Movie Hulk(Avengers) vs Movie Thor

Started by The Sorrow61 pages

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Wasn't expecting it? Lol. Yeah who would expect a full on hit mid-fight? Lol

The hammer was nowhere to be seen until Thor summoned it at the last second, Hulk literally shrugged it off after a second or two that's very impressive.

If that was the case he wouldn't have moved.

It didn't cause Hulk to miss a beat. The punch barely hurt him which is accurate. The only significant strike Thor landed was with Mjolnir and that was shrugged off, his punch and knee to the face were shrugged off even quicker. The fight reminded of the Cap vs Loki fight in that Thor was clearly outmatched but showed heart and fought anyway.

And that's without Thor being able to fly around. If he only got in one good punch in such a confined space, what do you think would be his chances of getting in any hits when Thor's flying about and has the space to go all out.

Thor would need his other powers because based on his showings he has no chance of beating Hulk in a melee contest.

We've seen what Thor can do in an all out in his own film. The Lightning, the Tornadoes. Yeah Hulk barely felt a portion of Thor's power. Like it or not, that's fact and you know it.

Thor using all of his powers against Hulk would be a great fight, this was never disputed, by me at least. My gripe was how you lied to inflate Thor's feats.

No, because he barely got a touch on her. He was about to kill her until Thor saved her life by smacking Hulk through the wall.

He backhanded her into a solid wall a human being isn't surviving that with no damage. He wasn't intending to kill her, when he approached her he looked as though he was calming down until Thor rushed in.

Lol he frigging tried! His first punches Thor blocked. Other hits he completely dodged.

Hulk punching Thor =/= Trying to kill him. It's pretty obvious his uber punch later on in the film was > anything he had shown against Thor. He held back against Thor.

Not necessarily. He threw him out. That could have killed him. Pilot just got lucky.

Throwing the pilot out of ways harm with a parachute = trying to kill him? Lol. In fact looking at the scene again it seems as though Hulk goes out of his way to take down the jet without harming the pilot. He could as easily have thrown some type of debris through the aircraft like he normally does or smashed the cockpit rather than disable the jet piece by piece.

Well that might have just been luck. But let's assume your right. By that point he was away from the Hellicarrier, and considering he turned back to Banner soon after, shows Banner was probably gaining control back.

But he conveniently lost all influence when Thor attacked right? Smh.

Lol look whose talking. Im shocked you've completely missed that Loki was influencing him at that point. Missed the part where BW works out Loki's plan to influence Banner/Hulk. Missed the part where Banner was clearly the most influenced by the staff.

You read too much into that scene. Loki's plan was to unleash the Hulk because he's powerful and smashes sh*t. He did that via attacking the helicarrier, it's not as if he had Banner under a spell like Hawkeye or something. This somehow proves Hulk wasn't holding back? Lulz.

And most of all missed the completely obvious, which is that Banner controlled Hulk wouldn't attack Black Widow! LOL And put thousands of innocent at risk on the Hellicarrier for no reason LOL.

Moot point. This isn't Hulk with Banner's brain, everytime he transforms he puts innocents at risk.

No I believe Hulk TRIED his best to slice Thor in 2.

You believe Hulk tried to kill him by throwing the wing, I could just as easily say Thor tried to kill Hulk by attempting to choke him.

LOL First of all Hulk is stronger. Im not denying that. Loki is Thor's adopted brother. If you can't see he held back on Loki then your comprehension skills are beyond hope.

Loki stabbed him, has tried to kill him several times, betrayed Asgard, destroy Earth and yet Thor hasn't gone all out once? Bullshit. Maybe Thor didn't go for the kill but Hulk didn't kill him either just beat the utter sh*t out of him. Far easier than Thor ever has.

Iron man required a PIS 4* amp to even go toe to toe with Thor.
Lol. And even then Thor was crushing his armor arms with his bare hands. Lol

Iron Man was hurting Thor just as much after the "amp" as he was prior. It gave his armour more juice it didn't amp his strength or anything.

No he tried to resist changing but failed.

Lol he changed the first time due to Loki's influence. He didn't want to change at that point! Are you nuts? So what he Wanted to chase and hurt BW?? Banner wanted to Batter Thor?? And enganger the whole Hellicarrier?! Don't be ridiculous!


He has limited influence over the Hulk, he may be angry and smash things but behind the-scenes Banner stops the Hulk from going completely ape-shit and killing everyone.

^ Sorrow I don't think we have an issue.

I never meant to imply Thor has a chance in a Melee. And you've agreed Thor hasn't unleashed his full powers on Hulk, so the outcome of an all out is undecided. And I'm fine with that.

In the all out I'm a Thor fan so will always support Thor. While you will always support Hulk. And that's fine.

I have a problem with people who claim it was said and shown and proven in the film that Hulk was more powerful. That's simply not true.

Originally posted by carver9
I don't get it...why can't I say Hulk held back when people are saying Thor held back the entire movie? Doesn't make sense to me. Hulk held back his powa.

@Nib

Read this post and tell me what you are getting from it.

Originally posted by carver9
@Nib

Read this post and tell me what you are getting from it.

I get that you're a troll. Thor was obviously holding back during the Hulk fight.

Originally posted by carver9
@Nib

Read this post and tell me what you are getting from it.

I'm getting that you either have very low comprehension skills, or are just f***ing with everyone.

I've read the entire thread 😮 , and honestly can't tell.

Oh, and if you are just messing with everyone, you sure do go through a lot of trouble, and a sh*t load of making yourself look bad, to do so.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
@Carver:

I don't like to accuse you of trolling, bro, but you can't be serious!

The Berserk Hulk who was being controlled by Loki was holding back?

How does one even come to that conclusion???

Lol

Loki's spear had the mind gem in it, he was using it to manipulate Banner/Hulk which is why Banner was randomly grabbing the spear in the middle of his rant.

My only real gripe with the movie portrayals was that Thor held back against Iron Man, Hulk and Loki. He never had a chance to really cut loose till that lightning bolt at the end. Which made him seem a bit weaker than he did in the Thor movie. Held back against Hulk because he didnt want to fight and ruin the ship, held back against Loki because he was too concerned with trying to turn him back good. When he wanted too he manhandled Loki almost as easily as Hulk did.

That said movie Hulk would win. Unless Thor starts using those blasts from his movie then I'm not sure what happens.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Throwing the pilot [B]out of ways harm with a parachute = trying to kill him? Lol. In fact looking at the scene again it seems as though Hulk goes out of his way to take down the jet without harming the pilot. [/B]

The pilots ejection seat didn't malfunction, IIRC. It worked, but then Hulk caught it, shook it, and then tossed it away. Then he proceeds to continue ripping into the jet until it explodes.

Originally posted by lft4ded
The pilots ejection seat didn't malfunction, IIRC. It worked, but then Hulk caught it, shook it, and then tossed it away. Then he proceeds to continue ripping into the jet until it explodes.

👆 I think Hulk has this passive power that makes some people twist shit left and right to make him look good. Like he even needs that shit to look good.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
👆 I think Hulk has this passive power that makes some people twist shit left and right to make him look good. Like he even needs that shit to look good.

QFT

Trust Carter to make this shit up.

To anyone who watched the movie Thor wasnt trying only stop/calm down Banner, Hulk was raging trying to kill Thor

If Thor cut loose. the fight would end in one or 2 shots.

Originally posted by TheBadguy
Loki's spear had the mind gem in it, he was using it to manipulate Banner/Hulk which is why Banner was randomly grabbing the spear in the middle of his rant.

My only real gripe with the movie portrayals was that Thor held back against Iron Man, Hulk and Loki. He never had a chance to really cut loose till that lightning bolt at the end. Which made him seem a bit weaker than he did in the Thor movie. Held back against Hulk because he didnt want to fight and ruin the ship, held back against Loki because he was too concerned with trying to turn him back good. When he wanted too he manhandled Loki almost as easily as Hulk did.

That said movie Hulk would win. Unless Thor starts using those blasts from his movie then I'm not sure what happens.

Originally posted by TheBadguy
Loki's spear had the mind gem in it, he was using it to manipulate Banner/Hulk which is why Banner was randomly grabbing the spear in the middle of his rant.

My only real gripe with the movie portrayals was that Thor held back against Iron Man, Hulk and Loki. He never had a chance to really cut loose till that lightning bolt at the end. Which made him seem a bit weaker than he did in the Thor movie. Held back against Hulk because he didnt want to fight and ruin the ship, held back against Loki because he was too concerned with trying to turn him back good. When he wanted too he manhandled Loki almost as easily as Hulk did.

That said movie Hulk would win. Unless Thor starts using those blasts from his movie then I'm not sure what happens.

Hulk held back as well. Ironman also held back.

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk held back as well. Ironman also held back.

Neither held back, in fact Iron-man was boosted to 475%

I went with 13 friends to see the movie opening night. When I met up with some of them the next morning, one of my good friends (who likes comics a lot, but doesn't necessarily read too many of them) opened up the conversation with:

"Huh... Thor really is the most powerful, isn't he?"

Originally posted by Existere
"Huh... Thor really is the most powerful, isn't he?"
Originally posted by Silent Master
Neither held back, in fact Iron-man was boosted to 475%

If I want to say somebody held back, I can. Fury held back against Loki as well...held back through the entire movie.

Originally posted by carver9
If I want to say somebody held back, I can. Fury held back against Loki as well...held back through the entire movie.

Carver, stop being butthurt.

Hulk would shrug off anything thor has to offer

Originally posted by carver9
If I want to say somebody held back, I can. Fury held back against Loki as well...held back through the entire movie.

Neither the Hulk or Iron-man was holding back.