Characters vs. ability official tier list!

Well...who wants to help with this?

Premium

NJO+ Luke
DE Palpatine

Top

Palpatine and Yoda
Mace Windu
Count Dooku
Obi Wan and Anakin

...

...

This is very, very incomplete, so I wonder who would be willing to help fill this out.

I'd be willing to help. I don't really subscribe to any of the literature so my knowledge of the pre-TPM/post-ROTJ era is weak.

Well, if anyone is interested, you can just post the revised version on this thread, while adding names in.

maul is somewhere int he god tier.

aside from that i dont know. i dont read or watch star wars : )

What the shit?

Why is Dooku above Bane and Kas'im?

Where is Nihilus?

What is this with Sidious and DE Sidious? I suppose we should include TPM Windu, AOTC Windu, CW Windu, Shatterpoint Windu, and ROTS Windu as well, right?

Originally posted by Shoes
What the shit?

Why is Dooku above Bane and Kas'im?

Where is Nihilus?

What is this with Sidious and DE Sidious? I suppose we should include TPM Windu, AOTC Windu, CW Windu, Shatterpoint Windu, and ROTS Windu as well, right?

...well, he's sort of the reborn version, and characters' abilities fluctuate.

Oh, and I've said that this is very incomplete.

Shoes, don't be so rude. Also read the thread first next time.

Originally posted by Shoes
What the shit?

Why is Dooku above Bane and Kas'im?

Because he is better than they are?

Bane would wreck Dooku. 😬

Who wouldn't?

Look at that thick hair, those chisled buttocks.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Bane would wreck Dooku. 😬

And Dooku would wreck Kas'im.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
This is questionable at best.

And Dooku would wreck Kas'im.

Except no.

lolololololololol

is funny b/c ur rong

Do we even have a way of telling how the best force users of other eras compare to Dooku?

We have info on uber-tier people, Palps and Luke are highly unusual in the entire history of SW, but how Tyrannus compares to the top sith of other eras (after all, in most other times Dooku would be the master, not the apprentice. Part of why Jedi kept making mistakes with them) like Bane and Kas'im is trickier. Hm... I'd think Dooku is force-stronger but it wouldn't surprise me if Kas'im was sword stronger.

To be honest, I find threads like these to be a waste of time. And there are bunches and bunches of them hiding out in both the Vs. area and this area...

Should this not be a Vs. area subject anyway?

Originally posted by REXXXX

Should this not be a Vs. area subject anyway?

It's not a match, so it'd be closed if posted there, or at least that's my understanding.

I find threads like these to be a waste of time.

👆

Actually Ankakin beat Dooku using mainly saber. Bane would destroy Dooku and Kas'im was beating bane until the temple crumbled on him.

Thus, Kas'im > Dooku

That's... that was terrible.