Darth Caedus vs. Exar Kun

Id say Anakin Solo was Luke's greatest student. Kyp can be 2nd. Kyp is definately top 10.

Jacen is first IMO.

Edit: By this I mean Luke's top student.

If this is the strongest incarnation of each, Caedus wins with ease, since that would be the incarnation that fought Onimini.

Which was plot-induced uberness. By that kind of logic, Zonakin is a verifiable and usable versus entity, and can stalemate Force-unity Caedus.

Nah. In the Essential Guide to the Force Caedus was called the most powerful force incarnation ever. Zonakin was just Anakin tapping into his potential there wasn't really any force oneness going on.

But the fact remains that it was an isolated event. Also, Nihilus eats Force. Therefore, he eats Caedus. QED.

What does Nihilus have to do with anything? But yes it was an isolated event and, IIRC, it was staed he would never be able to preform such a feat again.

Originally posted by ares834
Jacen is first IMO.

Edit: By this I mean Luke's top student.

If by "top" you mean "failed" then I agree.

I meant top as in most powerful of course. Afterall, I wouldn't say Kyp Durron is a model student either.

That is why I said Anakin Solo was his top.

But Kyp as second... 😬

I mean he blew up some stars.

Wow, none of Lukes students did very well did they?

Dessann, Jacen, Kyp, Anakin, probably a few more I dont care about..... not a good track record. No wonder all he worked for gets destroyed a few decades after his death.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Wow, none of Lukes students did very well did they?

Dessann, Jacen, Kyp, Anakin, probably a few more I dont care about..... not a good track record. No wonder all he worked for gets destroyed a few decades after his death.

Well at least the Chosen Ones sacrifice still has some actual meaning and shit amiright?

Urnawtrite.

pewp.

The one decent thing Lucas could have done is tell all the NJO authors not to bring back the Sith.

Even the Old Republic is full of too many Sith and Sith invasions. It seems Coruscant is conquered every other day.

In a franchise were the heroes are always Jedi, it made sense to make the only antagonists capable of opposing them the brand-name friendly Sith.

He ruined his movies though. He just says, "Oh my story in the movies is my own world. There isn't any story after ROTJ." That's such a piss poor excuse.

Honestly, when I found out Sidious comes back, that destroyed any ray of hope I had for George Lucas and his management of this franchise.

I honestly don't think he's too aware of the EU. Apparently he's never bothered to read any of the novels. Say what will you about him, but he's at least adamant that "his" universe is his. Contributors get their own and pay financial homage. I can understand him not caring about the rest very much, unless it's interfering with his.