Thor (Without Mjolnir) VS Wolverine ---Revised Thread

Started by D-Block16 pages

Quick question anyone has Wolverine ever stabbed Thor or has he just scratched him before? I've seen the Arm scan but it's been a while.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Wolverine never fought X-Cutioner.

Gauntlet and X-Cutioner are two different characters. Sheesh.

You are correct, it was X-cutioner's Song. I looked at the issue, Bishop asks Wolvie if he's ok and in Wolvie's reply he says he has cracked ribs. That's pretty specific to me. I'm thinking it's a matter of simply not paying attention. On the other hand, it's a whopper of a boo-boo.

Even if I got the character that did it wrong, he still had a rib cracked by a below cl 100 character.

Originally posted by D-Block
Quick question anyone has Wolverine ever stabbed Thor or has he just scratched him before? I've seen the Arm scan but it's been a while.
marvel has a policy of not letting its big names get maimed unless you can heal

so you have wolverine who can slice up hulk real well

but you'll never have wolverine cut thor or even captain america badly because those two would be maimed or crippled

ie, wolverine did cut off King thor's arm straight off (that was ok, since king thor was only a temporary character)

so, in short, wolverine can easily cut thor apart, but Marvel would never allow it

He's scratched him with slashes that his Asgardian skin resisted mostly. He also stabbed him and didn't do any fatal damage.

Thor also healed fairly quickly from them, too.

And no, Wolverine NEVER cut off King Thor's arm.

I don't get why people keep assuming he did.

Originally posted by Starscream M
marvel has a policy of not letting its big names get maimed unless you can heal

so you have wolverine who can slice up hulk real well

but you'll never have wolverine cut thor or even captain america badly because those two would be maimed or crippled

ie, wolverine did cut off King thor's arm straight off (that was ok, since king thor was only a temporary character)

so, in short, wolverine can easily cut thor apart, but Marvel would never allow it

Wolverine did not cut KT's arm off.

Can Thor not summon wind and storms? Maybe no need for Storm-level control, but how gimped is he by having no Mjolnir?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Even if I got the character that did it wrong, he still had a rib cracked by a below cl 100 character.

Assuming he was being literal... which he clearly wasn't.

Yes, he can still summon wind and storms without Mjolnir, but per the OP, he's not allowed to. Of course, that's a smart move banning him from doing so, because if he did, the fight would still be spite.

As is, Thor wins the majority.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I don't get why people keep assuming he did.

Because Wolverine slashed at him, Thor is then shown holding his arm above some slash marks, and then his arm is gone. Do the math. Comics are written to be digested by children, the simplest answer is probably the right one, the idea that Thor lost his arms by some unknown attack off panel is - frankly - absurd.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Assuming he was being literal... which he clearly wasn't.

Even if he wasn't being literal about it being cracked, it still injured him...otherwise he'd have said he was fine. So the example still counts as being hurt/injured by below cl 100 force.

Therefore you have to post at least 168 examples of Wolverine taking cl 100 hits.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Because Wolverine slashed at him, Thor is then shown holding his arm above some slash marks, and then his arm is gone. Do the math. Comics are written to be digested by children, the simplest answer is probably the right one, the idea that Thor lost his arms by some unknown attack off panel is - frankly - absurd.

His arm isn't shown as gone until after his fight with the Hulk and Thing.

Thanks for the info Jake and Starscream M. Thats what I thought Jake Thor Skin Was tough enough that Wolverine would not have the strength or have not shown it to make any serious wounds. Thanks for the scans also.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Because Wolverine

Yeah, I'm aware that this is the reason most of the nonsense is spewed.

He still had both arms when he fought Hulk and Thing, without the OF mind you.

Trying to cite that Wolverine de-limbed Thor is phucking retarded, tbh.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Yes, he can still summon wind and storms without Mjolnir, but per the OP, he's not allowed to. Of course, that's a smart move banning him from doing so, because if he did, the fight would still be spite.

As is, Thor wins the majority.

Actually the OP just said no Mjolnir/lightning...that still leaves things like rain, wind, hail etc

Originally posted by Silent Master
Actually the OP just said no Mjolnir/lightning...that still leaves things like rain, wind, hail etc

I'm sure they'll be banned too.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Even if he wasn't being literal about it being cracked, it still injured him...otherwise he'd have said he was fine. So the example still counts as being hurt/injured by below cl 100 force.

Therefore you have to post at least 168 examples of Wolverine taking cl 100 hits.

He injured Wolverine with an energy blast, which very well could have been - and likely was - the equivalent of a class 100 blow, considering he has advanced futuristic weaponry courtesy of Apocalypse. Anyway, Wolverine was only injured for a panel or two, then he was right back in the battle fighting off hundreds of enemies.

Wolverine has baseline human durability, he can get hurt by anything that would hurt a standard human, but he heals. What you need to find are examples where he was koed by less then class 100 blows.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank

I don't get why people keep assuming he did.

jake, logan did cut off king thor's arm. in your scan, you can see king thor clutching his arm...it was prob only held up by tendons.

it fell off later.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
He injured Wolverine with an energy blast, which very well could have been - and likely was - the equivalent of a class 100 blow, considering he has advanced futuristic weaponry courtesy of Apocalypse. Anyway, Wolverine was only injured for a panel or two, then he was right back in the battle fighting off hundreds of enemies.

Wolverine has baseline human durability, he can get hurt by anything that would hurt a standard human, but he heals. What you need to find are examples where he was koed by less then class 100 blows.

Prove that the energy blast was equal to a cl 100 hit.

BTW, even ignoring that one...you'd still have to post 144 examples for Wolverine in order to back up your claim.

Originally posted by Starscream M
jake, logan did cut off king thor's arm. in your scan, you can see king thor clutching his arm...it was prob only held up by tendons.

it fell off later.

Prove it.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Prove it.
in the scan where KT kills captain america, his left arm (the one logan sliced) is missing

gee, coincidence? I think not.