Harry Potter Magic versus the Force (Army thread).....

Started by Rogue Jedi73 pages

Originally posted by dadudemon
So he just goes intangible and all attacks against him are useless? Is that what you're saying?

Cause I can take a shit on that argument.

Pay my $20 and I won't take a shit on your argument and instead, support it. 🙂

He walked right through the gate, dude. As if it weren't even there. He phased through it. Just saying that objects like bullets and lightsaber blades will not harm him. Magical spells and force attacks? Discuss.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Wow, that is just stupid. NJO Luke would curbstomp raaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaape any wizard with absurd ease. I can't believe Nai would say that.

edit: OMG, reading his above posts..... wtf Nai?

Not so sure. Depends entirely on the conditions of the fight.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Wow, that is just stupid. NJO Luke would curbstomp raaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaape any wizard with absurd ease. I can't believe Nai would say that.

edit: OMG, reading his above posts..... wtf Nai?

yeah agree NJO Luke is a damn beast

How's NJO Luke gonna deal with a wizard who can apparate instantly into the clouds and cast fiendfyre, then simply wait for it to catch Luke? Or utter one word, "Confundus", making Luke forget who he is and what he is doing there?

Wizards are on a whole different level than any force user. It's a way higher power set.

Only you would revive this after three months...

...bout time.

Sssshhhhh, it's gonna be OK.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
How's NJO Luke gonna deal with a wizard who can apparate instantly into the clouds and cast fiendfyre, then simply wait for it to catch Luke? Or utter one word, "Confundus", making Luke forget who he is and what he is doing there?

Wizards are on a whole different level than any force user. It's a way higher power set.

EU Luke can is beyond anything HP can produce. We're talking galactic level telepathy, being able to move so fast he appears to have 20 arms, reactions pretty much near lightspeed, telekinesis strong enough that he can manipulate black holes and later so strong that 'not even the supermassive black hole in the centre of the universe could move him.'

Oh yeah and now he can teleport.

Originally posted by Nephthys
EU Luke can is beyond anything HP can produce. We're talking galactic level telepathy, being able to move so fast he appears to have 20 arms, reactions pretty much near lightspeed, telekinesis strong enough that he can manipulate black holes and later so strong that 'not even the supermassive black hole in the centre of the universe could move him.'

Oh yeah and now he can teleport.

K I forgot about Fold space.

Still agreeing with Borbarad, with Luke as the sole exception.

Most EU Jedi and Sith would own Voldemort or Dumbledore really. Vastly superior reactions and force powers = dead wizards.

Again, I disagree. Voldemort can apparate instantly into the clouds and cast fiendfyre. Or just mind rape them. Legilimency does not rely on the victim being weak minded, all Jedi/Sith would fall to it and be Voldemorts puppet.

I don't recall Luke being able to fly like a wizard. If Voldemort is in the clouds, Luke can't touch him.

But then again, it's been ages since I've read the EU, I could be forgetting some things.

Legilimency does not rely on the victim being weak minded, all Jedi/Sith would fall to it and be Voldemorts puppet.

Yeah it does. Harry (a 14 year old boy) can resist it through willpower. A strong mind can resist it easily. Jedi will shrug it off.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Yeah it does. Harry (a 14 year old boy) can resist it through willpower. A strong mind can resist it easily. Jedi will shrug it off.
Point, I stand corrected.

The Imperius Curse, however, that's the ticket.

http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Imperius_Curse

It too can be resisted the same way, but:

Resisting the Imperius Curse is possible, but requires great strength of will and character. Harry Potter, Barty Crouch Sr. and Barty Crouch Jr. each learned to resist the curse after being subjected to its effects, though the latter two took quite a long time before building the said resistance. Resisting the Imperius Curse is similar to Occlumency, which requires a great amount of willpower.

They learned how to do it over time.

Harry (again, 14) did it the very first time. Nice try.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Harry (again, [b]14) did it the very first time. Nice try. [/B]
WTF are you talking about? Details.

In the lesson, remember?

Originally posted by Nephthys
In the lesson, remember?

That's what I was thinking when he resisted the fake Mad-eye Moody. Is that what you're talking about? It's the part where he fell flat on his face. 🙂

Yeah thats the part.

Originally posted by Nephthys
In the lesson, remember?

Narrow it down, dude haermm Lotsa lessons in the HP movies.

Originally posted by dadudemon
That's what I was thinking when he resisted the fake Mad-eye Moody. Is that what you're talking about? It's the part where he fell flat on his face. 🙂
Ah, I was thinking about this part, FF to 3:14

YouTube video

Voldemort, obviously stronger than Moody, had Harry Imperio'd for a full two minutes.

I was like "Lesson with Voldemort wuuuuuuuuuuuut?" haermm

Besides which, no wizard has the reaction speed nor movement speed to keep up with the obviously superhuman EU forcewielders. They have their necks snapped in milliseconds.