Thor (without Mjolnir) VS Sebastian Shaw

Started by Dum Dum Dugan3 pages

Originally posted by Q99
I would say the amount it took is PIS since we have seen him handle more energy than that, but the main point is it's never said physical force can't overload him and an incident that says it can.

That incident would be pis. U can't pick and chioce which part of it is pis. The fact it overloaded it period is pis, so how on earth can u determine that as legitment limitation to his power, based off pis event?

Think about what ur saying.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
That incident would be pis. U can't pick and chioce which part of it is pis. The fact it overloaded it period is pis, so how on earth can u determine that as legitment limitation to his power, based off pis event?

Think about what ur saying.

Let's put it another way: Do we have any evidence at all that physical force works different than any of the other types of energy that can overload him?

No, no we do not.

Originally posted by Q99
Let's put it another way: Do we have any evidence at all that physical force works different than any of the other types of energy that can overload him?

No, no we do not.


when has he been overloaded by other types of energy?

Do u even have evidence of other types of energy overloading him? I feel this answer is likely no.

Originally posted by Newjak
It was in the Shaw respect thread on the 2nd page.

It was incident where they had Shaw catch his hand. The next panel showed Shaw getting flow into by Namor, and knocked down. It looked to me like Shaw was bleeding from it.


it a little sketchy, but I agree it does look like he bleeding, which supports my theory he can't efficiently absorb 100% of the kinetic energy

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
when has he been overloaded by other types of energy?

Do u even have evidence of other types of energy overloading him? I feel this answer is likely no.

What? Yes, he's been overloaded. Storm's done it.

Originally posted by Q99
What? Yes, he's been overloaded. Storm's done it.

When? Issue and title please.

thor wins,

namor knocked shaw on his ass and had him bleeding(although shaw made namor bleed too) but thor is stronger than namor

Originally posted by ankur29
thor wins,

namor knocked shaw on his ass and had him bleeding(although shaw made namor bleed too) but thor is stronger than namor

Not denying thor wins, but your reasoning is flawed. Namor done the same thing to Hulk that does not mean Thor beating Hulk in h2h.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
When? Issue and title please.

Uncanny X-men 152.

Originally posted by Q99
Uncanny X-men 152.

Isent that because lightning is a form of energy shaw can't absorb? pretty sure that was the same tactic used by pierce, who designed claws that used eletrical attacks, because shaw is unable to absorb them.

If this is the case, what relevence does that have to this fight?

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Isent that because lightning is a form of energy shaw can't absorb? pretty sure that was the same tactic used by pierce, who designed claws that used eletrical attacks, because shaw is unable to absorb them.

If this is the case, what relevence does that have to this fight?

In the OP 2 scenarious were stated for this thread

1. Thor with no lightning
2. Thor with lightning

There's also Astonishing X-men vol 3 #15, wherein after a particularly brutal fight with Colossus he was bruised and injured. He won the fight but the hits were still enough to cause significant damage.

Originally posted by Q99
There's also Astonishing X-men vol 3 #15, wherein after a particularly brutal fight with Colossus he was bruised and injured. He won the fight but the hits were still enough to cause significant damage.

I am pretty sure those were images place in his head by emma and not Shaw at all.