Superman vs Thor (punching contest)

Originally posted by abhilegend
It was midnighter.
Yeah it is. The dreamt up version of DC heroes were based upon the memories of majestic when he was in DCU.

Maj didn't meet a lot of those characters though. Doomsday, for example. Certainly not the Legion of Super Heroes.

They were created from this big cosmic book, and the constructs had memories of events like the LOSH dealing with the Sun Eater. IMO, that should make the characters pretty accurate renditions..

Like the man said, "They're as real as we are".

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Oh. so you're saying a made up from scratch Superman that isn't actually Superman that can one shot Majestic?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Heh, it didn't even need the real superman. I was just referencing that fight as to show that being not able to roll with punches can be a very important factor in this fight.

Might as well have used Cap rolling with punches.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
No. They knew they couldn't justify real Superman doing that to Maj.

Might as well have used Cap rolling with punches.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Oh. so you're saying a made up from scratch Superman that isn't actually Superman that can one shot Majestic?

It's more complicated than that..

Basically, a kid who was once considered as the next Doctor, gained access to a library that houses the books of all dreams from all dreamers. Normally, the only people who access this library are people at the moment of death, when they see their life flash before their eyes, said flashing being the collection of dreams they stored up over their lifetimes..

According to a group of past Doctors, dreams are more accurate than memories...

So, using these dreams, this kid recreated the JLA, Titans, and even the Legion of Super Heroes.. And, these constructs personality and memories of events reflected their real life counterparts, at different points in their lives (Superman, for example, was created from a point before he met Doomsday, and had no idea who he was when the kid created a Doomsday..)

So I, personally, think the kid was plucking dreams right out of the heads of the characters he was creating, in addition to dreams of people who saw or interacted with them. No one present in that story could have dreams of all the characters involved, not to mention some of the events those characters remembered from their personal lives..

So it's the only explanation that makes sense..

I'd guess they're no less real than an Elseworlds version of each character, given the sources used to create them..

Originally posted by cdtm
It's more complicated than that..

Basically, a kid who was once considered as the next Doctor, gained access to a library that houses the books of all dreams from all dreamers. Normally, the only people who access this library are people at the moment of death, when they see their life flash before their eyes, said flashing being the collection of dreams they stored up over their lifetimes..

According to a group of past Doctors, dreams are more accurate than memories...

So, using these dreams, this kid recreated the JLA, Titans, and even the Legion of Super Heroes.. And, these constructs personality and memories of events reflected their real life counterparts, at different points in their lives (Superman, for example, was created from a point before he met Doomsday, and had no idea who he was when the kid created a Doomsday..)

So I, personally, think the kid was plucking dreams right out of the heads of the characters he was creating, in addition to dreams of people who saw or interacted with them. No one present in that story could have dreams of all the characters involved, not to mention some of the events those characters remembered from their personal lives..

So it's the only explanation that makes sense..

I'd guess they're no less real than an Elseworlds version of each character, given the sources used to create them..

He even stated the book was from a different world.

It was also heavily implied at the end that everyone was sleeping the whole time. The DC characters were confirmed constructs, and it showed a ton of Wildstorm characters waking up after Chimera was woken up.

It's really not proof of anything other than the contrast of Wildstorm's actions and the regular universe's.

If we want to start taking it at face value, we might as well state that Dr Fate can be killed by Grifter's basic attacks. And Batman jams batarangs into eyes, and stabs bitches, and can somehow get killed by being decapitated, which I can't stress enough isn't possible.

It certainly isn't fuel for debate, considering the DC characters weren't even real.

Well, like I said, it's just my opinion. Not proof of anything..

The actions of the Batman in that story would make a lot more sense if it was The Goddamned Batman though. I could totally see that Batman stabbing eyes out with battarangs..

Originally posted by cdtm
Well, like I said, it's just my opinion. Not proof of anything..

The actions of the Batman in that story would make a lot more sense if it was The Goddamned Batman though. I could totally see that Batman stabbing eyes out with battarangs..

Superman not holding back will knock out Thor with one punch.

Watch Superman vs The Elite for reference.

lol