Marvel Elite Herald Team vs DC Elite Herald Team

Marvel:

1) Thor

2) Silver Surfer

3) Beta Ray Bill

4) Gladiator

5) X-Man

DC(Pre-Flashpoint):

1) Captain Marvel

2) Green Lantern (Hal)

3) Martian Manhunter

4) Wonder Woman

5) Superman (No Red Sun or K-Nite Weakness)

Location: Uninhabited Earth like Planet.

Marvel team is a bit superior.

Funny that supes is the only one who needs his weaknesses removed 😛

Considering Kryptonite from other universe doesn't affect him anyway, and the Marvel team wouldn't even know about them anyway, I don't think he needs them removed. Also, it's funny whenever there's a Superman vs X debate, everyone always brings up kryptonite or red solar radiation, like they couldn't beat him without it. Enough of that rant anyway.

Captain Marvel vs Thor could go either way, but edge to Thor.

Edge to SS vs Hal

MMH completely owns Beta Ray Bill

Wonder Woman beats Gladiator quite handily

Superman will take down X-man.

I'm going to go with DC on this.

(oh, and what about Gladiator's weakness?)

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
Considering Kryptonite from other universe doesn't affect him anyway, and the Marvel team wouldn't even know about them anyway, I don't think he needs them removed. Also, it's funny whenever there's a Superman vs X debate, everyone always brings up kryptonite or red solar radiation, like they couldn't beat him without it. Enough of that rant anyway.

Captain Marvel vs Thor could go either way, but edge to Thor.

Edge to SS vs Hal

MMH completely owns Beta Ray Bill

Wonder Woman beats Gladiator quite handily

Superman will take down X-man.

I'm going to go with DC on this.

(oh, and what about Gladiator's weakness?)

Don't think anyone here can affect glads physically to cause him to weaken himself psionically.

But whatever, as for the fight team 1. Too much diversity and comparable strengths. Good fight mainly because team 2 already has good team work (then again Hammer bros and Glads+ surfer have fought along side a many times as well).

Originally posted by Newjak
Didn't think about Glads weakness but I guess we'll remove it to, he won't lose confidence.

He also has some sort of radiation that weakens him.

Where's Hulk??

Originally posted by byrdgang21
Where's Hulk??

Disneyland

Originally posted by byrdgang21
Where's Hulk??

Originally posted by Newjak
Marvel Elite Herald Team

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
He also has some sort of radiation that weakens him.

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
Considering Kryptonite from other universe doesn't affect him anyway, and the Marvel team wouldn't even know about them anyway, I don't think he needs them removed. Also, it's funny whenever there's a Superman vs X debate, everyone always brings up kryptonite or red solar radiation, like they couldn't beat him without it. Enough of that rant anyway.

Captain Marvel vs Thor could go either way, but edge to Thor.

Edge to SS vs Hal

MMH completely owns Beta Ray Bill

Wonder Woman beats Gladiator quite handily

Superman will take down X-man.

I'm going to go with DC on this.

(oh, and what about Gladiator's weakness?)

Hal vs. Norrin could go either way, but other than that I completely agree with everything you've posted. People always bring up Superman's weakness, but forget that Thor is a sloth, Silver Surfer has a glass jaw, Gladiator lacks balls, Beta Ray Bill looses because he's ugly and X-man isn't Wolverine. 😛

Team 1 needs less Gladiator.

how does supes take out shaman x-man? he can function as pure energy and he has monster tp. mm or gl would be better match ups vs nate....nate vs mm's tp would be interesting.

Just to clarify this isn't a series of one on one battles, it seemed like a couple of people were treating it like on, this is a team battle where everyone is fighting at the same time.

What about supes magic weakness?

Originally posted by pym-ftw
What about supes magic weakness?

If I took Supes Magic 'weakness' away then I would take away Glads/Thor/Green Lantern/Wonder Woman's telepathy 'weakness'.

To me there's a difference between a weakness that takes away your powers and a type of attack you're just not being particularly suited against like magic/telepathy/or other types of energy attacks or physical attacks to.

So I'm not making Superman immune to magic.

Originally posted by Newjak
Just to clarify this isn't a series of one on one battles, it seemed like a couple of people were treating it like on, this is a team battle where everyone is fighting at the same time.

I realized that, it was just one way to break down the battles for me.

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
I realized that, it was just one way to break down the battles for me.

One other big advantage DC has hear is MMH. He can and has mentally coordinated the DC team's attacks, making them a much more coherent team.

as always gladiator the weak link 🙄