Originally posted by Q99
Considering he focused on sword for many, many years while she's an all-arounder, I'll buy that he's better, but we aren't talking a big gap either.
Also Logan focus upon blades weapons and sword espcially, however he is extremely skilled in the art of numerous weapons.
Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
yes there is with out a doubt a gap. He straight up beat Silver Samurai ass with haft a sword, while he had two swords. Diana has done nothing remotely close to the achievement of swordmanship skill.Also Logan focus upon blades weapons and sword espcially, however he is extremely skilled in the art of numerous weapons.
The gap isn't large enough for Logan to overcome Diana's absurd strength advantage.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I guess I don't see the point in bringing up "well, if character A had ______ and character B didn't have _______ than A would clearly beat B."
Originally posted by wildernesss
logan will keep healing; WW will not. logan wins scenario 2 that I posted in the opening post.
Yeah, he'll heal. It won't really mean anything if the wound itself is grievous enough to incapacitate Logan long enough to make him unable to fight or defend himself, which is well within Diana's ability to do so.
Originally posted by Cogito
She'll keep dicing him like an onion, except she won't cry cutting him up
logan has regenerated from a skeleton before. Jean Grey Phoenix restores logan from death on a spiritual level; Therefore, WW will eventually tire. logan won't stop regenerating & will eventually defeat her in scenario 2. it could take days, months, years. who knows; but logan will win.
Originally posted by wildernesss
logan will keep healing; WW will not. logan wins scenario 2 that I posted in the opening post.
One, if you're so sure, why make the thread?
Two, nah. As said, once he loses his sword due to damage sustained or from being flung into the air from hits, she'll just use it.
Originally posted by Q99
One, if you're so sure, why make the thread?Two, nah. As said, once he loses his sword due to damage sustained or from being flung into the air from hits, she'll just use it.
cause i'm not sure about scenario one. scenario 2 I'm was UNSURE
about until some rather lame WW feats surfaced.
I said no grabbing in the op rules; this would include grabbing the opponents sword. especially when the opponent is knocked down; she has to use her own sword.
Originally posted by wildernesss
logan has regenerated from a skeleton before. Jean Grey Phoenix restores logan from death on a spiritual level; Therefore, WW will eventually tire. logan won't stop regenerating & will eventually defeat her in scenario 2. it could take days, months, years. who knows; but logan will win.
WW cuts electrons off atoms. I don't care how good his healing factor is, its not going to reattach electrons. It could take days, months, years. who knows; WW will win.
Edit: After reconsidering, I don't know how Logan heals from nothing. The guy pulls the matter to create new cells out of nowhere, so hell, maybe he can reattach electrons, as stupid as that is.
Originally posted by wildernesss
cause i'm not sure about scenario one. scenario 2 I'm was UNSURE
about until some rather lame WW feats surfaced.
So you were unsure until you found out some stuff that showed she had beaten some legendary warriors in swordfights, and that made you decide she was weaker?
Chains of events don't work that way. You were 'sure' ahead of time (heck, beforehand you were arguing she only had 1/3rd his skill) and simply decided to not change your stance when new information said otherwise.
I said no grabbing in the op rules; this would include grabbing the opponents sword. especially when the opponent is knocked down; she has to use her own sword.
I sense goalpost shifting. There's a big difference between grabbing an opponent and using a sword lying there.
Also, aside from that sword it is rather unclear just what *can* kill Wolverine.
Hm..... one option is to simply hit the sword with her sword hard enough to inflict major wounds on him 🙂 Grabbing is not required.
Originally posted by Q99
So you were unsure until you found out some stuff that showed she had beaten some legendary warriors in swordfights, and that made you decide she was weaker?Chains of events don't work that way. You were 'sure' ahead of time (heck, beforehand you were arguing she only had 1/3rd his skill) and simply decided to not change your stance when new information said otherwise.
I sense goalpost shifting. There's a big difference between grabbing an opponent and using a sword lying there.
Also, aside from that sword it is rather unclear just what *can* kill Wolverine.
Hm..... one option is to simply hit the sword with her sword hard enough to inflict major wounds on him 🙂 Grabbing is not required.
Claw is legendary? who knew? she has one example of NOT winning against a legendary warrior (singular). she doesn't have the feats to suggest she's anywhere near logan with a sword.
I don't care if you sense goalpost shifting; i was remiss in not specifically stating it, but when I said "no grabbing, etc" I meant they must use their own swords.
power equals strength x speed. WW has no super speed here & thus her striking power with a sword would be dimished enough for logan to parry and/or evade her heavy cumbersome attacks. logan wins 🙂