what will happen to these guys

Originally posted by Lord Feron
I'm juts gonna run with you rthoery for now but you think Cap can live if he got run over by a truck? I mean getting hit by one is one thing and getting run over is another. I have a feeling getting run over aint half as bad meaning he should still live.

If the wheels pass over you, I think it might be even worse. If he got hit straight up the damage would be very bad too. Do you remmebr a scene in chuck's bride where a guy freaks out and steps out of the van, then a speeding truck hits and desintegrates him? I think that would actually be reasonable for the impact of a 40 ton truck moving at 200km/h like this thread. Without some serious HF or invulnerabilty I don't think anyone can survive that, or at the very least they won't be pretty afterwards if they live.

Originally posted by jalek moye
because it looks cool

Damn straight, real man dont budge when hit by trucks or flinch when walking away from explosions.

But it really is completely far fetched, writers just don't understand intuitive concepts of atriction or inertia. Those same people can get tossed arround by judo flips.

Originally posted by 753
Unlike the truck, Hulk's fist is small enough to fit the frame of the shield. I personally don't think he should be able to stop a punch packing the equivalent energy of a truck moving at 130mph, assuming hulk was punching at least that hard. Given his previous history of feats and strengh, a punch like that should blow him away or shove him in the ground. I know it's because of the vibranium in the shield that absorbs the energy so he doesn't have to tank it directly, but even then, it seems far fetched.

Not to be rude, but everything else you said is irrelevant.

Originally posted by Mindset
Hulk's hand being smaller doesn't really matter, he'd be able to generate more force than the truck, anyway.

Not to be rude, but everything else you said is irrelevant.

No offense taken, I simply disagree.

I doubt hulk put that much force into that punch then (even though he obviopusly can exceed it by far). If the shield could absorb all manner of force, kinetic energy and impact, CA would be the juggernaut with it. He'd be able to withstand and push through anything regardless of his own strengh to back it.

And the truck being bigger means that even if it just deforms arround the shield, it will still hit the rest of CA's body, unlees he is crawling into a ball behind it.

Originally posted by 753
No offense taken, I simply disagree.

I doubt hulk put that much force into that punch then (even though he obviopusly can exceed it by far). If the shield could absorb all manner of force, kinetic energy and impact, CA would be the juggernaut with it. He'd be able to withstand and push through anything regardless of his own strengh to back it.

And the truck being bigger means that even if it just deforms arround the shield, it will still hit the rest of CA's body, unlees he is crawling into a ball behind it.

Why do you doubt it?

No, he'd be like Sebastian Shaw, seeing as even vibranium has its limits. Being able to absorb kinetic energy doesn't give him super strength, I'm not sure how he'd be able to push through anything. Unless you mean something else.

The shield is curved, the pieces would probably fly outward away from his body.

Originally posted by Mindset
Why do you doubt it?

No, he'd be like Sebastian Shaw, seeing as even vibranium has its limits. Being able to absorb kinetic energy doesn't give him super strength, I'm not sure how he'd be able to push through anything. Unless you mean something else.

The shield is curved, the pieces would probably fly outward away from his body.

so you believe cap would be fine?
when the truck hits his shield does the truck stop?
if the truck doesnt stop what happens to cap behind the shield, does he just move backwards along with the moving truck, or does he go underneath?

if the truck stops after it hits him, which would be almost impossible for a truck that size to immediately stop, but if it does immediately stop then the shield may absorb the impact. i wont get into that debate since it will turn into real world logic vs comic logic.

but if the truck doesnt stop, cap is will most likely be pushed underneath where he will be killed.

The shield puts the truck in reverse, and it backs away.

Originally posted by Mindset
Why do you doubt it?

No, he'd be like Sebastian Shaw, seeing as even vibranium has its limits. Being able to absorb kinetic energy doesn't give him super strength, I'm not sure how he'd be able to push through anything. Unless you mean something else.

The shield is curved, the pieces would probably fly outward away from his body.

Because of action and reaction. If he absorbs all kinds of force, the reaction force objects make against it would be nullified and he'd be able to push them forward. But let's ignore this, cause it will get complicated when dealing with comic books loose physics.

Let's just say he is like shaw and not jugs. If CA gets in a defensive position with the shield and the hulk pushes, not punches just pushes, the shield and CA back with his hands does he move? If the hulk can push CA back, then the shield can't nullify all force directed at it and, in the case of the truck, its huge mass would simply keep pushing CA back very fast, he'd drop and get run over.

In another way to look at it, picture CA laying on the ground with the shield on his chest, the hulk jumps or punches down on it. Does CA get hurt? Or does the shield absorb/eliminate the force made against him? Because if CA can hold his ground with the hulk pushing him, it's not because of his physical stats holding the shield, it's all the shield's doing, so he should walk out of this situation too.

If the shield can take all that force and keep CA still and intact behind it in the above scenarios, then CA can stop the truck with it (assuming debris dont hit his legs).

Originally posted by r0nm0n88
so you believe cap would be fine?
when the truck hits his shield does the truck stop?

but if the truck doesnt stop, cap is will most likely be pushed underneath where he will be killed.

👆 that's how I think it would go down.

Cap could take a punch from Hulk, because the surface area of his fist is smaller than the shield, so if he braced himself, he could stop it. On the other hand, him just standing there, he'd either get launched backwards, or demolished underneath.

I see Cap stopping the truck while being pushed back, if bracing was allowed. Since it is not he will be run over and become captain pancake.

i think Captain America would be fine.....his shield would keep the truck from hurting him and since I imagine that cap is standing directly in front of the truck as it comes.....he falls backwards but remains to lay their with the shield over his face just in case any jagged parts are hanging down.....seriously he wouldn't need to brace because the shield would probably absorb most of the impact that he might get a small scrape on his back but that's it......

Spidey knows he can`t survive this

Originally posted by Mshinu
Spidey knows he can`t survive this

did spider man just jump on water?

Originally posted by Lord Feron
did spider man just jump on water?