Pinkie Pie
Cupcake Devourer
You both neglect to remember a few things about the Lich King. I can even get a whiff of cognitive bias from your direction 😛 I find it important to point out that while similarities between the Lich King and whatever other character, in this case the Witch-King may exist aplenty it does not neglect two important things ✅
1. The character can still be good, ripoff or not. It doesn't make it a bad character just because another character is a notable inspiration. Lich King doesn't become shitty just because he's not original.
2. Many differences exist as well. That there are more differences than similarities seem to visit only few minds. Why? Because the big things are easier to see. He's evil, he wears a crowned helmet and metal armor, he like his world dark and dead and he likes concealing his face. Good thing the renown and popular Witch-King is there as reference for people to point at 😛
Now that I think about it . . . The Witch-King is our traditional evil villain as well and he wasn't original either. It is such a painful experience to see intelligent men brush something of as a ripoff to the Witch-King when the Witch-King himself is very likely inspired by an again-walker king in Norse mythology who was actually referred to as the Witch-King Thráinn. A dark soul, a crowned king in armor and cloak who forged a dark world.
Don't say something isn't original and then reference to a villain that any younger man or woman with decent creativity who doesn't know of Tolkien would think up given enough time 😛 Should a character deviate from a good character design because it'll make him a cheap ripoff? Not in my world ❌
Although I digress (Fresh start). The point here wasn't that he was alike the Witch-King. The point was that he is a shitty character. Which brings us to the agreeing by our Sailor Hades 😛 The plan that the Lich King set in motion during the Wrath of the Lich King is one of such astonishing complexity that neither of you seem to have picked it up. It was working exactly as intended. It had a few setbacks, unexpected progresses but it never deviated from the trail that the Lich King had set up.
Let me ask you this before you question the brilliance in his plan: What is an army worth if some heroes can swat it like nothing? Now imagine in place of this army a ruler is in control of a force of such power that it top that army and then some! Even in its few numbers it proved itself of greater power than his vast quantities. And that was without the gift of the Lich King 🙂
It wasn't a mistake that they got to the Lich King. It wasn't a mistake that he fought them. It wasn't a mistake that they put up a fight. It was a test and a training exercise! And don't get me started on the rest of the Lich King's life. It's a brilliant character who's getting an unfortunate amount of shit because of a falsely believed original idea called "Witch-King" 😛