Originally posted by Starscream MExcept that is what I said the first time around.
if you said thats how you remembered it, thats one thing. saying you feel it seems wrong to me...its too wishy washy.if you remembered thor giving hulk a bloody nose, then fine, I'll go rewatch and see if I can confirm
Originally posted by Newjak
And maybe I'm remembering it wrong but I swear Thor gave Hulk a bloody nose when he bashed him into the plane.
Originally posted by Mindset
How does it matter if it happened in the 70's?As a general rule? You mentioned one movie, I countered. You lost.
I constantly overestimate your ability to comprehend the obvious. I need to stop doing that. The 70s. People were less knowledgeable all around. No internet for quick references after all. Hell, that goes for Silver Age comics versus Modern as well. Writers are more knowledgeable and attempt to portray that in their stories.
Hence the difference between Superman 1 and, you know, Returns.
Yes, as a general rule. Which is redundant, because that's what 'as a rule' means in the first place. I was just trying to dumb it down for you.
Originally posted by CosmicCometLol, so in the 70's people thought that someone flying around the Earth at lightspeed and turning back time was completely logical?
I constantly overestimate your ability to comprehend the obvious. I need to stop doing that. The 70s. People were less knowledgeable all around. No internet for quick references after all. Hell, that goes for Silver Age comics versus Modern as well. Writers are more knowledgeable and attempt to portray that in their stories.Hence the difference between Superman 1 and, you know, Returns.
Yes, as a general rule. Which is redundant, because that's what 'as a rule' means in the first place. I was just trying to dumb it down for you.
You're a dunce.
Comics now make about as much sense as Silver Age, now they just skew physics to make them seem "realistic".
Originally posted by Mindset
Lol, so in the 70's people thought that someone flying around the Earth at lightspeed and turning back time was completely logical?You're a dunce.
Comics now make about as much sense as Silver Age, now they just skew physics to make them seem "realistic".
Maybe, maybe not. Don't know the writer personally. I was referring to the feats in general, Superman could save a falling plane a lot easier as Christoper Reeves than he could as Routh, even if they are the same character in continuity.
Why? Greater attention to physics.
As always Mindset, you are always a step behind. But you're funny, so you're excusable.
And exactly, attempts, as I said.
Now, tell me what you think of Thor hitting the ground? That's the only thing I care about out of this tangent.
Originally posted by CosmicCometYou don't know much. Superman had trouble saving a falling plane. Superman then lifting a island sized piece of rock and tossed it into space without it completely breaking apart. SO realistic, I'm glad we live in an age where comic movies adhere to physics.
Maybe, maybe not. Don't know the writer personally. I was referring to the feats in general, Superman could save a falling plane a lot easier as Christoper Reeves than he could as Routh, even if they are the same character in continuity.Why? Greater attention to physics.
As always Mindset, you are always a step behind. But you're funny, so you're excusable.
And exactly, attempts, as I said.
Now, tell me what you think of Thor hitting the ground? That's the only thing I care about out of this tangent.
You have nothing but mediocre insults because you're wrong.
Originally posted by MindsetTo be fair the Island was made of K-Nite so it may have been able to not break apart while if you watch the the little rock shield Superman used was breaking apart.
You don't know much. Superman had trouble saving a falling plane. Superman then lifting a island sized piece of rock and tossed it into space without it completely breaking apart. SO realistic, I'm glad we live in an age where comic movies adhere to physics.You have nothing but mediocre insults because you're wrong.
So it could have been more realistic then you're giving it credit for.
Originally posted by Mindset
You don't know much. Superman had trouble saving a falling plane. Superman then lifting a island sized piece of rock and tossed it into space without it completely breaking apart. SO realistic, I'm glad we live in an age where comic movies adhere to physics.You have nothing but mediocre insults because you're wrong.
Poor Mindset, always fails to see the bigger, general picture of a statement so tries to retort with holes that were obvious to anyone in the first place. I blame this stemming off the fact that you probably didn't know what 'as a rule' meant. The rock was breaking apart, actually, so still more realistic than similar things he did in Superman 1, like move tectonic plates.
My insults always seem to rile you up, since you're always wrong whenever you've attempted to address me. 🙂
I ask again, what, do you think of Thor hitting the ground? That is the only thing I wish to know.
Originally posted by NewjakK-nite never showed any kind of super durability. In fact, iirc, it broke like regular rocks.
To be fair the Island was made of K-Nite so it may have been able to not break apart while if you watch the the little rock shield Superman used was breaking apart.So it could have been more realistic then you're giving it credit for.
Superman needed to reach escape velocity in order to get it out of Earth's orbit.
Originally posted by MindsetExcuse me it was crystal mixed/given K-Nite properties. That is what I meant.
K-nite never showed any kind of super durability. In fact, iirc, it broke like regular rocks.Superman needed to reach escape velocity in order to get it out of Earth's orbit.
So it may have been more durable than normal rock.
Originally posted by Mindset
Lol, so in the 70's people thought that someone flying around the Earth at lightspeed and turning back time was completely logical?You're a dunce.
Comics now make about as much sense as Silver Age, now they just skew physics to make them seem "realistic".
Originally posted by CosmicCometThe rock was barely breaking apart, it was still the size of an island when he pushed it out of orbit. As a general rule it would have to, you know, be a general rule, i.e. show that for the majority of instances the laws of physics are adhered to...which is obviously not the case. For example, as a general rule, it's best not to listen to you because you don't know what you're talking about.
Poor Mindset, always fails to see the bigger, general picture of a statement so tries to retort with holes that were obvious to anyone in the first place. I blame this stemming off the fact that you probably didn't know what 'as a rule' meant. The rock was breaking apart, actually, so still more realistic than similar things he did in Superman 1, like move tectonic plates.My insults always seem to riled you up, since you're always wrong whenever you've attempted to address me. 🙂
I ask again, what, do you think of Thor hitting the ground? That is the only thing I wish to know.
If you want to think I'm rile up that's ok, you're still wrong.
He hit the ground at a slower speed than Hulk did.
Originally posted by MindsetYou mean where he hit a few skinny pieces?
And it was breaking like regular rock.Look at the fight scene when they were kicking Supes ass.
Do you think if Superman lifted the Fortress of Solitude into the air it would be weak enough to break apart in the way you are describing?
Originally posted by Newjak
You mean where he hit a few skinny pieces?Do you think if Superman lifted the Fortress of Solitude into the air it would be weak enough to break apart in the way you are describing?
What do you want me to say?