Hal Jordan & Martian Manhunter vs Superman & Womderwoman

Originally posted by Q99
Diana can fight in space, and outfought a Hyperclan white martian there once. Either as long as she holds her breath, or a breath mask she often takes on JL missions.

Diana can make low-orbital jaunts, but she is a "baby" compared to the other three in the space department -- she requires active life-support beyond low-orbital ranges, and in a forum battle that is a *very* exploitable weakness *if* the battle moves to space, which it easily could with this group. She fought Primate in low-orbit, not actual open space. It's not a definite "no", just a very exploitable situation for her compared to the other 3. Personally, I think she'd have to be more on guard against Hal using piercing/slashing ring attacks against her as getting her to/keeping her in - space is problematic; just listed it as a valid concern.

The pressure's no problem, and she can move around and fight as well as the others, the only real issue is oxygen giving something of a time limit unless she has a mask.

Originally posted by Q99
The pressure's no problem, and she can move around and fight as well as the others, the only real issue is oxygen giving something of a time limit unless she has a mask.

Exactly. That's my point. Her needing oxygen/a mask is an exploitable weakness in this context, with this line-up. Her having a tank/mask is something Hal/J'onn could negate, with enough finesse/power attack.

bump

Originally posted by tideoftime
Exactly. That's my point. Her needing oxygen/a mask is an exploitable weakness in this context, with this line-up. Her having a tank/mask is something Hal/J'onn could negate, with enough finesse/power attack.

Still, that leaves her, what, 4-5 minutes? And it's not easy to hit to begin with. Plenty of time to get back to Earth if need be if it does happen, possibly enough time to finish the fight.

And J'onn needs to breath too.

Team 2 8/10. I always thought of Superman being>any GL imo. Superman could take hal out pretty quick and again, thats my opinion.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
Split

👆

Originally posted by carver9
I always thought of Superman being>any GL imo. Superman could take hal out pretty quick and again, thats my opinion.

Personally, I'm of the opinion that any top-tier GL with common sense and even general knowledge of Superman, should be able to defeat him, at least in a forum battle. In comics, it doesn't happen very often, unfortunetly.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Personally, I'm of the opinion that any top-tier GL with common sense and even general knowledge of Superman, should be able to defeat him, at least in a forum battle. In comics, it doesn't happen very often, unfortunetly.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Personally, I'm of the opinion that any top-tier GL with common sense and even general knowledge of Superman, should be able to defeat him, at least in a forum battle. In comics, it doesn't happen very often, unfortunetly.

I disagree with this unless you count them creating kryptonite which would be there only hope.

^ Based on their high end energy manipulation feats, the ability to create or simulate kryptonite, the ability to create or simulate red solar energy, energy draining in of itself, mental assaults, BFR, simply being able to avoid or negate pretty much any attack Superman is capable of. Using everything that a power ring has been shown capable of doing, a vet GL should be be able to at least split even with Superman.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
^ Based on their high end energy manipulation feats, the ability to create or simulate kryptonite, the ability to create or simulate red solar energy, energy draining in of itself, mental assaults, BFR, simply being able to avoid or negate pretty much any attack Superman is capable of. Using everything that a power ring has been shown capable of doing, a vet GL should be be able to at least split even with Superman.

In theory mind you, but in comics it isn't this easy.

Hal was doing fine just before he got crazy didn't he?

Originally posted by carver9
Team 2 8/10. I always thought of Superman being>any GL imo. Superman could take hal out pretty quick and again, thats my opinion.

wow.

This is hard. Anyone who picks more than 6/10 for either team is misguided.

Team 2 6.5/10

^ misguided.

6.1/10?

lol

Originally posted by h1a8
This is hard. Anyone who picks more than 6/10 for either team is misguided.