Superman vs Thor (punching contest)

Started by keiththegreat20 pages

Superman vs Thor (punching contest)

Here's the setup:

Thor is chained by unbreakable bounds. How many punches does Superman need to deliver to KO him? (Superman is not holding back, and is willing to kill him).

Next, same situation but reverse the places of the heroes.

Third scenario is same as the second, except now Thor uses his hammer (for hitting only, no lightning).

Who KO's the other one faster, and how many punches do you think it will take?

1) Superman only needs one

2) Thor would need a few but probably less than five

3) I can see Thor one shotting him here but not 100% sure

Originally posted by juggerman
1) Superman only needs one

2) Thor would need a few but probably less than five

3) I can see Thor one shotting him here but not 100% sure

I'm 100% sure Thor is not one-shotting Superman with the hammer. I also don't think Superman is one-shotting Thor either. Superman definitely KO's Thor faster than Thor does Superman, by how much I'd have to think about it.

both guys can take punches from beings stronger than each of them, thor took punches from kurse like a champ while superman took darkseid and doomsday punishment like a champ, no one is one shotting the other here, by punching power i think superman has a slight edge, if we add mjolnir thor has the edge

This scenario is hard to gauge, it's one thing to take punches while you can move around and roll, less en the impact.

It's another to shit there and take a well-measured punch of that magnitude of power.

Of course these guys are extremely durable and can take a beating as well.

I'll say this though I think

Thor w/ Hammer > Superman Punch > Thor Punch

With Thor and Supes just standing there fully taking a 100% full force no holding back punch from eachother im pretty sure we'd see some one hit KOs.

They both usually hold back tremendously and still completely wreck sh!t. If they cut loose im sure they could one shot eachother.

Thor w/ Hammer > Superman Punch > Thor Punch

Probably this

Originally posted by Newjak
Thor w/ Hammer > Superman Punch > Thor Punch
Originally posted by Newjak

Thor w/ Hammer > Superman Punch > Thor Punch

Same here.

IMO Superman's punch, without holding back, is at least as powerful as a Mjolnir strike (w/o holding back)

IMO Superman's punch, without holding back, is at least as powerful as a Mjolnir strike (w/o holding back)

im actually quite conflicted here

Originally posted by Newjak
Thor w/ Hammer > Superman Punch > Thor Punch

Thor with Mjlonir>Superman punch=Thor Punch

Originally posted by carver9
Thor with Mjlonir>Superman punch=Thor Punch

No carv.
Thor can't punch as hard Superman, this is a fact. He may be able to hit harder than Superman with Mjolnir though (only through whirling slams though). But a non holding back Superman may almost equal him or probably surpass him.
IMO
A non holding back Superman punch > or = A mjolnir whirling two hand slam> A Thor two hand downward slam>a Typical Superman punch> or = a typical Thor one hand side swing> a typical Thor punch.

Originally posted by Newjak

Thor w/ Hammer > Superman Punch > Thor Punch

Superman punch >= Thor w/ hammer >>> Thor punch

Get at me.

I've never seen Thor do anything with his hammer (striking-wise) that comes close to Superman's fists, especially when he's not holding back. Thor's durability is also far lower than Superman's. Even with hammer, Superman will KO thor faster.

Originally posted by Cogito
IMO Superman's punch, without holding back, is at least as powerful as a Mjolnir strike (w/o holding back)

It's possible imo, but it's very close.

He broke Exitars armor which is an incredible feat that I doubt Superman could dupilcate with his fist

Thor w/ Hammer >>>>>> Superman Punch = Thor Punch

DCnU superman doesn't have the feats to justify this thread