Originally posted by Phantom Miria
[b]So why not just say "No"? The rest was irrelevant and I was trying to understand its relevance, which was not there. That is why I did not find it consistent. [/B]
He did say No. But he added more words after it that didn't serve any real purpose.
It's like if you asked me if I knew who Mr. Spalding was and I said "No. But I know a guy named Fred. Also, I know what the secret Mario backflip is. Also, you don't."
Originally posted by Phantom Miria
[b]So why not just say "No"? The rest was irrelevant and I was trying to understand its relevance, which was not there. That is why I did not find it consistent. [/B]
The "no" part was for you. The rest was for SV's 'gameplay mechanics' comment.
I failed to distinguish that, though, so I'm at fault here. Sorry for the mix up.
I've decided to give the gold to Sylvanas. I do not personally think her showings are more impressive than Link's, but they're hard to really compare. Both are excellent. My reasoning for Link taking silver is as follows.
-Both can acheive a perfect bulls-eye on command. A tie.
-Only one can take gold.
-... I included CIS. 😐 Link's character is such that he'd step down in the event of a tie. He's the opposite of selfish. (And I'm not calling Sylvanas selfish, I'm sayin' Link would volunteer without bein' asked. He's a goon that way.)
-If I gave it to Link, people would think me biased. 😛 I'd rather not have the resentment. <---Biggest reason. If someone else was running this thread, I'd fight for the gold, but it's not.
So, while I maintain that Link is worthy of gold, so is Sylvanas. Both can hit the target flawlessly, and in the event of a tie, Link's CIS will kick in, and Sylvanas will take gold.
Lesson learned: Next time, make the targets farther away. 131
Who takes bronze?
Originally posted by ScreamPaste
I've decided to give the gold to Sylvanas. I do not personally think her showings are more impressive than Link's, but they're hard to really compare. Both are excellent. My reasoning for Link taking silver is as follows.-Both can acheive a perfect bulls-eye on command. A tie.
-Only one can take gold.
-... I included CIS. 😐 Link's character is such that he'd step down in the event of a tie. He's the opposite of selfish. (And I'm not calling Sylvanas selfish, I'm sayin' Link would volunteer without bein' asked. He's a goon that way.)
-If I gave it to Link, people would think me biased. 😛 I'd rather not have the resentment. <---Biggest reason. If someone else was running this thread, I'd fight for the gold, but it's not.So, while I maintain that Link is worthy of gold, so is Sylvanas. Both can hit the target flawlessly, and in the event of a tie, Link's CIS will kick in, and Sylvanas will take gold.
Lesson learned: Next time, make the targets farther away. 131
Who takes bronze?
If both have the skill to hit the targets perfectly, it should come down to who can do it fastest. Because of the short range and the easy targets, that should be used to determine who is the better archer on that field.
Sylvanas. You can not deny her rate at aim and of fire is higher.
When it comes to archery outside this contest, the rest can be debated.