Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Basically, Carver wants you to remove any feat of Superman's that requires flight, has assistance in any way, even if said assistance isn't contributing much less taking away from Superman's strength, get rid of anything that borders on the absurd, even for comics, and accept that Hulk is the strongest one there is.
Naah, and this isn't about Hulk.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Its a black hole.Black holes are infinite in mass.
Half of infinity is still...well, infinity. Assuming of course, that Stewart was doing 50% of the effort, but judging from the casual way he's talking and0 the thickness of his construct's beam, I'm assuming that he's not. But feel free to argue that he is doing more than 50% of the work, please do.
If it was anything else (lifting the Earth, 150 billion ton mountain etc) and Superman did it with help - well, I will concede, and there is no way I would claim it all 100% as Superman's feat.
Originally posted by carver9I don't need to prove a negative. It was never stated that Hal did anything more than create the construct. That, coupled with him explicitly telling Superman to "pull [the earth] harder", is all the proof I need.
I'm well aware of the scene...I want to see something stating that Hal didn't participate in pulling the Earth which would be stupid since he is well capable of pulling things with his contructs. Why wouldn't he help Superman when its within his power to do so? Alan, I usually agree with almost everything you say but this one...oh hell naw.
Supes pulled. Hal maintained the construct. /debate
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Basically, Carver wants you to remove any feat of Superman's that requires flight, has assistance in any way, even if said assistance isn't contributing much less taking away from Superman's strength, get rid of anything that borders on the absurd, even for comics, and accept that Hulk is the strongest one there is.
Originally posted by Galan007
I don't need to prove a negative. It was never stated that Hal did anything more than create the construct. That, coupled with him explicitly telling Superman to "pull [the earth] harder", is all the proof I need.Supes pulled. Hal maintained the construct. /debate
It's the same thing here. Obviously the harness construct is doing all the work.
Originally posted by Galan007
I don't need to prove a negative. It was never stated that Hal did anything more than create the construct. That, coupled with him explicitly telling Superman to "pull [the earth] harder", is all the proof I need.Supes pulled. Hal maintained the construct. /debate
He asked Superman to pull harder which doesn't take away from the fact that he was pulling as well.
