Hercules (Marvel) vs Powergirl

Started by -Pr-5 pages

Any strength advantage he MIGHT have isn't going to be substantial, imo.

She should win imo.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Just because she's commonly portrayed alongside She-Hulk in fanart (along with Wonder Woman) doesn't mean she's her character equivalent. Power Girl is a lot less promiscuous than Jenn.
Who cares if they sleep arround? Doesn't say anything about their "self-respect". She'll rape hercules both figurativelly and literally, although he'll enjoy the second one.

Herc 7/10

Originally posted by -Pr-
Any strength advantage he MIGHT have isn't going to be substantial, imo.

She should win imo.

Any Kryptonian attributes that put her over Herc doesn't matter any more...

Spoiler:
since he's a skyfather now

Hercules stomps...errr humps her hard.

It is not necessary to phrase every conflict in terms of sex! Even if they are as slutty as Herc.

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
so thor is equal to powergirl?

Meh, Thor's stronger then Herc. Everyone knows Thor holds back, while Herc doesn't really share his same ethical code.. Serious Thor = Herc crushed in short order.

IMO.

Anyways, even if Herc was stronger then PG, he's still a lot slower and less maneuverable, so PG has the edge.

Originally posted by cdtm
Meh, Thor's stronger then Herc. Everyone knows Thor holds back, while Herc doesn't really share his same ethical code.. Serious Thor = Herc crushed in short order.

IMO.

Anyways, even if Herc was stronger then PG, he's still a lot slower and less maneuverable, so PG has the edge.

No

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
Any Kryptonian attributes that put her over Herc doesn't matter any more...
Spoiler:
since he's a skyfather now

Hercules stomps...errr humps her hard.

Well, that would make this spite then.

The Dark Cloud probably meant the "standard" version of Herc (Dark Cloud, this is what you meant, correct? It's your thread, so you get to specify the version of Herc.)

Originally posted by cdtm
Meh, Thor's stronger then Herc. Everyone knows Thor holds back, while Herc doesn't really share his same ethical code.. Serious Thor = Herc crushed in short order.

IMO.

Anyways, even if Herc was stronger then PG, he's still a lot slower and less maneuverable, so PG has the edge.

thats were your wrong, in all there fights thor has never held back(only held back his powers), hercules almost put thor to sleep before and thor had to call down lightning to break his hold and they have arm wrestled to a stalemate multiple times
not to mention hercules covered for thor before

Originally posted by iceman24567
Herc is stronger than her no doubt PG still wins
This.

I don't know why people don't want to admit Herc is obviously stronger.

Originally posted by Mindset
No

How do you figure?

Looked like Herc was trying to beat Atlas to death in Thunderbolts. Not really something Thor would ever do, even against someone that helped beat him into a coma.

Originally posted by cdtm
How do you figure?

Looked like Herc was trying to beat Atlas to death in Thunderbolts. Not really something Thor would ever do, even against someone that helped beat him into a coma.

What?

Originally posted by Mindset
What?

I'm saying Herc wasn't holding back against Atlas, in the Thunderbolts story where they fought. He was obviously trying to kill him.

While Thor, by contrast, rarely, if ever, hits someone as hard as he could.

So when Thor fights, there's the "Is he going all out?" question, while you can't really say the same for all of Hercule's fights.

Originally posted by cdtm
I'm saying Herc wasn't holding back against Atlas, in the Thunderbolts story where they fought. He was obviously trying to kill him.

While Thor, by contrast, rarely, if ever, hits someone as hard as he could.

So when Thor fights, there's the "Is he going all out?" question, while you can't really say the same for all of Hercule's fights.

😬
thor goes all out if he wants to.he has killed bor, brutally murdered ares
he even fights odin

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
😬
thor goes all out if he wants to.he has killed bor, brutally murdered ares
he even fights odin

If the stakes are high enough, sure.

He also held back against Firelord, despite the fact he was trying to murder him, and has been stated to routinely hold back numerous times in various canon and non canon stories.

Originally posted by cdtm
I'm saying Herc wasn't holding back against Atlas, in the Thunderbolts story where they fought. He was obviously trying to kill him.

While Thor, by contrast, rarely, if ever, hits someone as hard as he could.

So when Thor fights, there's the "Is he going all out?" question, while you can't really say the same for all of Hercule's fights.

Yea, anyway, Herc is the same strength level as Thor.

He had to strike Herc with lightning to get out of his chokehold.

Originally posted by Q99
It is not necessary to phrase every conflict in terms of sex! Even if they are as slutty as Herc.
It's not a matter of necessity, it's funny.

Originally posted by 753
It's not a matter of necessity, it's funny.

Gotta disagree. Jokes are funny, but "Hey, sex!" is not a joke.

Well, at least as much as it's run into the ground. Unexpectedness has a lot to do with what makes good humor after all.

Originally posted by Q99
Gotta disagree. Jokes are funny, but "Hey, sex!" is not a joke.

Well, at least as much as it's run into the ground. Unexpectedness has a lot to do with what makes good humor after all.

Cliché is a genre of humour in its own right.

Originally posted by 753
Cliché is a genre of humour in its own right.

Point, that's true enough.

Though I don't think it's done with enough irony to qualify.