You vs Harry Potter

Started by Sadako of Girth13 pages

Well the logical point of the thread would then be "how you'd you go about beating Potter up..?" or "What would you do to repell his melee attacks...?"
Basing it on shown H2H or melee feats that Potter has.

Fair enough. But only if he could sustain the cricket ball to the happy sack and continue. (Dunno about you, but I probably couldnt even say my own name after that, let alone cast spells.)

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
Considering the wizards considered Sirius Black to be "extremely dangerous" or something to that extent, because he was carrying a gun, I'd say I could kick Harry Potter's ass. Heck yeah.
No, they considered him extremely dangerous because they thought he blew someone to bits with a single spell.

Well if he gets no powers, yeah, most can take him. It's obvious in the OP he does have his powers though.

In one scenario, at least, but that Cricket ball kinda takes care of that.

Well that brings up a question.....How far are you from him?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Well that brings up a question.....How far are you from him?
"10 metres apart."

That's 33 feet. Yeah, Harry rapes.

Not my ass he doesn't. 😂 Why do you give into to his rapings so easily?

How long does it take a ball that moves at 70-100mph to clear that distance?

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Not my ass he doesn't. Why do you give into to his rapings so easily?

How long does it take a ball that moves at 70-100mph to clear that distance?

70 mph = 102.666667 feet per second; 100 mph = 146.666667 feet per second

Of course that's after its thrown. Now as you're setting up to make sure that you throw it like that (full rotation for full power) he could still get off a spell.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Not my ass he doesn't. 😂 Why do you give into to his rapings so easily?

How long does it take a ball that moves at 70-100mph to clear that distance?

Because he has spells that take less than a second to cast and hits it's target. One sectumsempra and you're done, unless you're a bullet timer.

What ball?

Whoa, throw a cricket ball at him? crylaugh

crylaugh Who are you? Nolan ryan? haermm

😛

I'm British: We ALL have them. 😖hifty:

Originally posted by Creshosk
70 mph = 102.666667 feet per second; 100 mph = 146.666667 feet per second

Of course that's after its thrown. Now as you're setting up to make sure that you throw it like that (full rotation for full power) he could still get off a spell.

Thanks for the data.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
😛

I'm British: We ALL have them. 😖hifty:

I'm an ex-ballplayer, dude. I was a catcher and could throw a frozen rope to 2nd in my sleep. There's no way in hell I could nail Harry with a baseball from 33 feet before he spells me. Hell, there's no way in hell a major league baseball player could either. Not to mention Harry can easily dodge it.

There are far more feasible options for weapons. Is it just no firearms, is that the rule here?

Have you ever thrown a cricket ball..?

Thats the way I read it, yes. I was thinking about a crossbow, also.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Have you ever thrown a cricket ball..?

Thats the way I read it, yes. I was thinking about a crossbow, also.

I've hefted one, never thrown one. A ball's a ball, really. I could replicate the frozen rope feat with a softball or even a tennis ball.

Crossbow is a good choice, but to make things fair, you wouldn't be able to have it aimed at Harry. Both of you would be standing with your weapons in hand, not aimed, at your sides, and a crossbow only has one shot. Risky. Plus a protego is gonna block any bolt/bullet/whatever you fire at him.

Your best bet is to have a weapon that can rapid fire and is lightweight with no recoil. Funny as it sounds, I'd choose a paintball gun. Fire away non stop with like 200 paintballs, over and over, advancing as you go, it MIGHT distract him enough to get close enough for cqc.

But that wouldn't work either. Remember poor Aunt Marge?

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Thanks for the data.
You're welcome. I have to at least try to be honest about such things(I say Try cause I might screw up on a calculation or something), even if it isn't favorable to my position.

That is admirable policy. ✅

The protego really is the clincher here. There's literally nothing you can do to get past it. I can think of many ways to get close to Harry, close enough to go h2h, but all I'll hit is the protego.

IF I could get past the shield, a flamethrower would be ideal, but would that be a "gun?"

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I've hefted one, never thrown one. A ball's a ball, really. I could replicate the frozen rope feat with a softball or even a tennis ball.

Crossbow is a good choice, but to make things fair, you wouldn't be able to have it aimed at Harry. Both of you would be standing with your weapons in hand, not aimed, at your sides, and a crossbow only has one shot. Risky. Plus a protego is gonna block any bolt/bullet/whatever you fire at him.

Your best bet is to have a weapon that can rapid fire and is lightweight with no recoil. Funny as it sounds, I'd choose a paintball gun. Fire away non stop with like 200 paintballs, over and over, advancing as you go, it MIGHT distract him enough to get close enough for cqc.

Who says you cant aim at Harry...? Gimping attempt.

This would be like saying "Harry cant start unless hes blindfolded."
But that wouldn't work either. Remember poor Aunt Marge?

Nope. A cricket ball is WAY heavier, smoother and more dense than a soft ball/tennis ball. You get one of them land on you at speed, its pain/broken bones time. And their travel, speed and accuracy, is all part of its secret.

This is again quite different in size, shape mass, air resistance and velocity to etc to a football, as you guys call it, for example..

So nope. I guess a "balls not a ball" after all.