Bane vs Caedus

Started by ares8343 pages
ares834 Senior Member

Probably the worst list I have ever seen.

truejedi Senior Member

He left Ka'sim off of it. End of discussion.

Q99 Senior Member

What's Carnor Jax even doing on a list?

He's no Sith Lord, he's an unfinished apprentice of Lumiya.

And Plagueis right at the top? Aside from his make-life thing, we have no idea of his abilities and he was certainly surpassed by Sidious.

Slash_KMC Retired Helper

I think the list is quite accurate, up until it reaches beyond the top 2. I agree that Revan and Plagious are the top 2 of all time, but beyond that it becomes quite blurry.

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

I approve of Bane, Traya and Nihilus being higher than Sidious. That made me smile. That gave me a little glow.

Slash_KMC Retired Helper

Well, Sidious is a big noob compared to the likes of cognus [wut?] and Sion.

truejedi Senior Member

if KTM is not number one, the list is garbage.

Zampanó The Blind Critic

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
Well, Sidious is a big noob compared to the likes of cognus [wut?] and Sion.

👆
Originally posted by truejedi
if KTM is not number one, the list is garbage.

👆👆👆👆👆👆👆👆

Lord Lucien Lets all love Lain

Originally posted by 3 fishys
WTF
THis is what i think is the most powerful sith list
1.Revan
2.Plagueis
3.Sion
4.Traya
5.nihlius
6.Caedus
7.bane
8.zannah
9.cognus
10.sidious
11.dooku
12.Vader
13.maul
14.Carnor jax
15.krayt
16.lumiya
17.Ruyn
18.Wyyrlock the third
#1 is a tie between KTM and Revan. They occupied separate times, but if measured together, you could never tell one's power apart.

Bandon is rightfully not on this list. I can't stress enough how second-rate this list is compared to the reality of His power.

Q99 Senior Member

I do wonder how "Darth Talon's teacher whom she decapitated" got on the list as well.

Lord Lucien Lets all love Lain

He couldn't name anyone else, so he went with the only ones he knows.

axel_jovan Looking around.
Originally posted by 3 fishys
WTF
THis is what i think is the most powerful sith list
1.Revan
2.Plagueis
3.Sion
4.Traya
5.nihlius
6.Caedus
7.bane
8.zannah
9.cognus
10.sidious
11.dooku
12.Vader
13.maul
14.Carnor jax
15.krayt
16.lumiya
17.Ruyn
18.Wyyrlock the third

😱

Where is Kas'im the Magnificent?! Where is Darth "Badass" Bandon?! Geez, Bane the Ultimate at 7, nuh-uh!

At least you've got #1 right. 😎

Q99 Senior Member

Of course I think Krayt and Wyyrlok should be higher (Wyyrlok only a little, but above Lumiya), especially 'Reborn' Krayt who is no longer limited by having to spend effort to fight off the vong armor constantly ... Maul lower of course, I don't see why he should be on the list... Sion lower...

3 fishys Revan the emperor

If bane wins:

Revan helps bane and rapestorms caedus

If caedus wins:

Revan helps caedus and rapestorms bane