If you had to make an absolute top ten list--No ties

Started by Blair Wind12 pages

Hey guys, no one cares.

This isn't the thread to be having the debate in, so stop it. It's your personal list of favorite characters. If someone posts something you don't agree with, who gives a shit? If you don't think that person is being honest, who gives a shit?

Bada's going to wipe out all your unneeded comments anyway.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Sigh of all sighs.

Cosighed

I didn't realize I was posting this in this thread...my bad Quan.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Sigh of all sighs.
PM me and I'll delete posts.

Edit: Deleted the posts.

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Hey guys, no one cares.

This isn't the thread to be having the debate in, so stop it. It's your personal list of favorite characters. If someone posts something you don't agree with, who gives a shit? If you don't think that person is being honest, who gives a shit?

Bada's going to wipe out all your unneeded comments anyway.

^^This.

I'll put this as nicely as I can. I have no problem closing and banning all threads which aren't vs threads. So you all have 2 choices: Stop spamming non-versus threads with petty arguments or follow the thread topics. And FYI, this includes the Character Ownage thread. And I'm not above handing out mass warnings.

Originally posted by carver9
I didn't realize I was posting this in this thread...my bad Quan.
😐

Lol..I really didn't know. Even though me and Quan clearly disagree with each other all the time, I wouldn't do him like that. My bad buddy. Let's get back on topic...I have the best list in this thread.

Hard to pin down 10 favorites. The first 6 are definite favorites. The last 4 are favorites, but they might switch out every now and then for other favorites.

Iron Man
Green Lantern (Hal)
Batman
Green Lantern (Kyle)
Calvin and Hobbs
Rayne Summers
Nightwing
Spider Man
Robin (Tim Drake)
Static Shock

Originally posted by Blair Wind

Static Shock
Rly?

I read his entire original run - kind of upset that they ended it on a cliffhanger (not in the good way) but couldn't finish the story because they ran out of money. I also watched the cartoon series as a kid.

I haven't read anything of his since so I can't judge for his re-makes.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol..I really didn't know. Even though me and Quan clearly disagree with each other all the time, I wouldn't do him like that. My bad buddy. Let's get back on topic...I have the best list in this thread.
Too late, I just warned you 15 times! osheet
Originally posted by Blair Wind
Hard to pin down 10 favorites. The first 6 are definite favorites. The last 4 are favorites, but they might switch out every now and then for other favorites.

Iron Man
Green Lantern (Hal)
Batman
Green Lantern (Kyle)
Calvin and Hobbs
Rayne Summers
Nightwing
Spider Man
Robin (Tim Drake)
Static Shock

My favorites tend to vary depending on what I'm reading, arcs, etc. But my top 4-6 are always consistent.

Originally posted by Badabing
My favorites tend to vary depending on what I'm reading, arcs, etc. But my top 4-6 are always consistent.

👆

1. Lucifer Morningstar
2. Spider Jerusalem
3. John Constantine
4. Dream of the Endless
5. Silver Surfer
6. Casanova Quinn
7. V
8. Thanos
9. Jesse Custer
10. Kid Loki

Originally posted by Blair Wind
I read his entire original run - kind of upset that they ended it on a cliffhanger (not in the good way) but couldn't finish the story because they ran out of money. I also watched the cartoon series as a kid.

I haven't read anything of his since so I can't judge for his re-makes.

Would you recommend his original run? I have it downloaded, just never got around to reading it.

Depends on the type of stories you like. He's more of the Spiderman of Milestone comics. If you like that type of character, go for it.

So I got bored at work (seriously) and broke down the responses so far based on number of selection in the top 10 and average position (from those who actually ordered them).

There were a couple people I didn't include because they have 20 lists and I didn't know what to do with them. I considered everyone's list as a ranked ordering unless otherwise stated in the post, for simplicity sake. To eliminate some variables, I grouped all the Flashes together as most people just said "Flash". Some other characters I divided if I felt they were different enough. I also may have duplicated a few names, so sue me.

A few highlights first:
There were 170 different characters listed
108 of those were unique to a single person's list
Avg. Rank only includes those on lists that were ranked. "In no particular order" did not get factored in to Avg. Rank.

I've listed here all the characters that made it onto at least two lists.
Among the Surprises/Notables:
-Wonder Woman made only 1 list
-Captain Mar-vell made 1 list
-Nova made 1 list
-Swamp Thing made 1 list
-Dr. Strange made only 2 lists
-Aquaman (3) made as many lists as Wolverine (3)

And the list (ordered by # lists):
[# lists made] [Avg Rank] Character Name

[19][5.3] Thor
[19][6.1] Spiderman
[17][4.2] Superman
[14][3.6] Batman
[14][4.9] Dr. Doom
[14][6.1] Silver Surfer
[13][4.2] Thanos
[10][3.9] Hulk
[9][5.3] Captain America
[8][4.7] Galactus
[8][7] Black Adam
[8][5] Magneto
[8][3.9] Flash
[7][4.4] Captain Marvel
[7][5.6] John Constantine
[6][6] Darkseid
[6][7.5] Joker
[6][3.2] Lucifer
[5][6.3] Hal Jordan
[5][6.7] Lobo
[4][4.3] Iron Man
[4][6.5] Genis-Vell
[4][5.7] Superboy Prime
[4][4.5] Kyle Rayner
[4][5.3] Sentry
[3][6] Loki
[3][4.7] Alan Scott
[3][6.5] Cyborg Superman
[3][5] Black Bolt
[3][7] Asgardian Destroyer
[3][1.5] Wolverine
[3][3] Boy Blue
[3][6.5] Sinestro
[3][8] Adam Warlock
[3][1] The Darkness
[3][6.7] Thing
[3][3.7] Aquaman
[3][2] Spider Jerusalem
[3][7.3] Walker
[2][8.5] Iron Fist
[2][1] Cyclops
[2][7] Martian Manhunter
[2][6.5] Powergirl
[2][7.5] Doomsday
[2][4] Dream of the Endless
[2][7.5] Tim Drake
[2][N/A] Nate Grey
[2][4] Cable
[2][5] Juggernaut
[2][7] Dick Grayson
[2][6.5] Venom
[2][5] Dr. Strange
[2][5.5] Rorscach
[2][6] Zeus
[2][2] Grifter
[2][3] Deadpool
[2][4.5] Ghost Rider
[2][3] Spawn
[2][2] Tyrant
[2][8] Sinister
[2][10] Squirrel Girl

^how many lists did hercules appear in?

other than mine

Originally posted by CosmicComet
^how many lists did hercules appear in?

other than mine

You were the only one

ahhhhhh

fear

That's actually pretty cool. I'd be pretty curious to see how our character preferences compare to those of the average comic reader, or really any large population size.

Kinda makes me want to go back and order my list for accuracy's sake.... meh.

i love how half of mine didn't make it.

Pretty cool cogito.