Manga comparison thread

1. One Piece
2. Bleach
3. Naruto

One Piece pretty definitively kicked the arses of both this week. Monet is a fun villain and I dig the fight.

Bleach I put above Naruto because quite honestly I love the reveal. How could I not? haermm

Naruto dropped a bit. I've loved the Obito flashback but here it was a bit sporadic and left me wanting more. But I'm glad to be back in the fight, which is awesome. Kakashi better not beat Obito though. :T

One Piece
Naruto
Bleach
Toriko

This makes me a sad panda. :C

Originally posted by AuraAngel

One Piece pretty definitively kicked the arses of both this week. Monet is a fun villain and I dig the fight.

Caeser may have the more dangerous fruit, but she seems the smarter, more skilled, and cooler headed.

Indeed. Really I feel more bad for Mocha discovering that Monet was a villain than Brownbeard not realizing that Caesar was lol evil.

That and she seems to be a better threat. Sure Caesar beat the Straw Hats but he messed things up by not killing them. Now that they know his hax he's done for.

1. Bleach
2. One Piece

Bleach was exactly what I expected, with the exception of some of Aizen's trickery(which I kinda liked). Looks to be interesting so I'll just wait and see.

One Piece was bullshit.

You know how a lot of the time when new manga comes out, we rank which series had the best chapter that week?

Both Bleach and One Piece sucked this week.

1) Fairy Tail
2) One Piece
3) Bleach

FT wins pretty solidly.

Originally posted by P8ers86ons1
You know how a lot of the time when new manga comes out, we rank which series had the best chapter that week?

Not really. We do that?

Vinland Saga is the best chap this week.

Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
Vinland Saga is the best chap this week.

1. Vinland Saga
2. One Piece
3. Bleach

[list=1][*]Bleach 514: 8/10[/list]

Bleach not up yet, but so far:

1) Fairy Tail
2) Claymore
3) One Piece
4) Naruto

Strong week.

[list=1][*]Berserk 332: 7/10[*]Gantz 373: 5/10[*]Naruto 608: 5/10[*]Bleach 515: 3/10[/list=1]Horrible week.

People read Gantz?

Originally posted by NemeBro
People read Gantz?

another one piece chapter I give no shits about. Go back to law or smoker and vergo please. Please dear god.

Naruto was ok I guess.

Bleach was hilarious

The thing about Naruto is on it's own it's not bad, but it's very similar to several other chapters we just had.

Bleach was hilarious

Yep, you got some bandages, one new eyepatch, and two 'dead' good characters are alive... at least wounds aren't insta-vanishing but really, they have Orihime, they can heal anything.

It gets 5th place.

I liked One Piece, but let's face it, it's not the kind of chapter that makes the series awesome.

Naruto was pretty average too.

1. One Piece
2. Naruto
3. Bleach

I liked OP and Naruto but Naruto had that retarded line from Kakashi dragging it down.

Bleach was the real trash. Obito, you ain't seen nothing til you kamui over to the true world of hell.

1. One Piece
2. Naruto
3. Bleach

One Piece and Naruto are really interchangeable to me but I put OP in first for no particular reason. Naruto had some neat action and character progression but Kakashi's dumbness held it back. One Piece also had a lot of good character development but felt a tad padded.

Bleach, no lie, was easily going to win first place until the line about Kenpachi and Byakuya. I absolutely love scenes between Ichigo and Rukia because they're consistent and organic. Nothing feels forced and it's all natural. But the fact that those two lived really hurts the story because it doesn't give the impression that anyone can go. This one reveal really hurts the weight of the arc and basically tarnishes a darn near perfect chapter, the idiocy of Yamamoto not knowing how to use medics.