Thor vs Hulk- Brute strength

Started by -Pr-13 pages
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Not even Kal?

I thought we were just talking about Marvel lol.

Out of any herald, I'd say Kal is the most likely to last against (and possibly beat) Hulk, assuming this current amp is temporary.

Thor is close behind though.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I thought we were just talking about Marvel lol.

Out of any herald, I'd say Kal is the most likely to last against (and possibly beat) Hulk, assuming this current amp is temporary.

Thor is close behind though.

Ok, gotcha.

Yeah, in a purely physical contest, I'd be more inclined to side with Superman than Thor if I wanted Hulk KTFO. In a all powers go thing, I'd probably pick Thor.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Ok, gotcha.

Yeah, in a purely physical contest, I'd be more inclined to side with Superman than Thor if I wanted Hulk KTFO. In a all powers go thing, I'd probably pick Thor.

Naturally I'd pick Kal anyway, but I'd agree that Thor has more options available to him, definitely.

Originally posted by Stoic
The entire problem with this thread is that it's full of shit. The moment that the Hulks strength raises above Thor's he auto looses... How long is this farce going to continue? This thread seems to be a way for Thoraniacs to pull they're d@cks out and dance around the fact, that a scenario like this would never happen.

Lol.

Also, that's bullshit. Without his healing factor, damage will eventually take it's toll. If Thor fights intelligently for the first time, I'd pick him. If he stands there and slugs it out, it'll be a battle of endurance. Unfortunately, I don't know how much of Hulk's damage soak was depended on his healing factor so he's the safer bet.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Naturally I'd pick Kal anyway, but I'd agree that Thor has more options available to him, definitely.

Yeah. Plus, Thor using all of his powers on Hulk would be more fitting because of those options; he would put him in his place.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Lol.

Also, that's bullshit. Without his healing factor, damage will eventually take it's toll. If Thor fights intelligently for the first time, I'd pick him. If he stands there and slugs it out, it'll be a battle of endurance. Unfortunately, I don't know how much of Hulk's damage soak was depended on his healing factor so he's the safer bet.

Wait, Hulk has no healing factor? Shit... mmm

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Yeah. Plus, Thor using all of his powers on Hulk would be more fitting because of those options; he would put him in his place.

True.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I thought we were just talking about Marvel lol.

Out of any herald, I'd say Kal is the most likely to last against (and possibly beat) Hulk, assuming this current amp is temporary.

Thor is close behind though.

It depends on the scenario really.

In a brawl type situation, I don't see the difference between the two. Thor's one of the few characters that can take a punch practically as well as Superman and might be the only non rejuvenating character I think has more stamina than Clark. And since the strength edge isn't major, if the Hulk's strong enough to start beating up Thor, chances are he's strong enough to start beating up Clark.

In a close up fight, Clark would safest bet. Speed will be a real asset if he decides to cranks it up. All powers and such, you'd have to take Thor though.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Wait, Hulk has no healing factor? Shit... mmm

Well yea.

Originally posted by -Pr-
😂

i never thought i'd see a man u gif on this forum...

i see you heard about their last match......

Originally posted by -Pr-
I thought we were just talking about Marvel lol.

Out of any herald, I'd say Kal is the most likely to last against (and possibly beat) Hulk, assuming this current amp is temporary.

Thor is close behind though.

you do realize "that superman" doesn't even exist anymore right?

grandpa is not going to show up for thanksgiving dinner son biscuits

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
It depends on the scenario really.

In a brawl type situation, I don't see the difference between the two. Thor's one of the few characters that can take a punch practically as well as Superman and might be the only non rejuvenating character I think has more stamina than Clark. And since the strength edge isn't major, if the Hulk's strong enough to start beating up Thor, chances are he's strong enough to start beating up Clark.

In a close up fight, Clark would safest bet. Speed will be a real asset if he decides to cranks it up. All powers and such, you'd have to take Thor though.

I disagree because of personal preference, but I find no fault in your logic.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
i see you heard about their last match......

you do realize "that superman" doesn't even exist anymore right?

grandpa is not going to show up for thanksgiving dinner son biscuits

The Everton one? Yes, we won quite comfortably. And that's all we shall say about Man U. sneer

Quiet you.

Thor really is a brawl kinda guy and so is Hulk but IMO Hulk really wades into situations where he knows his healing will help him.

When he was seperated from banner(after the onslaught saga) didn't he have to wear a leg brace? I realize this Hulk Incarnation is stronger/tougher but unless he just amps super fast and 2 hit ko's Thor it's not looking good for him.

Originally posted by -Pr-
The Everton one? Yes, we won quite comfortably. And that's all we shall say about Man U. sneer
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus

Go f*ck yourself.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Go f*ck yourself.

😂

United fans should just give up.

One bad game isn't going to kill a season. We were due a heavy loss anyways. Better that it happen now than in May anyway.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Of course it's relevant, but using that logic as the only reason for him being beyond Thor....well it's flawed. Fortunately you realize it goes both ways, hence the backtracking. Might as well argue Thor would one shot the Sentry.

What about Siege lead you believe that Sentry was above Thor? The Void I can understand, but the Sentry persona? Crazy talk.

Why would you stick to strictly non Siege feats, and that was a Void influenced Sentry. There's a noticeably difference in power between the Sentry, a Void influenced Sentry, and a manifested Void which Siege illustrated.

That isn't the only reason but against the Hulk he did what Thor was never capable of against a more formidable Hulk than Thor has ever went up against/

The fact Thor was completely at his mercy until Loki amped the heroes and gave them a second chance. The fact Thor was fighting with an entire team against a character who just destroyed ares, asgard, and his brother Loki.

You can't separate all his feats into little arcs just because you know what I say is true. The Sentry/Void is far more powerful than Thor. No shame there just accept it.

As to the thread Hulk, obviously.

^^Heh, most embarassing loss of fergusons career by his own admission. I cried tears of joy.lol

Originally posted by -Pr-
One bad game isn't going to kill a season. We were due a heavy loss anyways. Better that it happen now than in May anyway.

If I was on Utd, I'd burn my jersey.

My favorite part of the game right there.

Originally posted by Naija boy
^^Heh, most embarassing loss of fergusons career by his own admission. I cried tears of joy.lol

I was laughing my ass off.

too soon guys

@ Quanchi, The problem with saying obviously Hulk wins in terms of this particular thread, is that Thor is a world breaker type character as well if he isn't holding back, and goes all rabid (Warrior Madness is a real option for him in other words). The moment that the Hulk matches him in strength, a Grand Master type character pops up scratches his ass, and says you lose. Thor can't lose in this particular thread.

@ Rage, Thor being more powerful than the Hulk at this point is subjective, wouldn't you agree? Think about it before you answer.