Originally posted by quanchi112Some vague interview does not trump panel showings. A single writer doesn't have the power to retcon events, and that isn't proof here.
Someone posted the interview when this was fresh and the writer agreed it didn't go down the same way he remembered it.
Go back to Hero Chat, Quan! sneer
biscuits
Originally posted by BadabingIt's the writer verifying hulk didn't recollect things 100 percent. it also makes sense since Hulk has never dominated Thor like that.
Some vague interview does not trump panel showings. A single writer doesn't have the power to retcon events, and that isn't proof here.Go back to Hero Chat, Quan! sneer
biscuits
I can't it got ethered.
Originally posted by quanchi112Nope, what matters is what was shown. Unless Marvel wants to retcon it. And if it was supposed to be a certain way, then it doesn't make sense to come out with a comic w/o an explanation in the dialogue. That's someone backtracking from hate mail. And one interview that goes against panel showings still isn't considered proof here.
It's the writer verifying hulk didn't recollect things 100 percent. it also makes sense since Hulk has never dominated Thor like that.I can't it got ethered.
Yes, I know. Hence the biscuits.
Banner: Yeah right. And then I woke up.
Memory sequence that Banner himself questions. The writer stated he threw that in as an out or something similar when he made the first interview at CBR.
I recall you laughing at my reasoning of that statement when I first proposed it's meaning Bada. Then the writer confirmed it.
uhuh
Originally posted by BadabingI do agree it probably had to do with the hatemail but the comic itself made it very vague as to what actually happened.
Nope, what matters is what was shown. Unless Marvel wants to retcon it. And if it was supposed to be a certain way, then it doesn't make sense to come out with a comic w/o an explanation in the dialogue. That's someone backtracking from hate mail. And one interview that goes against panel showings still isn't considered proof here.Yes, I know. Hence the biscuits.
Originally posted by Rage.Of.OlympusWe've been through this. That dialogue box was referring to Banner's convo with the dude at the diner asking for the "Hulk's autograph.
Banner: Yeah right. And then I woke up.Memory sequence that Banner himself questions. The writer stated he threw that in as an out or something similar when he made the first interview at CBR.
I recall you laughing at my reasoning of that statement when I first proposed it's meaning Bada. Then the writer confirmed it.
uhuh
Banner - Look, I'm only going to say this once more... I am not the Hulk. But if it means you'll leave me alone, I'll sign the stupid paper.
Dude - You got it man... (Back at the Hulk/Thor scene) where a caption box continues - I definitely won't be bothering you again.
Banner - (At the end of the fight) where a caption box states - Yeah right. The very next page, Banner is confronted by Ross and the Army. So the "Yeah right" is a comment on the dude's previous dialogue with Banner and the Army showing up.
Which is all moot since I've already explained that panel feats trump an obscure interview.
Now, back to the topic of Thanos/Darkseid vs WWH/Superman/Wonder Woman/Thor.
And just to be clear, this isn't me debating but me modding. So this convo ends here and now. Thanks.
Originally posted by Badabing
We've been through this. That dialogue box was referring to Banner's convo with the dude at the diner asking for the "Hulk's autograph.Banner - Look, I'm only going to say this once more... I am not the Hulk. But if it means you'll leave me alone, I'll sign the stupid paper.
Dude - You got it man... (Back at the Hulk/Thor scene) where a caption box continues - I definitely won't be bothering you again.
Banner - (At the end of the fight) where a caption box states - Yeah right. The very next page, Banner is confronted by Ross and the Army. So the "Yeah right" is a comment on the dude's previous dialogue with Banner and the Army showing up.
Which is all moot since I've already explained that panel feats trump an obscure interview.
Now, back to the topic of Thanos/Darkseid vs WWH/Superman/Wonder Woman/Thor.
And just to be clear, this isn't me debating but me modding. So this convo ends here and now. Thanks.
Reply:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=490020&pagenumber=35#post13076381
Originally posted by iceman24567
The troll will continue to troll 😐
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Apparently though your opinions change every day. ODG has all but proven that you don't have to go back further than a few days to find a contradiction in your posts.
Originally posted by carver9
Very true, debating with quan is like debating against someone who has amnesia.
Originally posted by Rage.Of.OlympusWatching quanchi112 troll himself for an entire page has got to be the stupidest thing I've ever seen on KMC...
crylaugh0+1 ODG
... I mean... how do you not remember that every single one of those posts was among a series of posts that you trolled somebody else with on the same exact topic with the exact opposite position?
I was actually contemplating changing the wording and style around to make it less obvious that he was responding to nobody but his own posts... then I thought... "Ah, f@ck it. If he does notice immediately what I'm trying to do, he deserves more credit than I give him. If he doesn't, it just compeltely reinforces his trolling."
Let's just say, he didn't disappoint. Not only did he quanchiwaffle his position for no reason, he couldn't help but troll himself. I mean... he could have said, "Alright, I see where you're going with this... this sounds familiar to something I may have thought in the past." But no. He just kept repeating the same questions, feigning the same ignorance, trollin the same trollin, and he even ended up "LAFF"ing at his older posts...
... da f@ck?
It takes talent to be so oblivious. If he's not utterly oblivious, it takes determination to not care and just want to continue trolling. I almost felt bad doing it to him. Let's just say, having it play out the way it did -- FOR AN ENTIRE PAGE -- I don't. Somebody pray for him. I haven't the heart anymore.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0When have I contradicted myself ?
Watching quanchi112 troll himself for an entire page has got to be the stupidest thing I've ever seen on KMC...... I mean... how do you not remember that every single one of those posts was among a series of posts that you trolled somebody else with on the same exact topic with the exact opposite position?
I was actually contemplating changing the wording and style around to make it less obvious that he was responding to nobody but his own posts... then I thought... "Ah, f@ck it. If he does notice immediately what I'm trying to do, he deserves more credit than I give him. If he doesn't, it just compeltely reinforces his trolling."
Let's just say, he didn't disappoint. Not only did he quanchiwaffle his position for no reason, he couldn't help but troll himself. I mean... he could have said, "Alright, I see where you're going with this... this sounds familiar to something I may have thought in the past." But no. He just kept repeating the same questions, feigning the same ignorance, trollin the same trollin, and he even ended up "LAFF"ing at his older posts...
... da f@ck?
It takes talent to be so oblivious. If he's not utterly oblivious, it takes determination to not care and just want to continue trolling. I [b]almost
felt bad doing it to him. Let's just say, having it play out the way it did -- FOR AN ENTIRE PAGE -- I don't. Somebody pray for him. I haven't the heart anymore. [/B]