DCNU Superman vs AvX Thor

Started by carver910 pages
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I'm telling you that Thor's showings against the Force was the best out of all the other Avengers present.

I agree but none of them was on Thor, let alone Gladiator level. Them living from the attack and not being near death is proof enough to me that Gladiator would have withstood those attacks as well.

lol "Gladiator level".

Originally posted by -Pr-
That's what the thread is supposed to be about, so are you admitting to being off topic?

Uuummm, I am agreeing with you and since you posted what you said, I am changing my stance on this battle.

What in the hell. 😘

Originally posted by -Pr-
lol "Gladiator level".

Don't see what the "lol" was for.

Originally posted by carver9
Uuummm, I am agreeing with you and since you posted what you said, I am changing my stance on this battle.

What in the hell. 😘

What?

Originally posted by carver9
Don't see what the "lol" was for.

Yes you do, but that's the funny part.

Originally posted by carver9
I agree but none of them was on Thor, let alone Gladiator level. Them living from the attack and not being near death is proof enough to me that Gladiator would have withstood those attacks as well.

None of this makes sense.

Thor enduring the Force and suffering minor burns which he fully healed from and dealing damage to the Force > getting attacked by the P5 and being beaten into a coma without doing anything effective.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
None of this makes sense.

Thor enduring the Force and suffering minor burns which he fully healed from and dealing damage to the Force > getting attacked by the P5 and being beaten into a coma without doing anything effective.

Mjlonir damaging the force has nothing to do with Thors durability. Another thing, Thor wasn't the only person who lived after an attack from Phoenix. What's so hard to comprehend?

Thor would be saved a lot of face if it was revealed later that he never properly healed from the initial Phoenix encounter.

Funny enough, him 'clipping its wings', was the most impressive he's looked in a long time, and that was right near the start of this event.

After that has been a rocket propelled roller coaster downward, with the track possibly broken at the end of it.

Originally posted by -Pr-
What?

Yes you do, but that's the funny part.

Pr...I agreed with you and respected your post. Don't get why we are debating this? Reason why I said "what in the hell". Also the reason I did this...
😘

You underestimate Gladiator like you always do. Recognize his power.

Originally posted by carver9
Mjlonir damaging the force has nothing to do with Thors durability. Another thing, Thor wasn't the only person who lived after an attack from Phoenix. What's so hard to comprehend?

barker

Why is whenever Gladiator gets involved in a thread, you get all thick headed and impervious to logic?

Thor engaged the Phoenix and clearly fared better than his peers, which is a durability feat. He also managed to clip its wing, which is an offensive feat. Thor's showings against the Phoenix Force trump his fellow Avengers and is better than facing Phoenix Force hosts and being beaten into a near death state.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
barker

Why is whenever Gladiator gets involved in a thread, you get all thick headed and impervious to logic?

Thor engaged the Phoenix and clearly fared better than his peers, which is a durability feat. He also managed to clip its wing, which is an offensive feat. Thor's showings against the Phoenix Force trump his fellow Avengers and is better than facing Phoenix Force hosts and being beaten into a near death state.

What other person out there was High Herald minus Thor? I'll be waiting.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Thor would be saved a lot of face if it was revealed later that he never properly healed from the initial Phoenix encounter.

Funny enough, him 'clipping its wings', was the most impressive he's looked in a long time, and that was right near the start of this event.

After that has been a rocket propelled roller coaster downward, with the track possibly broken at the end of it.

Not sure how that is the best he's looked in a long time...?

Guy had great feats in Fear Itself and his solo ongoing.

Unless you mean solely through this event.

Originally posted by carver9
What other person out there was High Herald minus Thor? I'll be waiting.

What the hell does this post even mean?

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Not sure how that is the best he's looked in a long time...?

Guy had great feats in Fear Itself and his solo ongoing.

Unless you mean solely through this event.

Yes, in this event, and leading up to it a little before.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
What the hell does this post even mean?

In your post you said Thor withstood an attack from the Phoenix better than his peers. What person out there was Thor peer?

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Yes, in this event, and leading up to it a little before.

The times he's not looked good in this event is due to being outclassed by the Phoenix Force and its hosts, which isn't a bad thing. It just speaks to their power level.

Before AvX started, Thor took on two amped versions of Hulk and Thing while injured and beat them, fought the Demogorge and brought himself back to life, crushed an amped Ulik the fastest he's even done, and had his mettle tested in a cosmic brawl with the likes of Galactus, the Other, and Scrier.

Really, the only blemishes on Thor's record recently would be AvX (in which the opposition is clearly just more powerful than he is, not that he's somehow weaker than normally) and Avengers Assemble, which is a train wreck operated by Conductor Bendis.

Originally posted by carver9
In your post you said Thor withstood an attack from the Phoenix better than his peers. What person out there was Thor peer?

Peers as in his teammates (ie. fellow Avengers) not peers in power level.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Peers as in his teammates (ie. fellow Avengers) not peers in power level.

Lol...Jake, the people that was out there, of course Thor would withstand the attack better. What I am telling you is, if Ironman, Ms. Marvel, Captain Brittain can live from an attack from the Phoenix and be up in the same comic to fight the Phoenix again, why can't Gladiator, someone who swam in a Gas giant, someone who take baths in stars, someone who withstood a solar system destroying blast, NOT be up to tackle the Phoenix like Thor did (probably better)?

Originally posted by carver9
Pr...I agreed with you and respected your post. Don't get why we are debating this? Reason why I said "what in the hell". Also the reason I did this...
😘

You underestimate Gladiator like you always do. Recognize his power.

I could say the same to you, just in terms of overstatement, as usual.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...Jake, the people that was out there, of course Thor would withstand the attack better. What I am telling you is, if Ironman, Ms. Marvel, Captain Brittain can live from an attack from the Phoenix and be up in the same comic to fight the Phoenix again, why can't Gladiator, someone who swam in a Gas giant, someone who take baths in stars, someone who withstood a solar system destroying blast NOT be up to tackle the Phoenix like Thor did (probably better)?

Because if you want to go that route and list all the stuff Gladiator took and endured, the feats Thor has trumps his by far. facepalm

Christ, man.