Originally posted by TheAuraAngel
"Dared not to" and "Deciding not to" are two different things young chap.
And this is exactly why he dared not to after he got a dose of reality. It wasn't a casual, "Meh. Nevermind. I'll stay behind and do pushups." It was a verbal smack down, "Don't go because you'll just get in the way."
Glad you cleared up that you a Guy fanboy, though.
And you didn't want to type "chap", did you? Ahhhh, the new insult tool: use words of affection that 'seem' legit.
Originally posted by TheAuraAngel
The former indicates fear or hesitation while the latter is merely a decision.
And, clearly, Guy was out of his league and was put in his place. Let's go with, "Guy feared to interfere after hearing sluggy's words."
Let's be more direct and clear, "Guy dared not go after hearing sluggy's words."
It's actuall a bit funny that you're getting hung up on just one word when the outcome was the same: Guy was put in his place.
Play word games all you like, there's not getting around the fact that he was given a verbal smack down on his usual Gung-Ho "fight everything" attitude.
In other words, there's no reason to slobbering all over Guy when Naruto gets to him in this gauntlet.
Originally posted by TheAuraAngel
Guy has no way of knowing about Naruto's Sage Mode or at least I can't think of a way for him to have found out. Guy also has now way of knowing the extent of Pains power but in this regard I can certainly see Guy hesitating to interfere because of what Pain had plainly done.
I disagree on some of that.
Guy didn't know about Naruto's Sage Mode, at the time OR his taijutsu amp from training. This would lead him to step in and help a good friend of their entire team (Think about it, Naruto is a good friend to Neji, Guy, and especially Lee.) He didn't have any data on Pain, just that there's lots of destruction and his home and friends were virtually destroyed.
He would rather fight to the death (because that's his character) than sit around and do nothing. Anyone can clearly see that he would run off to do his best again Pain. HOWEVER, he would just get in the way of Naruto, as we were clearly told. Naruto would have to worry about protecting Guy and Lee in addition to trying to defeat Pain which is why he was given a nice warm cup of STFU.
I guess we do not disagree on this point, entirely. Guy clearly was in over his head against Pain as was anyone else in the village who fought him.
Originally posted by TheAuraAngel
The discussion about backing him up was dropped after the slug thing revealed that Naruto, who had been fighting Pain for a while and knew how to beat him, had a plan. "Getting in his way" does not necessarily mean that Guy would hamper Naruto's fighting with his presence but rather add a variable to his plan at the last minute.
Incorrect. The real reason is this:
"He would rather fight to the death (because that's his character) than sit around and do nothing. Anyone can clearly see that he would run off to do his best again Pain. HOWEVER, he would just get in the way of Naruto, as we were clearly told. Naruto would have to worry about protecting Guy and Lee in addition to trying to defeat Pain which is why he was given a nice warm cup of STFU."
It's a bit retarded to for Guy to think he even stood a slight chance and the reader is supposed to clearly pick up on that. Guy was just staying in his character by wanting to fight an opponent that clearly outclassed him. Again, he would rather die than sit around and do nothing...especially if someone was already at the cutting block.
Originally posted by TheAuraAngel
So no, I do not agree with "Dared not" but rather "Decided not". Besides, it's not like Guy could even find Naruto without the slug things info which it was not going to give. So one could actually argue "Could not."
I like my version better as it stays in character while not showing a bias towards Guy.