Black Canary Vs Dick Grayson

Started by Prep-Man3 pages

Originally posted by -Pr-
you wouldn't have a link by any chance? i'd love to read it... dick being bruce level is a huge boost imo...

he's been gradually getting one the last two-three years or so.

Yeah, but how are you guys measuring skill boosts? Because BC has had a boost as well.

Originally posted by -Pr-
you wouldn't have a link by any chance? i'd love to read it... dick being bruce level is a huge boost imo...

he's been gradually getting one the last two-three years or so.

I looked around real quick but I couldn't find it. I'm not sure the exact interview or where I read it (ign, newsarama, cbr ect), and it now occurs to me it might have been Tomasi and not Dini... but I'm not sure. I know I read it somewhere shortly after battle for the cowl, but I don't recall enough info to find it again. 🙁

Originally posted by SamZED
Ugh.. as much as I like seeing NW display his fighting skills, him stalemating or beating Deathstroke is just wrong. Slade is his superior in pretty much everything except agility.
Agility can mean a lot in a fight.

Look at Spiderman.

Originally posted by SamZED
Ugh.. as much as I like seeing NW display his fighting skills, him stalemating or beating Deathstroke is just wrong. Slade is his superior in pretty much everything except agility.

He is also a significantly more skilled fighter, which is the primary reason for him being even a mild threat to Slade. DS has superhuman stats across the board, but he isn't that hot of a fighter, maybe Punisher level... maybe.

Originally posted by SamZED
Ugh.. as much as I like seeing NW display his fighting skills, him stalemating or beating Deathstroke is just wrong. Slade is his superior in pretty much everything except agility.

If you consider the fact that Cass, Batman(Bruce) have also given him problems among other streets. And with NW getting a push and stalemating Cass herself. Then him giving problems to Slade doesn't seem that bad either.

Don't get me wrong Slade would win the majority against them but not easily.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
DS has superhuman stats across the board, but he isn't that hot of a fighter, maybe Punisher level... maybe.

DS is on the very low-low end of the spectrum in superhuman-is though. That's why DC coined him twice in the books as being almost superhuman. Black Panther and Cap have also been termed almost superhuman.

I thinks its more his team fights with equipment and tactical planning that make him more of a threat then just a straight up fight against the best. Although he IMO was still take the majority over guys like Cass and Batman IMO.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
He is also a significantly more skilled fighter, which is the primary reason for him being even a mild threat to Slade. DS has superhuman stats across the board, but he isn't that hot of a fighter, maybe Punisher level... maybe.
That too.

Srank, why are people downplaying the best Batman? 🙁

Originally posted by Mindset
That too.

Srank, why are people downplaying the best Batman? 🙁

Their parents didn't hug them enough... or alternative, they "hugged" them too much? 🙁

Dinah is good, however Dick after nice fight

Originally posted by Prep-Man
How did Dick get a boost in skill?

read a lot of the nightwing issues and the current batman issues as well

Interviews don't mean much. Have we seen Dick face Bruce one on one?

BTW, I have been reading Batman and Robin. NW is good, but I don't see him as being Bruce level, yet.

Dick isn't at Bruce's level and it wouldn't make sense if he was.

Originally posted by SamZED
Ugh.. as much as I like seeing NW display his fighting skills, him stalemating or beating Deathstroke is just wrong. Slade is his superior in pretty much everything except agility.
did they ever confirm if Dick was an actual meta or not?

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
I looked around real quick but I couldn't find it. I'm not sure the exact interview or where I read it (ign, newsarama, cbr ect), and it now occurs to me it might have been Tomasi and not Dini... but I'm not sure. I know I read it somewhere shortly after battle for the cowl, but I don't recall enough info to find it again. 🙁

ah. dini i would believe. tomasi... not sure.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Dick isn't at Bruce's level and it wouldn't make sense if he was.

agreed.

how wouldnt it?!

Dick was raised by Bruce at a young age and was trained by batman himself... a guy who traveled the world to learn and then refined his MA to the most efficient form of fighting then turning around teaching nightwing after removing the frivolous MA crap from his own style.

now Dick is far younger more athletic faster agile then Bat's who batman himself acknowledges whcih is why bat's wears more body armor kevlar then nightwing.. Batman is a brute compared to Dick..

now Dick does a lot better against DS then bats does.. add the fact that Dick has bn around batman for so long he should be able to read batman like a book.

Until we see an actual fight, I'd always side with Batman. Not saying Dick can't surpass him, but there is no actual proof of it.

Originally posted by King Castle
how wouldnt it?!

Dick was raised by Bruce at a young age and was trained by batman himself... a guy who traveled the world to learn and then refined his MA to the most efficient form of fighting then turning around teaching nightwing after removing the frivolous MA crap from his own style.

now Dick is far younger more athletic faster agile then Bat's who batman himself acknowledges whcih is why bat's wears more body armor kevlar then nightwing.. Batman is a brute compared to Dick..

now Dick does a lot better against DS then bats does.. add the fact that Dick has bn around batman for so long he should be able to read batman like a book.

dick wears less body armour than batman to help him use his agility more. bruce wears the same amount he always wore. he doesn't add to it because he feels old/unfit.

bruce isn't getting on in age either. he's still in a reasonably strong physical condition, as good as he's ever been, so i don't see him weakening any time soon.

you also have to remember that dick was still a teenager when bruce turfed him out; bruce couldn't have taught him everything he knows.

normally these two to me are a dead split one being aged with experience, strength and iron will.. the other is speed, energy youthfulness and determination and knowledge of his opponent.

Yeah, like Bruce doesn't know Dick. lol. He taught him pretty much everything he knows.

Originally posted by King Castle
normally these two to me are a dead split one being aged with experience, strength and experience... the other is speed, energy youthfulness and determination and knowledge of his opponent.

you attribute determination to dick more than bruce?

That might be the dumbest point I've ever seen.