Grievous vs Maul

Maul's first assassination assigment.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Darth_maul

One of Maul’s earliest missions was the assassination of Siolo'urmanka. One of the greatest living Jedi warriors, Manka had since gone into seclusion, renouncing the lightsaber to concentrate on what he felt was a "purer" technique. He now lived on a jungle world in the Jentares system. Maul arrived on the world and cautiously approached the Jedi Master, brandishing his lightsaber. Thinking that he could easily kill the meditating Manka, Maul was caught off guard by the Jedi Master’s sudden attack.[5][6]

Originally posted by truejedi
Maul didn't fight Vader. I believe it was a clone. Which isn't the same.

A clone of Maul would likely be equal to or weaker than Maul himself.

Originally posted by One Free Man
do we doubt if sidious was sidious in DE just because he was a clone of himself?

also, he dominated Vader, making whether or not he was a clone or not a moot point.

Sidious essence transferred to himself. It was HIM in a new body.

A clone is NOT that. A clone would have to have the ABSOLUTE Same training and life experience as the original maul to be permissable here as evidence. Clone Maul would have had to kill QGJ, for instance, to be permissable here. He is not.

It is the farthest thing from a moot point. I might as well argue that Dooku could beat Grievous, so maul can, as to say that a clone of maul can beat grievous so maul can. This is a BASIC vs. forum thing man. Get it straight.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
A clone of Maul would likely be equal to or weaker than Maul himself.

so you're saying that without the training or affordances of original maul, clonemaul was able to dominate vader based on the teachings of no-ones? http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Resurrection

And clone-maul would have been taught better by these nobodies than sidious?

Fact: Its not the same person. No matter WHAT it did, it doesn't help a Maul argument. Anything else you try to add about this NOT MAUL PERSON will be ignored.

If Boba Fett==Jango Fett, THEN you have argument, till then, you don't.

Who gives a shit; this is retarded.

Greivous would hand Vader his ass if Vader fought him in the same way he fought Maul; not using any offensive force powers at all besides like one or two throws.

Maul's track record is beating Anoon Bondera the featless wonder and Qui-Gon Jinn the featless wonder, twenty seconds later he gets chopped in half by angsty Obi-Wan. Those are his high showings.

Grievous high showing is holding off multiple Jedi without a scratch, getting dragged by a high speed train with zero damage inflicted upon his body, tearing through clone honor guards, easily dispatching Shaak Ti who moments prior showed enough skill to fight off twenty+ magna guards without a scratch, and stalemating mace freakin' windu in a lightsaber fight and replicating Vapaad on the fly.

The two aren't even comparable.

Well technically they are comparable.

Maul uses a double bladed saber.
However
Grievous uses 1-6 single sabers.

This has nothing to do with the debate at hand, I am just showing, they can be compared.

^ That's more than a little biased. You should be careful: the opposition might tear into you with Grievous's performance from the new series.

Spoiler:
It really is terrible.

Originally posted by mattatom
Well technically they are comparable.

Maul uses a double bladed saber.
However
Grievous uses 1-6 single sabers.

This has nothing to do with the debate at hand, I am just showing, they can be compared.

Shut up.

Please?

Originally posted by Gideon
^ That's more than a little biased. You should be careful: the opposition might tear into you with Grievous's performance from the new series.

Spoiler:
It really is terrible.

I'm counting on someone bringing them up so I can destroy them on a case by case basis.

Specifically, going specifically by feats Ashouka's shaping up to be one the best duelists in the order... ermm You need to discuss her in your holocron thingy, if that's still going on.

From what I recall Greivous has been embarassed by... Ashouka, Kit Fisto, and someone else that I'm drawing a blank on.

Originally posted by Gideon
^ That's more than a little biased. You should be careful: the opposition might tear into you with Grievous's performance from the new series.

Spoiler:
It really is terrible.

Which is why I said Grevious's inconsistent.

Again:

CWC Grevious pwns Maul - CWC Grevious pwned 6 Jedi, 2 being council members (Ki-Adi-Mundi and Shaak Ti), at once
CW animated Grevious loses to Maul - CW animated Grevious got defeated easily by Kit Fisto.
ROTS Grevious beats Maul - 20+ strikes per second

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
Shut up.

Please?

Spoiler:
Sure, sorry I was bored

Spoiler:
Not

Originally posted by mattatom

Spoiler:
Sure, sorry I was bored

Spoiler:
I still love you

@Re: Blaxican

Are you really Final Blaxican?

Eeth Koth, I believe.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
@Re: Blaxican

Are you really Final Blaxican?

I am. If you don't believe me, I'll take my pants off.

Originally posted by Gideon
Eeth Koth, I believe.

Yeah, that guy.

I got nothing on him.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
I am. If you don't believe me, I'll take my pants off.

When did you realize that the Comic Book vs. Forum for KMC forums wasn't really closing? 😉

Tomorrow

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
Who gives a shit; this is retarded.

Greivous would hand Vader his ass if Vader fought him in the same way he fought Maul; not using any offensive force powers at all besides like one or two throws.

Maul's track record is beating Anoon Bondera the featless wonder and Qui-Gon Jinn the featless wonder, twenty seconds later he gets chopped in half by angsty Obi-Wan. Those are his high showings.

Grievous high showing is holding off multiple Jedi without a scratch, getting dragged by a high speed train with zero damage inflicted upon his body, tearing through clone honor guards, easily dispatching Shaak Ti who moments prior showed enough skill to fight off twenty+ magna guards without a scratch, and stalemating mace freakin' windu in a lightsaber fight and replicating Vapaad on the fly.

The two aren't even comparable.

just don't try the clones==the character we are discussing game. ****es me off every time. Its just so incorrect. This forum USED to have STANDARDS. : )