Superman Vs Captain Marvel

Started by -Pr-17 pages

Originally posted by ankur29

&

ok, fair enough.

question: do you think it's honestly been portrayed that way?

Originally posted by -Pr-
ok, fair enough.

question: do you think it's honestly been portrayed that way?

yup

CM is always weaker when sharing , in all his appearances i think this is true

the fact that SM can still feel CM's handstrength grip is just a show of how awesome CM is

Originally posted by SamZED
Or trying to help Parademon increase its self-esteem.

Lolololhahahaha... good one.

Originally posted by ankur29
yup

CM is always weaker when sharing , in all his appearances i think this is true

the fact that SM can still feel CM's handstrength grip is just a show of how awesome CM is

that wasn't what i was asking.

i was asking if you think it's always been portrayed as equal sharing. i honestly don't.

Originally posted by -Pr-
that wasn't what i was asking.

i was asking if you think it's always been portrayed as equal sharing. i honestly don't.

yup imho i think its always equal sharing

just CM gets more limelight,cause he's the first and on occasion takes the power/given it back from Jr and mary

Originally posted by ankur29
yup imho i think its always equal sharing

just CM gets more limelight,cause he's the first and on occasion takes the power/given it back from Jr and mary

so you think that at any given point, both freddy and mary were as powerful as billy?

Originally posted by ankur29
yup imho i think its always equal sharing

just CM gets more limelight,cause he's the first and on occasion takes the power/given it back from Jr and mary


I call BS.

Originally posted by -Pr-
so you think that at any given point, both freddy and mary were as powerful as billy?
i say, yes. only difference is experience.

Captain Marvel has bn shown to be equal to the others when they are all on panel and power sharing.

is there a particular moment you have in mind that you think says different?

Originally posted by King Castle
i say, yes. only difference is experience.

Captain Marvel has bn shown to be equal to the others when they are all on panel and power sharing.

is there a particular moment you have in mind that you think says different?

about a few decades of comics, tbh.

i've never gotten the impression that freddy was billy level. billy was the champion chosen by shazam. freedy was... freddy. same with mary.

Almost all of Mary's good feats come when she's being empowered by someone else like Black Adam or Darkseid. Power sharing Mary and Freddy really have nothing to compare with Billy.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Almost all of Mary's good feats come when she's being empowered by someone else like Black Adam or Darkseid. Power sharing Mary and Freddy really have nothing to compare with Billy.

what does billy have whilst power sharing???

Originally posted by ankur29
what does billy have whilst power sharing???

Apparently having the same effect on Superman as a Parademon. 🙂

Originally posted by -Pr-
about a few decades of comics, tbh.

i've never gotten the impression that freddy was billy level. billy was the champion chosen by shazam. freedy was... freddy. same with mary.


that doesnt change that their powers are halved.

i say Billy is better then CM3 but only due to experience which is why he would win.

Mary and Billy have raced and she won only slightly its all up for grabs when they power share but, of course marvel would be shown to win in a comic fight if they were to fight.

as it should be. 😇

i'm sorry but you are goin to be specific where his powers arent split evenly.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Apparently having the same effect on Superman as a Parademon. 🙂

don't hate on CM 😕

that is defo BS or a really strong parademon

everyone should know CM is superman strong...strong enough to match him/hurt him/make him bleed with physical strength

so don't be disrespectful to CM and compare that intant with the parademon to undermine him

Originally posted by King Castle
that doesnt change that their powers are halved.

i say Billy is better then CM3 but only due to experience which is why he would win.

Mary and Billy have raced and she won only slightly its all up for grabs when they power share but, of course marvel would be shown to win in a comic fight if they were to fight.

as it should be. 😇

i'm sorry but you are goin to be specific where his powers arent split evenly.

consistent, on panel representations trump dialogue. they always have.

Originally posted by ankur29
don't hate on CM 😕

that is defo BS or a really strong parademon

everyone should know CM is superman strong...strong enough to match him/hurt him/make him bleed with physical strength

so don't be disrespectful to CM and compare that intant with the parademon to undermine him


All I see from the scan you posted is Cap making Superman grunt the same way a Parademon's punch made him grunt.

Ergo its as much proof that CM is as strong as he is as is a Parademon making him grunt is proof that a Parademon is that strong. 😛

Originally posted by -Pr-
about a few decades of comics, tbh.

i've never gotten the impression that freddy was billy level. billy was the champion chosen by shazam. freedy was... freddy. same with mary.

CM only outperforms the two when he isn't sharing

example:
i don't remmeber if this is 100% accurate but i think there was an instance where CM couldn't put captain nazi down while jr and mary were powered up , but did after they gave it back

^ Scans?

Because when this got brought up I was trying to think of a time where Cap says to Freddy and Mary, "You need to give me all the power so I can handle this."

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ Scans?

Because when this got brought up I was trying to think of a time where Cap says to Freddy and Mary, "You need to give me all the power so I can handle this."

it's not exactly like that
the power splits evenly and CM seems better than the other two cause imo he is the most experienced like a previous poster said
CM looks better cause he is the main charecter and in most cases is not sharing at the time

its true about what Ankur said about the Captain Nazi fight Captain Marvel wasnt strong enough and was getting beat by Nazi b/c Freddie was power sharing b/c he wanted revenge on CN for handicapping him.

once CM3 realized that it was his fault that CM couldnt fight to the best of his ability Freddie went to a near by roof iirc and returned to his non powered form and CM felt the power amp of his powers returning.