Captain America in a Throw Down Gauntlet

He recovers to full strength after each fight.

Fist Fight, no gadgets.

1. Ozymandias
2. Daredevil
3. Batman
4. Luke Cage
5. Spiderman

Bump

1. Cap
2. Cap
3. Cap
4. Dies
5. Dies

Originally posted by Kid Kurdy
1. Cap
2. Cap
3. Cap
4. Dies
5. Dies

Originally posted by SouthSpawn
He recovers to full strength after each fight.

Fist Fight, no gadgets.

1. Ozymandias
2. Daredevil
3. Batman
4. Luke Cage
5. Spiderman

1. Good fight either split or Cap slightly.
2. Daredevil
3. Cap
4. Luke
5. Spidey

Originally posted by Brockalizer
I'm not convinced that he couldn't beat Spiderman though. IMO Cage should be #5 and Spidey should be #4.

Then you are crazy. Because 2 CA with their shields couldn't beat Spidey using the full capacity rule.

Cap here is not only solo but doesn't have his shield.

1. Ozymandias
2. Cap
3. split
4. Luke
5. Spidey

Originally posted by Magnon
1. Ozymandias
2. Cap
3. split
4. Luke
5. Spidey

I can go with this but I think Cap beats Bats because of greater stamina, greater strength (not by much though), and about equal skill.

With gadgets Bats would own Cap though.

...Ozymandias would get his ass kicked.

Originally posted by h1a8
Then you are crazy. Because 2 CA with their shields couldn't beat Spidey using the full capacity rule.

Cap here is not only solo but doesn't have his shield.

Originally posted by Brockalizer
The only reason I picked Cap over Spidey is because Captain America has forgotten more about digging deep and overcoming tredendous odds than Spiderman will ever know.

That will be a great comfort to him when he awakens form his coma.

Originally posted by SouthSpawn
He recovers to full strength after each fight.

Fist Fight, no gadgets.

1. Ozymandias
2. Daredevil
3. Batman
4. Luke Cage
5. Spiderman

Stops at 2.

You should have put in Panther over Ozy, or at least someone good like
Batroc.

Originally posted by cdtm
Stops at 2.

facepalm

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
facepalm

The "altered heartbeat" thing is hit or miss, as his radar sense worked fine on Cap at one point, yet had problems at others. I'm assuming it should work fine on him now..

But if it doesn't, than it stops at 3. 😛

Originally posted by cdtm
The "altered heartbeat" thing is hit or miss, as his radar sense worked fine on Cap at one point, yet had problems at others. I'm assuming it should work fine on him now..

But if it doesn't, than it stops at 3. 😛

DD's radar sense works on Cap. His Batgirl + move reading abilities don't (similar to how Batgirl's don't work on Deathstroke).

Captain America rails through both Matt and Bruce, but DD does better.

Srank is still hating on batman.mmm

Originally posted by abhilegend
Srank is still hating on batman.mmm

Batman love is for fake comic fans, this forum is for people who read comics. Feel free to take your Batsurbation to tumblr where the hipsters who pretend to like comics reside. 😎

Spider-Man could stop Captain America's throw before he could get the shield out of his hand.

Eh, it's not unrealistic that DD takes Cap with no shield. DD is quite strong, as skilled, and significantly faster. He's also much less durable. Since DD has, by far, the best reflexes of any street I can think of:

1. Cap
2. Split
3. Cap
4. Cap/split (Luke is not immune to nerve strikes)
5. Dies

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Batman love is for fake comic fans, this forum is for people who read comics. Feel free to take your Batsurbation to tumblr where the hipsters who pretend to like comics reside. 😎