Black Lantern Kal-L vs Thor

Originally posted by Galan007
😂

Yes, quanchi. You ARE asking abhil to prove a negative. Thor cut Juggy off from his power source by negating all MYSTICAL energy in their vicinity. This was explicitly stated:

In truth, all Thor did was shut down Juggy's FF for a few seconds.

Anyway, unless you can show PROOF that Thor can negate non-mystical energies (more specifically, the Anti-Matter/Death energies that comprise the BLC), then him negating Kal's energy in this battle isn't even plausible.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Rings have a finite charge though hence the battery.

Yes, you did. Thor cutting someone off from their power source doesn't mean he can only do so if the character has a magical source of might unless you prove it.

Originally posted by Galan007
😂

Yes, quanchi. You ARE asking abhil to prove a negative. Thor cut Juggy off from his power source by negating all MYSTICAL energy in their vicinity. This was explicitly stated:

In truth, all Thor did was shut down Juggy's FF for a few seconds.

Anyway, unless you can show PROOF that Thor can negate non-mystical energies (more specifically, the Anti-Matter/Death energies that comprise the BLC), then him negating Kal's energy in this battle isn't even plausible.

.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I never even argued Thor would do so but the whole notion their charge is infinite and cannot be severed is absurd.

You're assuming Black Lantern rings work the same way as Green Lantern rings, which is absurd because they share so little in the way of anything other than being rings.

Green Lantern Rings create constructs, BL rings don't.
BL rings animate the dead, GL rings don't.
BL rings feed on emotion, GL rings are empowered by willpower.
GL rings have been shown to need recharging, BL rings haven't.
GL rings are powered by an abstract entity which represents willpower, BL rings are powered by the Anti-Monitor who represents nothing related to emotions.
etc etc.

They're totally different. The way they use power, or don't, is presumably totally different. You can't assume that a Black Lantern ring needs to be recharged, that it recharges the same way as a GL ring, or that the charge lasts for the same amount of time as a GL ring.

Come back with facts, not supposition and your best troll impersonation.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I never made such a claim.

My name is abhi, not abhil, dammit.
ranting

Whatever you say, ABHIL.

Originally posted by quanchi112
The cone negated all energy from entering the cone. The energy powering him was mystical that's why the word mystical was stated. Do you think the cone only prevents mystical energy or all energy from entering ? You can't be serious. I'm at a loss for words.

Originally posted by Cogito
You're assuming Black Lantern rings work the same way as Green Lantern rings, which is absurd because they share so little in the way of anything other than being rings.

Green Lantern Rings create constructs, BL rings don't.
BL rings animate the dead, GL rings don't.
BL rings feed on emotion, GL rings are empowered by willpower.
GL rings have been shown to need recharging, BL rings haven't.
GL rings are powered by an abstract entity which represents willpower, BL rings are powered by the Anti-Monitor who represents nothing related to emotions.
etc etc.

They're totally different. The way they use power, or don't, is presumably totally different. You can't assume that a Black Lantern ring needs to be recharged, that it recharges the same way as a GL ring, or that the charge lasts for the same amount of time as a GL ring.

Come back with facts, not supposition and your best troll impersonation.

Originally posted by quanchi112
The cone negated all energy from entering the cone. The energy powering him was mystical that's why the word mystical was stated. Do you think the cone only prevents mystical energy or all energy from entering ? You can't be serious. I'm at a loss for words.

It is not even alluded to that it negated every single type of energy across the board. Stop making shit up. You're blatantly trolling at this point.

Originally posted by abhilegend
😂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Then you agree the cone stops all energy from entering. This would effectively sever the connection.

Whatever you say, [B]ABHIL. [/B]

Originally posted by Galan007
Thor explicitly states that the cone would negate all MYSTICAL energy:

It is not even alluded to that it negated every single type of energy across the board. Stop making shit up. You're blatantly trolling at this point.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I never agreed on that too.
facepalm

Hey I have another idea for a battlezone when your laptop is working I'd consider waiting for Kal-l versus earth 22 Superman. Up for it ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Whatever power source he was connected to outside his own person was cut off hence mystical energy. I am not making anything up. If you feel that cone only stops mystical energy from entering I question your thought process. It's absurd.

Thor explicitly tells us the type of energy his cone negated. For you to ignore his statement and extrapolate it into "all" types of energy, is laughably idiotic.

Originally posted by quanchi112
It's the truth. Like his cones just prevent mystical energy from entering. That's ridiculous. In this instance they prevented mystical energy, abhil.

He even states that he sends his "enchanted Hammer" (bold) this and the word mystical are written extra bold, so it's obvious what the writers intent was. I mean, Thor is a mystical figure, an God with an mystical, enchanted Hammer. This might change over time but back then, the intent was clear.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Nice use of facepalm. I am glad you agree that cone prevents any energy power source from entering then.

Hey I have another idea for a battlezone when your laptop is working I'd consider waiting for Kal-l versus earth 22 Superman. Up for it ?

Originally posted by abhilegend

Originally posted by Galan007
Reported for trolling.

Thor explicitly tells us the type of energy his cone negated. For you to ignore his statement and extrapolate it into "all" types of energy, is laughably idiotic.

Originally posted by abhilegend
😂
Lulz, you think that I was serious on someone's typo of my name. This deserves a durquanchi for you.
durquanchi

My dur is very near and dear to my cold, black heart.

Originally posted by Galan007
Reported for trolling.

Thor explicitly tells us the type of energy his cone negated. For you to ignore his statement and extrapolate it into "all" types of energy, is laughably idiotic.

so to assume that same enchantment (that only lasted like 10 seconds) would shut down all of a BL's power is also pretty absurd on his part.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Seriously, galan you are such a child. Go ahead and tattle on someone for having a difference of opinion. The forums are dying as it is and you are part of the problem. You run and cry when someone disagrees with you and fully admit the boards are dying. Then call me idiotic in the same post. You won't ever man up and face me in a battlezone and will just hit the report to moderator button when someone disagrees with you. So grade school.

You're opting to ignore what the comics itself blatantly tells us, and are replacing it with your own conjecture instead. That, my friend, defines TROLLING. If you don't like the fact that I reported you, then I'd suggest you stop TROLLING... If you'd like to keep up with badgering posts like this, though, I'll have no problem reporting you again. I have no time for your BS these days. 🙂

Originally posted by john allerdyce
On top of this, thor's enchantment didn't even shut down all of juggernaut's powers, it just shut down his forcefield. he still had his mystically endowed strength, etc.

so to assume that same enchantment (that only lasted like 10 seconds) would shut down all of a BL's power is also pretty absurd on his part.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Seriously, galan you are such a child. Go ahead and tattle on someone for having a difference of opinion. The forums are dying as it is and you are part of the problem. You run and cry when someone disagrees with you and fully admit the boards are dying. Then call me idiotic in the same post. You won't ever man up and face me in a battlezone and will just hit the report to moderator button when someone disagrees with you. So grade school. Yes, I'm always super serious on the net. Sarcasm is a foreign language to myself.

My dur is very near and dear to my cold, black heart.