Harley Quin vs Black Cat

Originally posted by 753
Originally it was a version of supersoldier serum

Iirc, that was just in the animated series.

In the comics, started out with none, then 'bought' powers from, I think, the Kingpin, which gave her bad luck abilities. She got rid of them because they were harming Peter, and Dr. Strange morphed them into physical cat abilities (which was when she beat Sabertooth). They lasted for awhile, but eventually left, and she bought replaces in the form of gear/outfit from the Tinkerer.

lol, Super Soldier serum was only in the cartoon I believe. BC still wins this every time.

How? In this scenario Harley has super strength and super agility and BC doesn't. Skill wise they'd be around even based on average showings, so I'd say Harley should stomp by being all around tougher.

Harley.

Well Black Cat did beat Sabertooth (pre HF) and held her own against Carnage and Venom several times. She was also there when Parker fought sinister 12 and was beating a bunch of super villains before getting attacked by Electro. I think she should take it. Also she has her luck powers back and its no the costume that enables her to do everything she does imo it was supposed to be so but was forgotten a long time ago, now it's just her natural abilities and skills.

I'll take Quinn. She also has some good showings in her new series with Catwoman and Poison Ivy.

Beating Sabertooth was a lulzy retcon error, wasn't it?

Wasn't retconned. BC mentioned it not a long time ago.

Black Cat coz she is more sexy

Originally posted by Q99
Iirc, that was just in the animated series.

In the comics, started out with none, then 'bought' powers from, I think, the Kingpin, which gave her bad luck abilities. She got rid of them because they were harming Peter, and Dr. Strange morphed them into physical cat abilities (which was when she beat Sabertooth). They lasted for awhile, but eventually left, and she bought replaces in the form of gear/outfit from the Tinkerer.

Shows you how little I know about her, but she lost all the powers she had? That crossover with wolverine, wat was her powerset then?

Harley

Felicia.

Did I mention they're fighting naked? NAKED!

Harley

Explain to me how Harley has ANY fighting ability, let alone enough to compete with a world class athlete who has given people league's above her trouble.

She's stronger, faster, more durable, and has more stamina. At least in the scenario given. That's why she wins.

Depends on the version of BC being used. With her bad luck powers she wins almost by default. When her powers mutated and she lost the bad luck thing but gained better superhuman attributes and natural claws she'd probably win. Sans both bad luck and superhuman stats she'd probably lose after a good fight...