Cross Genre Nominations #21

Started by CosmicComet27 pages

Again, Megaman X vs Apocalypse.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
A lot of matches would be great in comics to watch/read but is a thread they would be pretty boring.

Like someone said Green Arrow vs. a Bleach character with a bow, the debate would be damn lame imo, but in a comic the match would probably kick ass.


Yeah. I actually think Jill vs Canary would be awesome in a comic. It's just I know that on a forum, Canary would destroy her with feats(even without her cry).

well how does a video game character, or anime, or any other media outside of comics supposed to stack up against any comic book character, when most of their abilities are implied or hard to quantify?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
well how does a video game character, or anime, or any other media outside of comics supposed to stack up against any comic book character, when most of their abilities are implied or hard to quantify?
They do. It's just lopsided to argue. You'll be at the disadvantage. Which adds to the fun. IMO.

Wonder Woman vs Morrigan.

well i guess im going to have to take a trip to barnes & noble to purchase some more books

Books-A-Million isn't bad. I love bookstores. Running out of room to put books, so I read a lot there. I just bought 4 today.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
She'd have to be weakened to make it a fair match. She is out of her league at full power no questions asked.

Who has to be weakened? Morrgian or Wonder Woman?

Morrigan would have to be weakened.

Originally posted by TheTyrant
Who has to be weakened? Morrgian or Wonder Woman?
Morrigan. She at full power is a full tier Darkstalker.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
well how does a video game character, or anime, or any other media outside of comics supposed to stack up against any comic book character, when most of their abilities are implied or hard to quantify?

Most moderately long manga/anime/tv series/etc can match up. Most people agreed Kakashi stomps Gorgon for example.

The tricky part comes when you get these: game characters; characters from 26 episode anime/tv series with ensemble casts; limited comic or book series. On the forum, you may just have to accept that you can't really argue for a win with certain characters.

That was why I am hesitant on the Kratos deal. I haven't played the games, but it's 3 games vs Diana's library of feats. It's not impossible, but he needs to have some undeniably crazy feats going for him.

Originally posted by StyleTime
Most moderately long manga/anime/tv series/etc can match up. Most people agreed Kakashi stomps Gorgon for example.

The tricky part comes when you get these: game characters; characters from 26 episode anime/tv series with ensemble casts; limited comic or book series. On the forum, you may just have to accept that you can't really argue for a win with certain characters.

That was why I am hesitant on the Kratos deal. I haven't played the games, but it's 3 games vs Diana's library of feats. It's not impossible, but he needs to have some undeniably crazy feats going for him.

You said it clearly. For instance a Galactus level character would be seen to win regardless of feats. But if they are close to the comic character argued, you have an uphill climb.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
I'm just going by my experience and what I saw and read, it was supposed to weaken him... but maybe I'm wrong. It seems to be the consensus though.

What is Hermes' best speed feat?

It was clear he had the power in his person to kill the gods and proved it when he literally beat Zeus to death.

Hermes dashing all over the landscape prior to the fight.

He also did it with the help of lots of plot devices. Thor and WW's standard gear really isn't because it's standard and consistent. Now if WW had "the sword of xxx" and used it for a special enemy that she couldn't beat any other way then *that* would be one too.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
He also did it with the help of lots of plot devices. Thor and WW's standard gear really isn't because it's standard and consistent. Now if WW had "the sword of xxx" and used it for a special enemy that she couldn't beat any other way then *that* would be one too.
Zeus' sword was his standard sword since part 2 he had it through all of part 3.

Kratos collects gear the gods used against him and usually beats them with it. You can't have it both ways.

I already proved you wrong because in the end Kratos beat the life from Zeus with his own fists showing how powerful the guy is.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Zeus' sword was his standard sword since part 2 he had it through all of part 3.

Kratos collects gear the gods used against him and usually beats them with it. You can't have it both ways.

I already proved you wrong because in the end Kratos beat the life from Zeus with his own fists showing how powerful the guy is.

I'm not having it both ways, I have no problem with it being in the game, just that quantifying it is an issue. He did use it on them though.

Nonetheless Herme's speed feat won't help against Wonder Woman on the forum unfortunately. This has all been covered.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Again, Megaman X vs Apocalypse.
megaman X vs ironman would be better

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
I'm not having it both ways, I have no problem with it being in the game, just that quantifying it is an issue. He did use it on them though.

Nonetheless Herme's speed feat won't help against Wonder Woman on the forum unfortunately. This has all been covered.

So what if he used it on them it's a weapon he had on him for the entire game. he also showed he can beat the king of the gods to death with his bare hands.

I never said it would.

Let's not pollute this thread and throw it off again and get it closed. We'll argue it in a thread or pm's or something. 🙂

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
Let's not pollute this thread and throw it off again and get it closed. We'll argue it in a thread or pm's or something. 🙂
In this thread it doesn't matter. The thread for this thread has already been made. There's nothing to spam.

And

Bayonetta vs. ...?

I'm trying to think who she wouldn't stomp but that she could damage.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
In this thread it doesn't matter. The thread for this thread has already been made. There's nothing to spam.

And

Bayonetta vs. ...?

I'm trying to think who she wouldn't stomp but that she could damage.

kratos