My input devices are perfect, and my screen manages some 280cd/m2. The 2010 13 inch Pro model doesn't have ANY major flaw. I'd never pay 1100 bucks otherwise. But find me a really good 13 inch notebook at 800€ or lower. There are none with these qualities. And if there are some that manage 80% of this, they usually come without optical devices.
Actually, with student options and a special refund campaign, I only paid 920€ instead of 1149. Totally worth the money.
And it's absolutely true that it depends on your needs. I've started using Logic Studio (being a musician) and I love it. If I had to choose a laptop now, I actually wouldn't buy a MacBook Pro (new generation sucks), but probably something like an Acer TimelineX (yeah, no optical drive), and run Ubuntu.