Immortal Hercules vs... Classic Thor

The Lion of Olympus has his Golden Mace; Thor has Mjolnir but none of its exotic abilities....

who wins?

Herc but with powers included, Thor.

Thor, with or without "exotic" powers.

Quick question, do yo consider Thor/Mjolnir's weather manip powers as "exotic"? Cause if no, then Thor stomps.

Split on average.

Originally posted by carver9
Herc

❌

Split

if thor's using the hammer as herc uses the mace, he'd def take some, maybe a split. normally thor+hammer are just too versatile though.

Maybe a split?

absolutely if thor's using the hammer as just a club.

Thor definitely gets 50 of the wins I don't think it's debatable.

out of 100 i agree. 😄

I just keep picture Herc showing against Hulk. He was working Hulk.

Originally posted by leonidas
out of 100 i agree. 😄

As long as you don't think Hercules wins the majority then we're cool.

Originally posted by carver9
I just keep picture Herc showing against Hulk. He was working Hulk.

So it that why you think he wins despite history indicating that you're wrong?

It was a good example of skill over strength, but Thor isn't Hulk. On the best day Hercules has ever had, his only slightly superior to the Odinson in unarmed combat. At his best, the Odinson holds his own advantages.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
As long as you don't think Hercules wins the majority then we're cool.

😂

whew.....

Originally posted by leonidas
😂

whew.....

You dodged a real bullet there but you best watch your step.

Regarding the fight, is Thor limited to using Mjolnir only as a club or can he get creative and spin it etc.?

Thor 6-7/10

no just as a mallet...no flight, no bfr, no soul suck, no god blast( even though he wouldnt get it off in a forum battle0 etc........imo sans mjolnir they are interchangeable

If Thor has his hammer in the fight, I can't see how he even loses once.

If Thor doesn't use his hammer, and Thor doesn't fight like an idiot, Thor still wins 9/10, IMO.

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
If Thor has his hammer in the fight, I can't see how he even loses once.

If Thor doesn't use his hammer, and Thor doesn't fight like an idiot, Thor still wins 9/10, IMO.

u see thor as that much greater than herc?

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
If Thor has his hammer in the fight, I can't see how he even loses once.

If Thor doesn't use his hammer, and Thor doesn't fight like an idiot, Thor still wins 9/10, IMO.

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
do you read thor comics? if you did you would know everytime they fight it was stalemate

Did you know Spiderman has a winning record over the Hulk if we go by fights between the two? If we're basing everything on fights I can make some REALLY ridiculous claims over who would beat who.

Did you know Thor 98% of the time fights like a complete moron who doesn't even remember 199 of his 200 powers? Have you seen how much different Thor and Hercules are treated when you compare common enemies? And if you want to start comparing feats we can go that way too.