Thanos w/HOTU vs God Swamp Thing

Started by King Kandy5 pages

Um, obviously it can be done without. You are basically saying that Retcons don't matter, you're just going to pretend it never happened because the original writing is "sacred". Says who? By that logic Spider-Man is a clone, because the retcon he was the original, we can just do away with.

The retcon pertaining to the Beyonder was stupid and illogical...thats a fact.

You dont agree that it was stupid and illogical?

In my honest opinion, thats reason enough to disregard it; it was PIS...pure and simple.

And you are also going to disregard, the dozens of comics that feature beyonder after the retcon?

well this is no longer fun. uggh

Originally posted by King Kandy
And you are also going to disregard, the dozens of comics that feature beyonder after the retcon?

I seperate it into 2 different characters; Classic Beyonder and Post-retcon Beyonder...

One is utterly omnipotent...the other is not.

And you still avoid the question; the explanation as to how Classic Beyonder was retconned, because the Abstracts/Cosmics were just playing along to aid in its cognitive development, was incredibly stupid and illogical...wasnt it?

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
The retcon pertaining to the Beyonder was stupid and illogical...thats a fact.

You dont agree that it was stupid and illogical?

In my honest opinion, thats reason enough to disregard it; it was PIS...pure and simple.

So you disregard it because you don't like it. Got it.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
So you disregard it because you don't like it. Got it.

I disregard it because its stupid; care to give an explanation as of how the retcons explanation makes sense?

Right...cant do it...cant do it because I'd destroy your explanation utterly and completely...

I challenge anyone here:

Explain the logic in the Abstracts/Cosmics allowing the Beyonder to humiliate them, beat them up, and clearly fearing him...

Explain them feigning all of that just to aid a lowly Cosmic Cube in its cognitive development...

You cant because that explanation is stupid and illogical, thus the entire retcon was illogical...

Classic Beyonder should have never been created in the 1st place, but he was created, so now you gotta deal with it; the explanation to his depowerment was 100% pure PIS...plain and simple.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
I accept it changed...[b]BUT it was BS as the reasoning of the retcon was illogical and stupid.

Do you not agree with this?

Unless you are willing to accept the Abstracts/Cosmics allowing themselves to humilated, beaten up repeatedly, and feigning fear as something logical... [/B]

It's a comic book? Thus fiction... Thus logic doesn't play into anything...you do realize that when reading comics you should suspend your beliefs and logic at the door otherwise the idea of comics goes out the window...

And different writers have different interpretations... Btw your opinion is not as you put it.. FACT...
fact is that the writers.. The company who own the subject material rewrote it

This is a comic book. You paid between 1.99 and 3.99 for it... Accept it for what it is.. A story... And stop trying to apply logic to a comic book. It makes you look as foolish as someone else claiming superman can lift billions of trillions of a boatload of toilets or whatever

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
I challenge anyone here:

Explain the logic in the Abstracts/Cosmics [b]allowing the Beyonder to humiliate them, beat them up, and clearly fearing him...

Explain them feigning all of that just to aid a lowly Cosmic Cube in its cognitive development...

You cant because that explanation is stupid and illogical, thus the entire retcon was illogical...

Classic Beyonder should have never been created in the 1st place, but he was created, so now you gotta deal with it; the explanation to his depowerment was 100% pure PIS...plain and simple. [/B]

Challenge accepted!!
Marvel comics wanted money and thus printed stories.

I win. Thank you for playing. Lol.

Well if we are not to apply logic to anything in a comic, then there is no reason for us to be here debating as we have to apply logic to it for us to do what we are doing...

So since we are arguing about comics and who can beat who, ect, ect...we MUST apply logic...and logically that retcon was utterly stupid and BS ridden.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Well if we are not to apply logic to anything in a comic, then there is no reason for us to be here debating as we have to apply logic to it for us to do what we are doing...

So since we are arguing about comics and who can beat who, ect, ect...we MUST apply logic...and logically that retcon was utterly stupid and BS ridden.

Nope. My opinion says your opinion is wrong.

Originally posted by rotiart
Challenge accepted!!
Marvel comics wanted money and thus printed stories.

I win. Thank you for playing. Lol.

You lose; everytime you login here and attempt to debate, you are attempting to apply logic to comics...

So logic does apply here and since it applies, I can reasonably argue that the Beyonders retcon was utterly ridiculous...

💃

And no...my stance on this issue is not opinion...its fact; unless you can come up with a compelling counter-argument as to how the retcon makes sense.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
You lose; everytime you login here and attempt to debate, you are attempting to apply logic to comics...

So logic does apply here and since it applies, I can reasonably argue that the Beyonders retcon was utterly ridiculous...

💃

.

And
Logically all you have is opinion and what I have is fact...
Fact beats opinion
Logically I win.

You just trying to be an ******* about it, but you know I'm right...

The explanation behind the retcon was illogical...true statement.

I don't think you even know the definition of the word fact at this point...
Please look it up. You have an opinion. Not facts. Please take your fourth grade understanding of the american language out an reapply at least seventh grade level intelligence. Thank you for playing.

Originally posted by rotiart
I don't think you even know the definition of the word fact at this point...
Please look it up. You have an opinion. Not facts. Please take your fourth grade understanding of the american language out an reapply at least seventh grade level intelligence. Thank you for playing.

f**k off...

Cheers!

🙂

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
f**k off...

Cheers!

🙂

I think he wore you down man that usually what happens when the swearing starts.

Originally posted by SuperiorTech
I think he wore you down man that usually what happens when the swearing starts.

He started the insults 1st; I wore him down...

💃