Mace vs. Galen, Darth Maul, Grievous

Started by Galan0073 pages
Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
How will Mace block Force attacks from Mace whilst combating Maul and Grevious at once? Unless if it's CWC Mace, in which case he easily wins.
The way I see it, GG is out with a flick of the wrist - this leaves only Maul and Galen to worry about. Maul wouldn't take much longer to deal with, considering Mace's speed (so fast Anakin couldn't perceive him) + Vaapad. Then there's Galen who IS extremely powerful with the force... But so was Sidious.... Who Mace beat.

Just my opinion.

truejedi Senior Member

Originally posted by ares834
Nope. Mace beat Sidious in the saber portion only. He would have lost the force battle.

prove this malarky. i remrmber anakin interfering.

Lord Lucien Lets all love Lain

He was choking on Ozone. And isn't it said somewhere that Palps was faking weakness. If he had kept it up...

Red Nemesis The Blind Critic

Bandon solos.

truejedi Senior Member
Originally posted by Lord Lucien
He was choking on Ozone. And isn't it said somewhere that Palps was faking weakness. If he had kept it up...

or if Mace had taken a step back... we have been over this.

Autokrat Unknown
Originally posted by truejedi
or if Mace had taken a step back... we have been over this.

Except force lightning doesn't behave like lightning.

truejedi Senior Member

Lightning doesn't have any sort of force behind it anyway. it electrocutes. So whatever sidious was doing, you would have a hard time proving it would be just as affective from across the room. especially since it always seems to be harder to get closer to lightning wielder. (Marek)

Ms.Marvel Don't wanna die...

lightning launched yoda from one end of the movie to the other and threw mace out a window

Autokrat Unknown

I sincerely doubt Force lighting is made up of electrons. Force Lightning does not seemed to be impacted by range.

truejedi Senior Member

It kinda is. When Marek moved closer to sidious, it exploded, when yoda moved closer to sidious, it exploded. Distance matters.

ares834 Senior Member

Electrons don't explode. 😉
Still if Force Lightning did follow the laws of physics its force should be incredibly weak and almost non existant. WHy? Because we have litteraly no charge within us. We are nearly electricly neutral. BUt it clearly has a massive force on us (FL has been shown to blow people back) Ergo it is does not follow Columb's Law.

truejedi Senior Member

But this lightning did? I'm not talking about electrons here. I'm talking about the obvious affect of distance the times we have seen lightning onscreen. If ANYTHING pushes you back, its going to get weaker as you get further away, you would be literally carried away, and never escape the force of the lightning.

Red Nemesis The Blind Critic

Originally posted by truejedi
It kinda is. When Marek moved closer to sidious, it exploded, when yoda moved closer to sidious, it exploded. Distance matters.

um, it is going to take a little bit more than that to prove a causal relationship between the force of the Force (lightning) and distance. Try again?

truejedi Senior Member
Originally posted by Red Nemesis
um, it is going to take a little bit more than that to prove a causal relationship between the force of the Force (lightning) and distance. Try again?

I'm actually good with what I've already written. If distance didn't make a difference, FL would literally push a Jedi back an infinite distance. (since the force that hit them would still be applied while they are flying backwards) Marek's death also shows he had it under control from across the room, and died as a result of getting closer to Sidious.

Red Nemesis The Blind Critic

Originally posted by truejedi
I'm actually good with what I've already written. If distance didn't make a difference, FL would literally push a Jedi back an infinite distance. (since the force that hit them would still be applied while they are flying backwards)

Yeah, because fights regularly take place in an infinite, frictionless void. How often do we see FL actually exerting any force on a victim anyway? It sure didn't send Luke flying across the room. It didn't lift Anakin off his feet. The only time we've seen it exert force (that we can be sure of) is when Sidious threw Windu out of a window.

You're reaching. (By which I mean only that you've yet to substantiate your axioms.)


Marek's death also shows he had it under control from across the room, and died as a result of getting closer to Sidious.

Does it?

Why do you think that?

truejedi Senior Member

It didn't exert force on Anakin? Really?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQTzGzVSHec

19s, you stand corrected on that one. Off his feet and into a wall.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kxb630ipsbs
4:10

He didn't fall out that window, not 30 feet out, he was thrown by FL.

Autokrat Unknown
Originally posted by Red Nemesis
It didn't lift Anakin off his feet. [/B]

I thought Dooku slammed him against the wall and tossed him through the air.

EDIT - Truejedi beat me to it.

Red Nemesis The Blind Critic

me
Sidious threw Windu

I said that part already. And you've yet to substantiate that it was the lightning exerting the force, and not some other application of the Force like, for instance, Telekinesis.

you stand corrected on that one.

😮

thrown by FL

has yet to be substantiated

truejedi Senior Member

Occum's razor is pretty obviously applied here. The definition of reaching would be assuming something that there is absolutely no evidence to suggest. I've never seen anyone use lightning and TK at the same time, (or lightning, and ANYTHING else at the same time for that matter, for all we know its not even possible.)

Red Nemesis The Blind Critic

I've never seen anyone use lightning and TK at the same time

This is begging the question. (😄) You're taking it as given that this isn't TK and then using that assumption as evidence, and I won't stand for it.

You will either give us solid evidence of your claims in a written out and not-flippant-in-the-least format or I will stop pretending to care about this topic.