Cap America Vs. Green Arrow

what is his code of honor, pls site them...

training is not indoctrination try again i dont think you know what indoctrination really is nor would superman or batman allow it to occur and definitely not ollie in the JLA.

being a member of a super team does not make him a warrior or anyone else it is not a military unit nor treated as such again superman and his team would never allow it..

best one what craft bow and arrow he does not have a set system he knows one skill and is not part of any standardized system again that is like an olympic archer saying he is a warrior b/c of his skill and physical trainining

1.He protects the "little guy". The fact that he dresses up and fights crime isn't good enough?
2.Not sure what the hell you meant there, please clarify.
3.He's on a super team that could be applicable to a S.W.A.T. team. What happens when superheroes need backup and no one person can solve the problem? Why do police officers dial 911? There the last line of defense. So what if the JLA isn't a military unit and don't kill their targets(this is what you getting at).
4.Not only is he the best archer, he is an adept martial artist, swordsman, and aviator, handles explosives, is great in hostage situations and rescue, can put out fires, etc.

Is that not similar atleast to a Seal or S.W.A.T. member? Let's not mention that he'd slaughter any of those guys be it Spartan, Samurai, Viking, S.W.A.T. member, Delta Force, Ranger, GSG 9, etc.

I understand it's cringe-worthy to label every superhero a warrior but if there was one character who fit the bill.......

1. his aspiration and reason for being a superhero does not make it an oath or code of conduct... spiderman does the same he believes with great power comes great responsibility.. these words make him do what he does but they are not a code of conduct or anything to do with honor.. police have the whole serve and protect and they are not warriors either.. so again what promise and oaths did he make and under what ceremony or what system of combat... example did his martial arts master make him promise do live a certain way of life?

2. i mean superman nor batman would allow members of the JLA to be hazed, belittled humiliated beaten nor brain washed in order to join the team... example.. i was burn with scolding water while walking naked in the showers single form lines same with cold water left to stand in a cold hall staring eyes front then over hydrated till you choke on the water and vomit.. then grabbed and forced to drink and drown by it.. punched, kicked and choked... forced to P.T. for hours on and off till i was ready to pass out and bleeding b/c i refused to call myself a b#$@ch... promotion i was given my rank without backings and stood in place well over 50 marines came up shook hands punch me on the chest and drove the backing into my chest..

3. again being in a team does not make him a warrior he has to live and breath and fight a certain way.. the swat team again are not warriors in itself even though many have past military training and are themselves warriors but it wasnt the swat team that makes them warriors it is their prior warrior training prior to joining swat. again JLA is not a military group nor treated as such their is no set rules on how it is operated it has bn brought up in the past by military personal that have had issues with them.. they have no loyalties to any one person or country... if they do not even serve one nation or obey one leaders words how can they be a warrior with a since of duty, loyalty and honor,, yes they have it to each other but not to a nation.

4. again it isnt what he knows that makes him a warrior it is the system that he is under he does not have one hence he is not a warrior.. a guy that studies martial arts cannot be called a ninja if he does not study that specific martial arts or have bn tested by their standard even though he knows certain types of the same skills... the title must be earned and given by said group.. he can be a great martial artist but he cannot be called a warrior although others may call him that it does not make him so..

It's not even worth it.

Originally posted by Wild Shadow
dont pick and choice the definition that you think agrees with your own definition paste the whole definition of it..

http://www.answers.com/topic/warrior
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrior

also a quick definition of a dictionary does not encompass everything that it is required to be a warrior and a warrior would be insulted to be called a soldier or referred as such major difference in most military societies.. .. tell me what military or warrior training have you gone in your country b/c in each country the requirements are different. which is why in a dictionary you get a short encompassing definition and comparison to a soldier.. try the military definition of a countries army to get what that countries military fighting men consider a warrior..

one think that remains the same is:

code of conduct

indoctrination: test body, mind & spirit

elite group above average military..

these were also specifically stated in the definition to be a warrior in the dictionary that you sited in but left out for just the top two similar noun.

which are only meant to give you an idea and similarity of the word but does not make it a fully accurate term just an idea..

like comparing karate to kung fu or tae kwon do.. martial arts they are used for comparison for certain words but not meant to be interchangeable that is the problem with todays society and what we have hear..

green arrow is a comic book hero a super hero even but he is not a warrior.