Classic Strange vs Odin

Started by carver93 pages

Classic Strange vs Odin

Both at their peaks. Can't use outside tools like the Destroyer, etc, etc..

Who wins?

I'm still giving it to Odin 9/10. The one win I give Strange is in case he pulls something spectacular from his butt.

Odin 7-8/10

odin

I say Odin, but I'm shocked that the Dr. Strange fans on here didn't chime up more .

Odin wins.

headbutt ftw 😛

Odin.

Hmm.. tough call. Classic Dr. Strange can kill a hungry Galactus with a simple gesture,

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/59088/1895915-strangevsgalactus1_super.jpg
http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/59088/1895918-strangevsgalactus2_super.jpg

whereas Odin can only momentarily KO a reasonably-well-fed Galactus,

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/6/67064/2023348-odin_vs_galactus.jpg

AFAIK, Odin doesn't have many showings against the higher cosmic powers such as the Living Tribunal, Mistress Death, Eternity and the Infinity Gauntlet (whereas Classic Strange does), so there are not many common measuring sticks... Well, maybe Surtur and Ymir, which were little more than toys to Classic Dr. Strange:

http://img224.imageshack.us/img224/4679/avengers06119kz0.jpg

So if I based my opinion objectively on feats alone, I'd have to say Classic Dr. Strange every time. However, in this case I'm willing to - perhaps irrationally - give the old Skyfather some credit and vote for...

A Draw. 5/10 for both combatants.

will strange be willing to call on black magic?

Classic Strange ftw , if Ymir and Surtur are toys to him then he is >> odin

Originally posted by KMC USER
Classic Strange ftw , if Ymir and Surtur are toys to him then he is >> odin
Strange has much more variable feats though. High and Low.

Steve at his best can compete with Odin and pull off a few.

Odin wins, but Doc at his best would give him a good fight.

Originally posted by Magnon
Hmm.. tough call. Classic Dr. Strange can kill a hungry Galactus with a simple gesture,

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/59088/1895915-strangevsgalactus1_super.jpg
http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/59088/1895918-strangevsgalactus2_super.jpg

whereas Odin can only momentarily KO a reasonably-well-fed Galactus,

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/6/67064/2023348-odin_vs_galactus.jpg

AFAIK, Odin doesn't have many showings against the higher cosmic powers such as the Living Tribunal, Mistress Death, Eternity and the Infinity Gauntlet (whereas Classic Strange does), so there are not many common measuring sticks... Well, maybe Surtur and Ymir, which were little more than toys to Classic Dr. Strange:

http://img224.imageshack.us/img224/4679/avengers06119kz0.jpg

So if I based my opinion objectively on feats alone, I'd have to say Classic Dr. Strange every time. However, in this case I'm willing to - perhaps irrationally - give the old Skyfather some credit and vote for...

A Draw. 5/10 for both combatants.

I'm not sure if the two are interchangeable. Galactus is a creature whose entire existence is based on the struggle to survive, and he is also a character based on super science (glaring weakness)? Whereas Odin is a character based on mysticism, and does not have to fight off the ever increasing hunger that serves only to weaken him as any particular battle with a worthy opponent proceeds.

Odin wins imo.

Odin should get a good majority

Strange at his best wins. Anything less from the Doctor cedes the day to the All-Father.

Re: Classic Strange vs Odin

Originally posted by carver9
Both at their peaks. Can't use outside tools like the Destroyer, etc, etc..

Who wins?

Strange, with ease.

Originally posted by Laminator_X
Strange at his best wins. Anything less from the Doctor cedes the day to the All-Father.
under these stips I side with strange overall... on the condition this is each of them at their absolute most powerful under there own power. At his height Strange is a universal scale character when operating under the full heading of the sorcerer supreme on par with the ancient one. That said on his absolute peak days I'd put him over Odin with ease. Anything else is much more hit and miss and i give Odin majority if they get no outside artifacts and powers.

not enough tricks for bag to use

odin is a 'god' strange is a mystic with a bag of hope 😂