaking devices ("No ship that small has a cloaking device!"😉. Surely they've developed some sort of countermeasure.

I remember asking about them, or reading about them, and they worked both ways. You couldn't see the ship but the ship couldn't see out. I don't know if that has has changed or if I just have bad information in my head.

i remember that i think it was in the thrawn duology?